Lost City Oyster House

Cozy little bar with two sides to the counter. You can play shuffleboard with friends at the back. Despite the good vibes, I was disappointed by the lack of variety and bland quality of the alcohol. My cocktail was way too sweet even though the bartender reassured me that it’s not. Besides, they only have one kind of wine for each of the 4 categories (white/red/rose/sparkling). Don’t have expectations too high when you visit.

Took a friend here to celebrate her birthday. The atmosphere was intimate and the music came from the juke box in the corner. The drinks are really good and cute and the tacos are yummy.

Loved this place. Felt welcomed by the whole staff. Great drinks, great food. Going back soon.

This place is fantastic. Great food, drinks and service. I recently hosted a birthday, and the events coordinators were communicative and helpful throughout the reservation process. Our server the night of was awesome, and the manager was responsive and gracious when I had to work out a billing issue (which was my fault, not theirs) with them after the event. I highly recommend the Lost Lady and can't wait to come back!

Great bar with amazing tacos Tuesday! Friendly bartenders and the tastiest cocktails!

Wonderful tiki style cocktails that I loved as well as the men in my group! A great, nautical vibe with a clear theme and very friendly bartenders. Would recommend!

Great little bar on Ave C. Extremely laid back and very nice bartenders.Drinks were on par and reasonable priced. (I am from NOLA so drinks are very expensive there!) Will definitely be back when I visit the East Village again.

Best “new” spot in Losaida—- - #1 pub burger in NYC; I crave this thing and it hits the spot every time. Tacos are A+, as well (try them all, but lean Carne Asada) - Great staff! Every single bartender makes a solid cocktail consistently yet they don’t take themselves too seriously. Bouncer is great, too, for the record, and 100% professional - Dark, funky atmosphere is so perfect. The maritime theme is tasteful AF and super intricate; they even play old 70’s-era surfer films on a little screen in the corner at night... you can’t look away. - There is a well-stocked jukebox, an old school shuffle board table, and well-placed bar panels throughout. You can also set up shop in the over-stuffed leather booths throughout the back room for more privacy. - Overall, it’s the best “new” spot on Ave C. The crowd is new wave Alphabet City, but enjoy it while you can bc once the word gets out (a la The Wayland), you never know!