Luigi's Gourmet Pizza

Pizza delivery · Midtown West

Luigi's Gourmet Pizza

Pizza delivery · Midtown West

2

936 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019

Photos

Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by Robert Sietsema
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null
Luigi's Gourmet Pizza by null

Highlights

No-frills pizzeria also serving pasta, calzones, wings & more for takeout, delivery & eating in.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

936 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019 Get directions

luigispizzanyc.com

$$

Information

Static Map

936 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019 Get directions

+1 212 265 7159
luigispizzanyc.com

$$

Features

delivery
takeout
Tap to pay

Last updated

Jul 9, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"Luigi’s Gourmet Pizza had deep Sicilian roots and the best offerings fell among the square slices, including the musketa — tomatoes and onions on a thick bed of cheese." - Robert Sietsema

NYC Pizzerias That Have Closed - Eater NY
View Postcard for Luigi's Gourmet Pizza
@eater

"This commodious pizzeria just south of Central Park has deep Sicilian roots and the slices show it magnificently. The best offerings fall among the square-slices including the musketa, which features chopped tomatoes and onions on a thick bed of cheese; and the oxymoronic Sicilian margarita slice, which melts artisanal mozzarella and shoots splotches of tomato sauce over an exceedingly well-browned crust." - Robert Sietsema

NYC’s Top Pizza Slices, Mapped - Eater NY
View Postcard for Luigi's Gourmet Pizza

D Sanc

Google
Pizza was OK. Had wings and garlic bread too. Nothing really stood out. Customer service was not great. Not much of a selection to drink and they charge $1 per refill. They give you attitude about paying w credit card over cash. Convenient to some degree, but not worth the stop while there's other options available.

Rumpelstiltskin

Google
Fast service and really good pizza. Make sure to order a side of red sauce to dip your crusts in (really good red sauce here) . Also, friendly staff and fun old school American pizza vibes. My partner and I got a belly ache out of eating here, that’s the only bad thing I got to say. Other than that, stop by for delicious pizza.

tastysydney

Google
This is my favourite pizza in NYC (also highly rated by One Bite Pizza Reviews) as this is actually better than Joe’s Pizza!! Perfect cheese & pizza sauce, crispy base, and reasonably priced too! This place is so underrated & needs to be discovered by all the pizza lovers out there! I went here twice on my recent NYC trip, and will no doubt come here again in the future!!

Indhira K

Google
Pizza was fresh and good. But we were prefer that the veggie pizza include onions and peppers.

O.G.

Google
I can't say anything else at this time but this small restaurant is a fabulous Authentic Italian Style Eatery

gigi b

Google
This is the most disgusting lasagna I have ever had and honestly I was shocked. The cheese was literally disgusting and it had a really weird smell coming out of it. At first I thought I was wrong and didn’t wanna throw my money away but please this is the second time I have had their pasta and left extremely disgusted and disappointed. I showed it to the workers and they basically told me this is how lasagna is supposed to look and decided not to give me a refund. PLEASE PLEASE DO NOT WASTE YIUR MONEY literally everything is nasty

Thomas Patrick

Google
The best of the best. No prisoners pie! Wife, 2 kids 12 & 11, nephew, his lady friend, we ALL rated the food a 10!

dgoodnpb

Google
Asked for extra sauce on my 2 sandwiches, food arrived via delivery, and the food is BONE DRY!! There is absolutely NO sauce on either sandwich. Dinner is ruined. Will never order from here again. Can't follow a simple instruction.