Italian Restaurants in Port St. Lucie

Chef Luca Fontanarosa’s fine-dining room champions “purist” Italian cooking—think regional dishes, pristine ingredients, and attentive, owner-on-the-floor hospitality. Frequently praised by diners and highlighted among top local Italian options by national roundups, reservations are wise.

Run by Vincenzo and family, this dinner-only spot leans Northern and Southern Italian with polished service and a serious wine list. Well reviewed by travelers and locals alike; the adjacent Casa Vincenzo Pizzeria expands the team’s old-country obsession to pies.

A PGA Village favorite for years, Tutto Fresco blends Sicilian family recipes with broader Italian classics, plus a lively bar and patio. It consistently earns strong OpenTable ratings and remains a go-to for celebrations and groups.

In Tradition Square, Pastaio showcases fresh, handmade pasta you can watch being shaped, alongside pizza and cocktails. Noted by local and national dining platforms for craft and consistency, it’s a modern Italian hangout with real technique behind it.

Family-run for decades, Ruffino’s is classic Port St. Lucie red-sauce culture: generous portions, nightly specials, and a community of regulars. Frequently cited by local guides and review platforms as a reliable favorite for traditional plates.

A true family affair with roots in Sicily and near Naples, LaMattina’s serves hand-tossed pies, pastas, and fun signatures like the garlic Knotwich. Covered by regional media and warmly reviewed by locals; it’s a rising Torino-area favorite.

A longstanding, family-operated spot for pizza, subs, and pastas, Da Vinci’s is valued for reasonable prices, friendly service, and dependable red-sauce fare. Popular with locals and frequently recommended on citywide roundups.

Independent since 2012, Tavola pairs hand-tossed pies and creative toppings with a Florida craft-beer list and surf-shop spirit. Local write-ups and review sites consistently praise its community presence and quality dough work.

A St. Lucie West staple for hearty pasta dinners, personal pies, and family-friendly service. Recent reviews and ordering platforms confirm steady hours and a loyal neighborhood following; expect big portions and straight-ahead flavors.

Part deli, part Italian pantry, this local favorite turns out Bronx-to-Brooklyn–style heroes, fresh mozzarella, and prepared foods. Featured by regional food writers and loved by locals for generous, quality-filled sandwiches and market finds.