Magill's World of Ice Cream

Magill's World of Ice Cream is a must-visit! The service was fast and efficient, allowing me to enjoy my treats without any delays. I tried the Strawberry Cheesecake and Nutella, and both were bursting with rich, delicious flavors. It's clear they use high-quality ingredients in their ice cream. What makes this shop stand out is its fun, welcoming atmosphere. There are plenty of board games to enjoy while you indulge, making it a great spot for friends or family. With a wide variety of flavors and toppings to choose from, you’ll never run out of options. If you're looking for a delightful ice cream experience, I highly recommend Magill’s. It's a fun and tasty treat for anyone.

First Visit to Magill’s – We Loved It! This was my first time visiting Magill’s Ice Cream, and it was wonderful! The ice cream is delicious — it’s the first time I’ve had real cream milk ice cream in the U.S., not made from whipped cream, and the difference is amazing. My daughters loved trying all the fun kid-friendly flavors like cotton candy, Superman, and birthday cake. It was a great experience for the whole family, and we definitely plan to come back!

Went for some ice cream with the family. I got a banana split at the register I told the young girl my ice cream was melted, she said that was the syrup, what syrup?????? When taking a bite it was already completely melted. Tasted like chocolate milkshake with bananas. 2 mins later my kids ice cream was dripping. It not even a hot day. It was actually a rainy type day. I rather drive 10 mins down for the real thing.

Very yummy flavors. Loved the salted caramel Oreo + Nutella. For non-chocolate flavors raspberry + huckleberry. There are also vegan and no sugar added flavors. GAMES!!! Love that there are some simple old fashioned, easy, family/ group games. Plenty of options. Reasonable prices!!

Such a cute spot! When I pulled up, there was a line out the door! I had the Carmel cashew ice cream and it was pretty tasty! I loved that there were little games to play at the table while you had your ice-cream. I will go by again!

* updated: Service can be slow at busy times but service is great and ice cream is amazing. Last couple of pints had a lot more toppings in them. Upgraded to 5 stars. I bought a pint of cookie dough ice cream. There were very little cookie dough pieces in the ice cream. See picture. I reached out to them about my disappointment and see if they would either do an exchange or refund and they said no. They suggested I open the ice cream and look at the top next time to determine if there's enough toppings and if not I can exchange it then. So you're saying I can exchange an opened ice cream as long as I didn't eat any? 🤔 For $6.50 for a pint, I had higher expectations. I've been here before and it's usually top-notch but their customer service is leaving a bad taste in my mouth.

My favorite place to get ice cream in Lakewood. Always has amazing options and a lot of options. My favorite flavor is their rocky road flavor. Also enjoy getting my pup and a pup cup every time I go in. Great service, always friendly and have a smile on their face. Also have ice cream cakes, and sandwiches, and pie slices.

Great! Ice cream. So many flavors to choose from. Non-dairy and sugar free options.