Sarah A.
Yelp
Summary: Glad I tried it, but was underwhelmed / likely won't be back. Best case: Elevated American small plates in a cute, intimate atmosphere. Worst case: Overpriced combinations of random ingredients thrown together in a visually pleasing but tepid atmosphere. Worth trying if you can afford it. Note that this is my review as a vegetarian, so I did not get to try some of the more interesting dishes on the menu.
---------------Full Review----------------
Had been wanting to try this place after seeing pictures of interesting dishes and prior vegetable-forward menus much earlier; so finally came here last Friday for dinner with a friend after work.
Space - 4 stars. Cute and modern rustic, but cramped! Friend and I both had our work bags and there was no place to put them - if we had not sat in the back left corner table with a rare bit of floor next to it, not sure where they would have gone. Coming from a 1-block walk, the room was also a bit chilly.
Service - 2 stars. Just the bare minimum; lower than my expectations for this place. I am non-alcoholic and vegetarian. The menu just lists a bunch of ingredients without explaining the dishes well, so I needed to clarify to understand the dishes and make my selections. The waitress seemed to lose patience after I asked questions about the menu a few times, answering without fully explaining the dishes. Then she was not particularly warm or attentive the rest of the evening. Nothing bad occurred, but the lack of warmth certainly detracted from the intimate ambiance from the visual setting - I do expect hospitality when I am shelling out hard-earned $$$ to visit a place like this. Not sure if this was a bad day (which we are all allowed!) or just the norm, but the service was not at all aligned to the 20% auto-gratuity we paid. (The bartender, on the other hand, was sweet/warmer and made me a nice custom drink, brought it over & explained it.)
Drink - 4 stars (non-alcoholic) - Asked for a less-sweet mocktail. Had a nice pomegranate-cardamom drink that was still on the sweeter side (not sure if the waitress actually passed on my request to the bartender) but with some nice flavors.
Food - 4 stars (Vegetarian) - Overall food was tasty if you like American cuisine. I ordered the carrot cavatelli, which is apparently a crowd favorite/enduring menu item despite seasonal updates to the menu, and the swiss chard cooked in cream:
--The cavatelli were al dente, sauced just enough, and had a nice balance of flavors and textures with the pickled ingredients, yogurt dots, and other elements. Portion was smaller than expected, just covering the bottom of a ~7-inch bowl, but ok for 1 person if you are getting another dish as well. Was not too carott-y, which I guess is an accomplishment - nothing particularly peculiar/offending in the dish, but also nothing particularly memorable stood out to me - guess it is a safe option hence the crowd favorite. Was served warm but not hot.
--The swiss chard were chiffon-sliced and lightly cooked in a thin, runny creamy sauce with tomatoes and other vegetables. The green onions added a fresh touch, and this dish was actually much more flavorful than the cavatelli. Was a smaller side portion in a ~5x2-inch saucer dish. This dish was served hotter and was much more satisfying to me; would definitely recommend.
(--Did not get dessert)
Value: 2.5 stars (for the vegetarian options). Did not see anything unique enough to merit the higher prices, ingredient-wise. Though the cavatelli were more filling than expected, the portion size for the cavatelli was maybe 1/3 of the portion I would have expected for an $18 dish. IMO these vegetarian options did not stand out / were things I could have made at home equally for less. Of course you are coming here for the experience and not the value solely, but the overall experience was far below my expectations related to the pricing.