Little Pie Company

Amazing staff and terrific service. The staff was great and very knowledgeable. Got the pumpkin and sour cream apple walnut pie! Warm them up in the oven. 10/10 will definitely return!

OMG sooooooo good! This is one of the best pecan pies I’ve ever had in my life. It had just the the right amount of sweetness and an insane amount of pecans. As you can see I couldn’t even get a picture before eating it!

What a lovely little store! I got the tri-berry pie on the recommendation there as well as the hard/impossible-to-find Mississippi Mud Pie. Absolutely delicious, cute presentation. Would definitely go back and recommend to pie-enthusiasts.

Desserts are good but pricey for the portions. Best macchiato. When you step in you’re greeted with the sweet smell of pie. Also tried the sour Apple walnut pie, which is supposed to be a favorite, but was not blown away. The atmosphere is clean, and the staff was very friendly.

so good. old fashioned apple - not too sugary and the tartness of the apple and cinnamon comes through sour cream apple walnut - a little more sweet but definitely not overpowered and sour cream and walnut balance out the flavor strawberry rhubarb - tart and sour and loved it. I especially loved the pie crust basket weave on the top. the bakers / check out people are really sweet and warmed up our pies to enjoy right there!

I really wanted to love it. Even with the prices I wanted to love it. But the pies were...barely filled with filling. The flavor was great, the pie was done exceptionally well, but there were...maybe 10cherries in the pie? The rest was gelatinized juice. For the price, I want a full proper pie. Please. A store dedicated to pies should not have this issue.

Sat outside at the outdoor zone. The cherry pie was a great size not too sweet with a tasty homemade style pastry. Filter coffee too NY standard

Just bought a small sour cream apple pie for 12 bucks and the cashier lady told me it’s right out of oven. It tastes days old and very cold, like it was in freezer for a couple days Aa

On a recent visit to see Hell's Kitchen we were lucky enough to visit Little Pie Company. The shop is warm and welcoming. It smelled so delicious. Service was wonderful. The pies were absolutely yummy! We had the following: chicken pot pie, peach pie, key lime pie, apple pie and mixed berry. My favorite was the key lime pie. The crust and filling were so delicious.

This pretty little shop is on 43rd between 9th and 10th, more towards 9th. The Little Pie Company is a cute shop, bright and clean, aesthetically pleasing. There is outsideThat serves hot and cold beverages, coffees & teas but the best part is the array of little pies & cakes, for the times you have a small craving and big pies and cakes for when the craving is big! They serve apple turnovers, brownies, cookies, and cupcakes. They also offer a gluten-free Blueberry Apple Crumb and a Florida Key Lime Pie. All pies are made from scratch. I specifically came in, hoping for a croissant. Disappointed when there was none but only briefly when they offered the giant, flaky apple turnover. This turnover was stuffed with nicely cooked sweet & tart apple filling. The flaky crust is tender and flaky. It was croissant adjacent. There is a small covered outside seating area. The service was amazing. Even advised that if I can't get back home for a visit, they ship.

We got some mini pies to go here. The people at the counter were very sweet as we looked at the options. We got a few flavors, and they were all great. Some might say $12 is little expensive, but this is midtown Manhattan, and I liked this pie a lot more than I've liked $12 desserts at fancy restaurants. If you walk by the window, you can sometimes see someone baking the pies. Tip: If you come shortly before closing, they sell certain items at a discount.

We picked up two key lime pies for a birthday celebration. I'm not a huge key lime person but this pie was delicious! The filling was smooth, tart, and fragrant and the graham crust was sweet and crunchy. Highly recommend even if you're not a huge key lime pie person (yet) :)

I finished an amazing dinner nearby before a show at the Westside Theater which is located right across the street from Little Pie Company. Before the show started, I wanted to get a slice of NY cheesecake and a cup of coffee (sometimes I fall asleep watching a long show, especially in the evening), so this pie store was perfect. The cheesecake was good, and paried with the black coffee, it was exactly what I was looking for. I got to bring my coffee into the theater and I enjoyed the show, watching my celebrity crush Constance Wu, crush the role of Audrey in Little Shop of Horrors!

