Magill's World of Ice Cream

I felt like I was tapping into a secret spot despite there being a full dining room, full outside benches, and a line out the door. I ordered a banana split and the ice cream was delish and the toppings were plentiful. Can’t go wrong with anything here.

Magill's World of Ice Cream is pure dessert heaven! I stop by regularly for their Double Dark Chocolate Fudge Crunch milkshake, and it’s easily one of the best treats around. It’s thick, indulgent, and packed with deep chocolate flavor and crunchy fudge bits—every sip is a chocolate lover’s dream. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, and the vibe inside is nostalgic and fun, like stepping into a classic ice cream parlor. They’ve got a huge selection of flavors and creative combos, but that milkshake keeps me coming back again and again. If you’re anywhere near the area and have a sweet tooth, Magill’s is a must-visit. Five stars all the way!

Magill's World of Ice Cream is a must-visit! The service was fast and efficient, allowing me to enjoy my treats without any delays. I tried the Strawberry Cheesecake and Nutella, and both were bursting with rich, delicious flavors. It's clear they use high-quality ingredients in their ice cream. What makes this shop stand out is its fun, welcoming atmosphere. There are plenty of board games to enjoy while you indulge, making it a great spot for friends or family. With a wide variety of flavors and toppings to choose from, you’ll never run out of options. If you're looking for a delightful ice cream experience, I highly recommend Magill’s. It's a fun and tasty treat for anyone.

MacGill’s Ice Cream is hands-down one of the best ice cream spots around! You can immediately taste the difference — every flavor is clearly homemade with real ingredients and so much care. The texture is rich and creamy, and the flavors are perfectly balanced, not overly sweet like so many others. It’s the kind of ice cream that reminds you what dessert is supposed to taste like. The staff is friendly, the shop has a welcoming vibe, and you can tell they take pride in what they do. A true gem — worth every scoop!

We are local residents who live right by magills and have been obsessed with their ice cream for years now. They have the most authentic yummy ice cream and the best staff in the world! We love them so much we even decided to use them for our wedding dessert. They offer wholesale three gallon tubs for purchase and we bought 4 flavors for our guests. It was so fun and so highly praised. Their team organized store pickup for us so professionally for one of our groomsmen to pickup for us and it all went so smoothly. Jennifer answered so many of my questions and helped me set up the pickup order. It was one of our most complimented details that really made our wedding feel authentically us.

Very yummy flavors. Loved the salted caramel Oreo + Nutella. For non-chocolate flavors raspberry + huckleberry. There are also vegan and no sugar added flavors. GAMES!!! Love that there are some simple old fashioned, easy, family/ group games. Plenty of options. Reasonable prices!!

First Visit to Magill’s – We Loved It! This was my first time visiting Magill’s Ice Cream, and it was wonderful! The ice cream is delicious — it’s the first time I’ve had real cream milk ice cream in the U.S., not made from whipped cream, and the difference is amazing. My daughters loved trying all the fun kid-friendly flavors like cotton candy, Superman, and birthday cake. It was a great experience for the whole family, and we definitely plan to come back!

An amazing selection, quality ice cream, excellent service, and great prices!

Great ice cream! I was impressed by the number of flavor options they have. The staff were patient with us first-timers as we contemplated our choices and even let us sample a couple flavors. The price is a good deal for the portion they serve in a regular cone (2 scoops), and I like that they let you have 2 different flavors on your regular cone. They had several dairy-free flavors, and the one I tried I didn't even notice the difference! Plenty of seating and it looked like they have several to-go options like cakes and cookie sandwiches

Magill's is still the bomb - and if you're like me and aware of your sugar intake and pay attention to processed ingredients, Magill's still hits the spot. I am always a fan of supporting local businesses over big box stores and/or brands and love that the ingredient list on their ice cream isn't a mile long. All that said, our last visit was just as good as the first. Yes, there will always be a line. This is a great sign. People wait for the good stuff, lol. The staff continue to be fast and friendly - and are happy to offer you samples so that you can choose just the perfect flavors. I def have some favorites and love that they literally have so many flavors to choose from, container sizes, cakes and even sweet treats for your pup. Happy girl here!

Magills never disappoints, and for sure never skimp on portions sizes. Photo here is the regilular (not large) 2 scoops. For $6, this is amazing. And their milkshakes are just as good. Been in denver close to 1 year and tried a lot of ice cream places. This one still my #1.

Your traditional creamery with all the classic flavors and then some! In addition to the standard cones, you can get pints, gallons, cakes, etc. Super generous with the servings! Be prepared this place can get a super long line and sometimes up to 30 minutes to wait. While you wait, you can play cute board games like Connect Four and Guess Who. Ample parking, but this is like the only thing happening in the plaza.

Okay, this place is super cute!! I love the retro aesthetic and the selection of flavors and treats. My toddler and I shared a regular sized bowl with pistachio and chocolate ice cream. They were both good, especially the pistachio, which I find can be kind of hit and miss depending on the shop. The person who helped us was very nice and patient. We also loved the games and had a fun time playing Connect 4 while we enjoyed our ice cream. The only thing I would change is that it would be great if they offered a kiddie cone or a kiddie scoop!

