Christopher T.
Yelp
We've visited twice now, and both experiences have been memorable. Our first trip was especially anticipated, as Love Supreme came highly recommended by someone who overheard me at the airport lamenting the lack of good pizza in Austin. (Disclaimer: You won't find a decent taco in NYC, just like you'll be hard-pressed to find an equivalent slice of pizza or bagel in Austin. Each city has its own unique strengths!) It took us five months to finally coordinate our schedules and make the visit, so anticipation was high!
Our first visit was back in April, with the most recent one this past weekend. On our first trip, we enjoyed a spectacular Panzanella Salad (featuring fresh local tomatoes) which was nothing short of divine. Unfortunately, it wasn't available on our second visit in September. I later learned from the staff that the salad was a seasonal collaboration with Easy Tiger, which apparently recently started closing locations. (PLEASE NOTE: Easy Tiger just closed two locations. What?!)
As for the pizza, their Veggie Pizza -- topped with mozzarella, kale, mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, pepperonata, and green olives -- is a fantastic choice. (My boyfriend particularly likes this one because the cheese does not overpower the experience.) Though not listed on the website, they also had a Cacio e Pepe pie which was exceptional. The space itself is comfortable and versatile with both indoor and outdoor seating and the service team is not only friendly but notably accommodating.
The bubbly, golden-brown crust is thin and crisp but still malleable enough to fold without cracking. The marinara strikes a perfect balance between sweetness and acidity, and the toppings elevate the whole experience. While "Favorite Pizza" and "The Onion" still hold the top spots for me, Love Supreme is definitely making me reconsider my stubborn claim that you can't find a good slice of pizza in Austin. Thank you for that! (And my boyfriend loves the house-made fermented pepper sauce in which he dips his french fries.)
[Please note that both Favorite Pizza and The Onion both offer by-the-slice but Love Supreme does not.]