Monica S.
Yelp
Just steps away from Wisconsin's State Capitol, you can find this beautiful restaurant. Lucille's is a tri-level restaurant that serves craft beers, cocktails, wood-fired pizza, and a variety of shared platters. If you are fortunate enough to get seated upstairs, you will also be able to get an amazing view of the capitol building.
This review is based on my first visit to the restaurant on a Saturday afternoon, with a reservation for a party of 4. NOTE: Strongly recommend making a reservation (and, if you check-in via Yelp on your first visit, you can get a free dessert item).
Food: My party of four tried the steel pan nachos, a steel pan pizza (serves 3-4 per their menu), empanadas, and a 'build your own' wood-fired pizza. We all enjoyed the steel pan nachos- the homemade chips were crisped to perfection, and the toppings were tasty. The empanadas were just okay- they left more to be desired. They lacked enough filling, and seemed to compensate with more dough instead. Our wood-fired pizza arrived before the steel pan pizza, so everyone was eating from the wood-fired pizza. The pizza provided a savory taste with every bite and the sauce was delicious. When the steel pan pizza arrived, we were already full from the nachos and wood-fired pizza. Two people in my party still had a slice of the steel pan pizza and they enjoyed it.
Service: We arrived a few minutes early than our reserved time, but we were seated immediately on the lower level near the bar. We were provided with water and small plates immediately, but shared that we needed more time to review the menu as it was our first time visiting. While the waiter was pleasant and provided everything we needed, she was slow. When it was time to pay our bill, she waited so long to collect the funds that I went looking for her so we could leave. Perhaps they're just having staffing issues, like many other restaurants during this time.
Value: Keep in mind that this place is known for pizza and shared plates. With that said, I personally would not dine here alone. It is a little pricey for the location in my opinion, and if you dine alone, you will really be paying for it. The 'build-your-own' pizza can add up quickly as each topping costs between $2-$5, and I didn't try any of the 'fresh house cocktails' as they ranged from $13-$17 each. I did notice that they have a happy hour everyday from 3pm-6pm (all day Tuesdays), so that might be the time to try those!
Ambiance: The restaurant has a modern, rustic, renovated warehouse feel to it. When you walk in, you will immediately notice the high ceilings, all of the lights, modern decor, and U-shaped bar in the center of the lower floor. It was very warm and inviting.
Beliefs: Speaking of the restaurant being 'warm and inviting,' I also love their beliefs, which create a healthy environment for inclusiveness. According to their website (and some of the decor in the restaurant- see pride flag, etc), the restaurant stands for humility, collaboration, respect & justice, love, equity, and inclusivity. The website adds that they stand in solidarity with 'Black, LGBTQ, and indigenous communities everywhere'.
Location: Located in downtown Madison, WI near the state's capitol. Other restaurant and shopping boutiques nearby as well. 101 King St, Madison, WI 53703.