Super cute little bakery with a nice selection of mini pies for grab and go. This place has been on my list for awhile so I'm glad I was finally able to stop by. It was so hard to choose just one but my all time favorite is a banana pie so of course that's what I got. This particular banana pie also has coconut which was extremely complimentary. The service was quick and friendly. Everything about the pie was delicious from the coconut flakes to the buttery crust. It was also loaded with banana which I absolutely appreciated. Highly recommend this spot and cannot wait to return to try some other flavors!

They used to have a LOT more goodies for half-price after 7pm . But I today I was lucky to get their banana cream pie, totally worth it! Made fresh and delicious. I paid $6 instead of $12 ... probably could splint w/ a friend but sooo good ... my server give me a hint on taking the pie to go home without spilling it! .

Best pies in the city!!!! My husband and I used to walk by this shop every day when we worked in the city and when you pass the shop the smell is intoxicating! Now Every time my husband heads into the city for work he gets me something from here and I am never disappointed! Their sour cream apple walnut pie is delicious and the flavor profile is elevated so much compared to a regular apple pie. The crumblies on top are delicious! I have also had some of their cookies and they have always been delicious.

This place did not disappoint! The Mississippi Mud Pie was phenomenal! This is a chocolate on chocolate on chocolate pie that's delicious. Each bite is decadent and chocolatey. The textures are soft and tender, with the exception of the chocolate cookie crust. There are so many flavors offered, I'd definitely try others. I can't wait to explore the other offerings. They ship nationwide as well, so it's easy to enjoy this dessert even if you're not in the city.

Ive had some of their delicious mini pies before. It has been a few years somce ive tried anything from here as it is a little out of my way to get. I stopped by because i wanted a sweet treat and the Christmas cookies caught my eye from the street out with their beautiful decorations. I went in the the staff was able to assist me right away as it was empty at the time. They were friendly and showed us gingerbread cookies and sugar cookies. I got the sugar cookies and was not disappointed. The cookies are crispy and not too sweet. I have to make the trek back here.

In a last-minute scramble for a dessert for a dinner party, Little Pie Company was my immediate thought. Their sour cream apple walnut pie had won me over in the past, so I was excited to find they had a seasonal pear apple crumb pie available. Walking into the shop, the delightful aroma of freshly baked goods welcomed me, along with a display case filled with tempting treats. The staff was busy at this time but they were attentive and reassured me that i was not forgotten. After much deliberation, I left with both a 5" Sour Cream Apple Walnut pie and a 10" Pear Apple Crumb Pie. While the Pear Apple Crumb Pie was tasty, I found the cinnamon a bit overpowering. However, the Sour Cream Apple Walnut pie was, as always, an absolute delight. For those new to Little Pie Company, I highly recommend serving the pie warmed. It truly brings out the flavors, especially with the crumb top slightly crisped--a small touch that makes a big difference. Overall, Little Pie Company continues to impress with its delicious offerings and meticulous attention to detail.

Cute shop filled with pies, cookies, and cakes! The zebra bar is so yummy! Not too sweet and very light and fluffy. Tastes like a fluffy peanut butter cup. Lemon cookie is soft and doesn't have that... fake lemon flavor. Really delicious cookie. Carrot cake is moist and not to sweet which I love! If you go in the evening you can get certain baked goods at 50% off! :)

Sweet Potato Pie Perfection! Title: Sweet Potato Pie Perfection! I stumbled upon Little Miss Pie Company after missing the Thanksgiving deadline for their sweet potato pie. Determined not to miss out, I decided to order it post-holiday, knowing it's a seasonal delight. And let me tell you, the hype is REAL! Following the easy-to-understand instructions, I eagerly pulled the pie from the oven, and from the first bite, I was transported to a sweet potato pie paradise. Words can't do justice to the amazing flavor and texture; it's unlike any sweet potato pie I've ever had. Little Miss Pie Company has truly mastered the art of pie-making. Not only did I fall head over heels for this pie, but so did my boyfriend and even his mother. I had to resort to hiding it from her, as she was on the verge of devouring the entire thing. It's that good! The only downside? It's a seasonal item, and I find myself yearning for it all year round. I'm already planning for next year, and this time, I'm ordering two pies to ensure I have a stash to last me through the year. If you haven't tried the sweet potato pie from Little Miss Pie Company, you're missing out on a slice of heaven. Don't make the same mistake next year - order early and savor the deliciousness! P.S. I forgot to take a picture because it was so good! I'll definitely try out their other pies.

