Stacy K.
Yelp
I really wanted to love this place and was so excited to try it out because I thought the idea of a coffee/cheese shop-turned restaurant was great. However, I walked away extremely disappointed, and was even laughing over how much of a bummer it was. I came here about a month ago with Jeffrey M., who's already written a detailed Yelp review, and so I'll add some additional highlights to my experience and try not to be too redundant on what's already been said. If Yelp gave half stars, I'd give this a 2.5.
PROS:
-Menu: The menu is versatile and is reasonable in price for a tapas style of sit-down restaurant. It looks like it's updated frequently based off of available and local ingredients.
-The entrees that we ordered: fried spring chicken and a ham & potato. Both were delicious and I'd happily eat them again! The chicken was refreshingly light and crispy, and came with slices of pecorino cheese and a lemon sauce that was fantastic. The ham & potato entrée reminded me kind of a cheesy layered hash brown, and was the best kind of comfort food that you could imagine.
-Atmosphere: I thought the owners did a great job with transforming the café into a nice evening restaurant. I noticed that each table was covered in a white tablecloth and a candle, which added a cozy and intimate touch.
-Women's Bathroom Art: Okay before you think this is weird to list as a pro, the women's bathroom has this portrait of a dog (poodle maybe?) that is fuzzy and 3D! Where does one even find art like that!? I just thought that was hilariously awesome.
CONS:
-Service: Our server was nice, but extremely unprepared and uninformed about the menu. When I say uninformed, I don't mean not knowing what some of the more unique ingredients that were listed were, such as ramp greens. What I mean by this and what was somewhat awkward is that when we asked for recommendations on what to order, she admitted that she had only tried 1-2 things on the menu and what she did offer as recommendations were 5 of the most expensive items because "they sounded good." While I understand that most of the more enjoyable items may come at a higher price point, the fact that she only highlighted these seemed a bit unsettling to me. Later, my opinion of the service went even more downhill when the credit card machine was broken. Instead of informing us of the situation, she wrote down our credit card number on a scrap piece of paper without asking the card owner's permission first to see if this was okay, which seemed unprofessional and tacky.
-"Bread Plate with Good Butter": We ordered this because I'm a huge carb-lover, but the few pieces of bread that we received were cold, hard, and extremely thin. Like paper thin. The butter was hard and cold as well, and I failed to see what made it "good" in quality. By 5:15 pm (doors open for dinner began at 5), they ran out of this item and so I'm guessing that they were running low on bread when we ordered and decided to skimp on this, instead of just letting us know this. Considering one of their specialties is their freshly baked bread, I was really disappointed by this.
-Side of Butternut Squash: Meh.
- Dessert: Our server raved about the banana cream pie, calling it "crack pie," even though she had never tried it herself. We ordered this and what we were presented with was the smallest slice of pie that you could imagine. I took a picture of this, but it was on a small plate, and so it looks a lot bigger in the picture than it appeared in real life. The maximum width of the slice was maybe an inch. In terms of taste, the custard filling was extremely rubbery and unappetizing from being overcooked and the crust was so hard that I had to use both hands to stab it with a knife to cut through. I took one bite and then left the rest.
Overall, the entrees were great and it's a nice place to go if you're in the mood for a sit-down meal but don't necessarily want to pay for the higher price of some of the other dining establishments in the FM area. I understand that there's going to be some growing pains and that a frequently updated menu may be especially challenging for the servers to keep up with. Nevertheless, due to the unprepared service and the dessert/bread starter, my overall experience was awkwardly weird and just really disappointing. It's very possible that I came in with too high of expectations and I'm sure that they worked out some of the kinks by now, and so I'd recommend this place if you've been wanting to try a new restaurant out. However, I personally don't plan on coming back.