Stopped in here to grab something to bring to a dinner with friends. It was AMAZING. We got the applesauce carrot cake which was part of the end of day half off special. Honestly possibly the best carrot cake I have ever had. The area is also super cute and it looks like a lovely spot to grab a quick dessert bite. Will be back!

This place is serious. If you are looking for a tastefully satisfying pie, look no further. This is our family's go to for Thanksgiving. The sour cream apple walnut pie is a crowd pleaser and never disappoints. Not entertaining and want a taste? They even have minis!! Enjoy!

Little Pie Company is a delightful spot for pie lovers! I often pick up their pies to gift to friends, and they always appreciate the treat. The workers are friendly and make the experience pleasant. I've tried the Three Berries Pie and the Key Lime Pie, both of which were good. Their Key Lime Pie isn't the best I've ever had, but it's still good overall. They also have seating if you prefer to enjoy your pie on-site. Overall, a charming place with delicious pies and great service.

I got four of the mini pies: sour cream apple walnut, blueberry apple, Southern pecan, and Mississippi mud. I love that they come in personal sizes- even the personal sizes can be easily splittable! Of the four- the sour cream apple walnut and Mississippi mud were easily my favorite. The sour cream apple walnut came with the b e s t most buttery, flaky pie crust. Ugh- I could eat just the crust by itself. The apple slices were thin and the sour cream provided a good cream cheese contrast. The walnuts got a little lost though- wish there was a bit more. The mississippi mud was my friends favorite. Super rich and decadent, legitimately a brownie in pie form. Warmed up with vanilla icecream is legitimately heaven on a plate. Not too sweet either. I'll be back to try the others!

I'm absolutely surprised that I haven't written a review for here. I have been coming here since they were in the meatpacking district ages ago. I used to stop by after my voice lessons down the street. They are known for the most delicious pies, which come in mini sizes as well as larger too. My favorite is the Sour Cream Apple walnut which comes with a delicious streusel topping. The sour cream lends a nice creaminess and flavor but you won't necessarily taste it, kind of like a little extra tang. The streusel is so amazing, and they pile it on. You definitely want to warm it up and serve it a la mode. This is the pie I have every thanksgiving. Service is friendly and helpful and they kindly served warm cider when they had pie pickups in November.

This place is awful and the way the 2 ladies handled my inquiry left a bad taste in my mouth. Initially I thought the decor was cute and was intrigued by the many different types of pie, such as Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie, Uptown Baby Bourbon Pecan Pie, Cherry Pie, Mississippi Mud Pie, Banana Coconut Cream and more. There were also yummy looking chocolate cakes with luscious looking frosting, carrot cake, as well as cookies. I heard one person ask if they still do discounted pies after 7PM, so I asked about it as well and was told that there will be discounted pies between 7 to 8PM. The lady behind the counter let me know that the smaller 5 inch pies would be $5.45. So I rushed through dinner with a friend to make it back to this shop just to get this deal. I really wanted the Cherry Pie, but they were sold out. I decided to get the Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie (which I was told they are known for) and the Chicken Pot Pie. However, when the person rang me up, they charged full price. When I asked why I wasn't getting the discount, the lady explained that there was only one section that held the discount pies. This took me by surprise, because none of this was specified when I first asked about the discount pies. When I mentioned this, the lady stated that I was standing in front of said window and proceeded to rudely state that for future reference, that is where the discount pies are. She then said that sometimes they are in other areas. How does that make ANY sense? If I am asking a general question about if they will have discount pies, obviously I'm referring to the entire store and not just assuming that it's only limited to 1 area. The lady then insinuated that it was my fault that I didn't realize which ones were the discount pies. How would I know though? There were no signs anywhere and it was my first time visiting. The workers asked what I wanted them to do. Maybe apologize and honor the price that they quoted me. Even if it was for just 1 of the pies, so I could taste it for myself. And if they are as good as others say they are, I would have returned and gotten more from them. Now this spot has lost a customer and I honestly have no desire to ever come back or try any of their baked goods. A little bit of kinder customer service would have gone a long way.

No bathrooms = 1 star. The pie is fine, nothing special. Adding more characters to hit minimum. Eye roll.

so I am not a pie girl let me preface with that. small shop with outdoor seating. they also have a window where you can watch their bakers at work. they had a selection of a few small 5inch pies, cookies, and brownies. we opted for banana coconut cream. THIS PIE. omg. like I said not a pie person but this little pie far surpassed my expectations. it tasted so fresh and a perfect level of sweetness. it also features fresh bananas inside and not a creamy custard, which I found made it super refreshing and didn't ruin my entire night. they also have a savory chicken pot pie and seem to be able to heat up any pie upon request and serve you if dining in. it is $10 for a small pie, but again I think nowadays that's on par with most desserts in the city. for a 10inch it's more like $48

Really adorable little pie shop that's a bit removed from the insanity of the theater district but close enough that it doesn't feel like a schlep. They have sweet and savory pies in slices, individual sized, or full sized. You can also get cakes, cookies, muffins, and breads. I loved the triple berry pie. The crust is nice and buttery and the filling not too sweet. They have some indoor seating, but when I was there it was totally full. I was able to score a spot at one of the high top counters after waiting a few minutes. They also have some outside seating when it's warm enough. Very much recommend a visit!

Hands down the best Apple pie that I have ever tasted. I got the Sour cream Apple walnut pie. I have never tasted apples that were that paper thin in my life. I Am going back in two days to try the carrot cake!!!

Unsurprisingly, the Little Pie Company specializes in selling a ton of little pies. So many varieties it's a bit overwhelming, but it seems the Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie is a must. Then I guess just go with personal preference or pie shop recommendation. Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie: I can see why this pie is so popular, it's fabulous! Very thin slices of apple, like a fancy French tart rather than typical American apple pie. But between each thin layer of apple is rich sour cream. When the apples roast and the sour cream melts, it plays perfectly against the buttery flaky crust. As if that is not enough, the sugary walnut crumble on top adds all sorts of crunchy sweet texture. Quite honestly, the best apple pie. Banana Coconut Cream Pie: Very banana-centric. Like a bunch of chunks of bananas with a thin layer of coconut pudding and then a moderate layer of whipped cream. If you're a banana fanatic, good on you. However, if you're more into the pudding pie stuff, you might feel short changed. Personally, I felt it could have used a little less banana and a little more of that delicious coconut pudding.

We only had the two chocolate chip cookies, but the other desserts look fantastic. The service was top-notch. Great place to meet people. Couldn't recommend it more and the pricing was doable.

I ordered an Applesauce Carrot cake. To simply put, it was scrumptious. The icing was very delicious but more importantly, the carrot cake itself. It wasn't too sweet. The carrot within the cake wasn't too big so it was not like I was chomping or gnawing on the carrot for days. It was diced or grind just right. How the bakery looked like inside is just how I imagined it. The store looked cozy. It was clean and it wasn't as crowded as I thought. Outside of the store was pleasant. The garden was intact and I love how they have multiple benches for people to sit on to enjoy this delicacy. The lady who served me the cake was ready and helpful. I'd like to come back to try other options.

Amazing pies. They have seasonal flavors as well as some classic. Recommend topping up the pie with some ice cream or whipped cream. The staff that works there were very kind and made great suggestions. Do ask them their favorite and what's the best way to eat the pies

Always delicious desserts. Their sour cream apple pie is always a fan fave as well as other offerings like strawberry rhubarb. Consistency is key - and they have had it for well over 25 yrs.

Simply the best. Not too sugary or sweet, and perfect balance of taste. Their pies were a big hit on our Thanksgiving dinner table! The pumpkin pie is a must-try, and people in front of me and behind me (in the long line) all ordered pumpkin pies and happily left the store.

Happy early Pi Day! There's no better way to celebrate than with an awesome piece of pie. This has been a favorite of mine for a few years. I used to live on this street and you can't beat the amazing smell that wafts out the building. As someone who isn't a huge fruit pie person, I appreciate all the different pie options that they have. They have mini and full pies, which is great especially if you are looking for a personal sized pie. They also have cakes and various coffee/tea/cocoa drinks. Today, I went with the peanut butter chocolate pie, which is a special pie of the month. If you love peanut butter, you need to get this pie! The peanut butter mousse was so light, yet flavorful. I loved the crumbly chocolate crust. The mix of textures was perfection and I would 100% recommend it! In the past, I've had their key lime and pecan pies. Both were just as delicious. I did an online pick up order and it was so easy. My order was ready when I got there and I had prepaid online so I was in and out very quickly. I love supporting local businesses, especially ones with pie as good as this!

The Little Pie Company is in fact a little place with little pies (and some bigger ones too). I got a Sugarless Apple Pie, which was pretty good! The crust was nicely baked to a golden color. As the name of the pie suggests, it is a relatively healthy option, but as a result, it was not quite as sweet as I would've liked (I guess that's what I get for trying to be healthy). It was also kind of airy on the inside, so they definitely could've had some more apples in there. I'd say the pie was a fair size for $10. The interior has a couple seats for seating, but seems like most people take the pies to go. The staff are average friendliness. Overall, I enjoyed my pie and would recommend Little Pie Company to other pie fans as well.

I'm a little ashamed to say that I ate a whole Mississippi mud pie in one sitting. Sorry not sorry. It was delicious. Husband got the chocolate cream pie, which he also devoured. His was light; mine was rich and heavy and perfect. We will definitely be back to work our way through the entire menu. Next on my list: the key lime pie for sure. Or maybe the cherry. Everything looked great. Staff was friendly.

Tried the sour cream apple walnut, Mississippi mud pie, and chicken pot pie. Loved all of them but the sour cream apple stands out. Would come back to get more pies and also to try the carrot cake. It's super easy to heat them up in the oven and they are absolutely decadent.

Prices have gone up! The 5" pies used to be $10 are now up to 10.95 and the large pies are $42. Very pricey pies but very delicious

I came here after hearing that it was a best cheesecake contender. I got the NY style cheesecake ($5) - they got it from the back since I don't like fruit goop on top and that's all they had in front. It was alright - I've had much better elsewhere. However, I couldn't resist getting the sour cream apple walnut pie (small for $10). I enjoyed this much more, and was sharing with a friend eating it cold. However, I warmed the leftovers a few days later and it went to a whole other level! The brown sugar crumble melted in parts and the whole pie was elevated. I would get this again as a bigger pie to share. They have instructions on the box on how to warm it up - I did mine a few minutes longer because I like my food generally hotter than most.

Great mini pies. We purchased and loved the Mississippi Mud pie and Three Berry pie. So delicious and rich. We'll be back again.

I ordered through Goldbelly after viewing a sumptuous pic of Little Pie Shop's seasonal Cheddar Crust Apple Pie. My Mum's homemade apple pie with a chunk of cheddar melted on top would captivate guests until after dessert was served. The Cheddar Crust Apple pie had all those memories rushing back. Oh my goodness, It has the perfect balance of Cheddar Crust to apple with just the right natural sweetness. My family and I highly recommend this pie. Do purchase before it's out of season.

I totally love this place! I always get my holiday pies here! High quality products! Friendly service, clean environment. Decent prices. Banana Coconut Cream Pie is heavenly

50 stars!! Is that a thing? I don't even care that the desserts are very expensive. They are divine. I'll pay anything for that carrot cake. It's moist, rich and the frosting isn't an over powering cream cheese flavor. The cheesecake! Mom is so picky. This is the only cheesecake she will eat now. I wish they had flavors for the coffee. Also, is it possible to offer the peanut pie year round? Come on! Every season is peanut butter season! We are such fans we even ship their cakes through GoldBelly.

Love this place near my apartment. I'm not a pie person but this place is great, with great selection of traditional pies in different sizes. They also have cakes, cookie, brownies and cupcakes. I ordered a small size banana coconut cream pie, there are big chunks of banana in the middle, covered with cream and shredded coconut. It's not too sweet and perfect for just a dessert after meal for 2-4 people family. The pie is delicious.

A friend ordered me an unexpected gift of pies as a sympathy gift. The package was delivered and left on the ground by my front door. I had no idea that it was there. It might have been there a full day and night or 2 or maybe more. I called the store and the person answering the phone was not helpful at all. I asked if she could tell me when it was shipped, or when it was delivered. I was trying to determine if the pies were still good. She had no answers for me. The ice pack was completely melted and I had to throw them away. It is my opinion that if a company ships their products, especially perishables, they need to have the proper customer service and delivery policies in place. You should know when it was shipped and delivered. You could get a contact number to text or call.

Great Sour cream and apple pie. Made one myself about a week ago with fresh apples I picked off my apple tree and their pie was better! Great job here. Triple Berry was also good, but I'd probably try something else the next time

The service was wonderful. As a first timer I asked many questions and was given advice with no attitude. Made a follow up phone call as to storage of pies ( even though I overlooked the instructions on the wrapping of the pie..duh reading is lol) As for the pies , magnificent! Put me down as a repeat customer!!!But after the holiday season cuz driving home to Brooklyn was a nightmare!

I got a Mississippi Mud Pie for my birthyay and it was awesome. I also got the tiny chicken pot pie and it was glorious. They really put care into their pies. I miss the old fashioned chocolate cake this year but the mud pie was amazing.

This bakeshop was super busy on a Saturday evening around 7pm. Their signature pie is the sour cream apple walnut. I don't usually like nuts in baked goods so I opted for the old-fashioned apple pie instead. They include warming instructions for the pie on the box. It was great. Nice flaky crust with subtly sweet apples and filling. Despite the nuts, the high quality convinced me to try the signature pie next time I visit. The shop is small with seating at a high top counter as well as three tables. They have small, medium, and large pie sizes to choose from as well as drinks including coffee and lemonade.

NYC HIDDEN SECRET GEM! Make sure to put this place on your itinerary! Little Pie Company dishes out the most spectacular pies! Both mini personal sized and standard large pies. From Cherry, Mississippi Mud, Apple. Pecan, Key Lime (my fave), Pumpkin you name it! They also have the most legit NY style cheesecake as well as the most delish Brownies, cookies, Bread Pudding, apple filled Coffee Cake, banana bread and mind blowing apple turnovers! I highly recommend the Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie - unforgettable! Just note to pre order these if buying for the holidays (especially Thanksgiving). This is where New Yorkers come for pies as I've been for over 30 yrs. Hopefully you'll be served by Dasia who will not steer you wrong in making the best selections. Little Pie Company never disappoints- the hardest part is not buying one of everything! Guaranteed New York's Best hands down!

Absolutely delicious pies. The sour cream apple is decadent. Triple berry is a sleeper, delicious! Service is friendly and super efficient. You cannot go wrong ordering a pie for a special occasion from Little Pie Company.

Deliciously overpriced Pies. Nonetheless moist and fresh. Usually purchase a pie or two for Thanksgiving day

I pass by this store every time I take the subway, so I figured I had to try it sooner than later. I ordered a Key Lime Pie to bring home for Father's Day, and it definitely did not disappoint! The pie wasn't too sweet, and had a very tart taste and creamy texture. The crust was soft but also didn't break apart at all. Due to Covid restrictions there could only be a limited amount of people in the store at one time. The staff however were friendly enough to bring my pie out when I called instead of having to wait in line. (I had placed a reservation for the pie earlier in the day) I highly recommend this store and will definitely be back to try the rest of their desserts!