If you've never heard of a Superman cake, don't feel stupid because I hadn't either but can tell you that it is delicious. We ordered one at the recommendation of Magill's for our daughter's birthday and everyone was very happy. I can't even really tell you what ice cream is in it, but when they cake it with cookie crumbles and cover it in a whipped frosting it turns into magic. If you haven't tried their ice cream you need to give it a shot!

They have bubblegum and all of the other nostalgic flavors. Plenty of seating inside. They also have a huge selection of ice cream cakes, cookie sandwiches, and quarts of ice cream to take home.

Wowza! What a great variety of choices here! I had a scoop of huckleberry and a scoop of s'mores; I know weird to have together but I couldn't make up my mind. Though there was quite a crowd in there on a Saturday night, the staff kept up with the flow without making us feel rushed to make a decision.

Magills has been a staple my whole life! My parents and I went here on a particularly hot day and it really hit the spot! Their super friendly people met our every need with a smile! And the ice cream/sorbet.... Ohmygoodness!! I got the mango sorbet and it was sheer perfection!!

The mango flavor is the best ! I ordered the small cup, but it is a lot ! I could not finish it

We drove from Morrison on the advise of our server @lunch, it was worth the trip! The vibe is a hometown ice cream parlor. Magill's world of Ice cream is very inviting with friendly employees. Don't have time to enjoy a scoop? A large freezer section offers grab and go ice cream pints, gallons and ice cream cakes. Don't forget the homemade cones. I enjoyed that everyone in my group could have a scoop, they offer great dairy free & sugar free options.

Amazing!!! Get ready for amazing ice cream! It's all real and the flavors are wide-ranging. You have standard chocolate and vanilla, but then speciality ice creams, like Guinness-flavored or coffee. It's all real and all delicious! Lines can be a bit long. You can taste test, so find out what you like!

Such a fun, long-standing ice cream spot! My daughter has an egg allergy, and most of their flavors are egg-free, plus the allergens are posted on their online menu. The staff are friendly and helpful. They have many flavors, and always have no-added sugar, vegan, and seasonal options. Be prepared to wait in line if it's nice out!

If you like ice cream and don't wait to wait at little man ice cream. This place is a hidden dime. They got lots of flavors and even oat milk for those who have sensitive stomachs.

I would give them 4.5 stars if I could. Not a perfect 5, but pretty darn close. Great ice cream with non-dairy selections as well. Board games and quiz challenges can be found in their seating area. The staff is friendly and the lines go fast. The only thing that would make this place better would be cleaning the tables and seating area more frequently. Great place!

FORTY EIGHT FLAVORS. We didn't try every single flavor, but I am willing to bet every single flavor is delicious. The line was almost out the door when we arrived and it makes sense because this ice cream is top tier. They had several people working and keeping the line moving fast and the overall vibe was joyous because everyone was enjoying delicious ice cream. We were all obviously in the mood for cookies with our ice cream so we got a mix of all of them. We will definitely be back!!

Really amazing ice cream! Fast service and the prices are reasonable for the amount of ice cream you get. We tried Irish cream, Jack daniels, huckleberry, sleepless in Seattle (coffee) and root beer. The Irish cream and Jack daniels were the best, the root beer lacked flavor. The other two were good solid choices. Loved playing connect four while we ate our ice cream. Love this spot!

Stop sending me spam. I did not give you my email address and you do not have my consent to use it.

It was national ice cream day this past Sunday and my wife suggested Magill's because she heard about it on the news. It was not far from where we lived, so we decided to check it out. With 40 flavors, choosing one is not easy. It was slightly busy, but the line moved quickly and the service was great. My wife wanted a waffle cone with a scoop of banana oreo and I ended up getting a waffle bowl with Sleepless in Seattle, which had coffee and chocolate chunks. Both were so good and the banana ice cream was OG banana flavor (think banana runts). They also had little cups of doggie yogurt - so awesome! Our pup loved his treat too. This is a great, old fashioned ice cream shop with flavors sure to please all. They also have ice cream cakes plus pints and quarts to go. Huge portions and reasonable prices. I really enjoyed the waffle bowl!

This place is a neighborhood gem. We come here probably once a week for an afternoon treat, and the rotational flavors, dairy free and vegan options, and assortment of other treats is far too many to ever make it through in one lifetime. But that won't stop me from trying! The prices are affordable, the service is friendly and fantastic, and the atmosphere is great for gathering family and friends. Board games and connect four scattered throughout the place filled with smile and laughter. What more could you ask for? Plus, they are such a strong supporter in the community as well, and we see them at plenty of events from time to time. We'll never get tired of going here, even in the dead of winter.

Always good ice cream with lots of seasonal choices and friendly staff! Thanks for being a local favorite!

Greatest freaking Ice cream in the State and the service beyond that Highly recommended

Best ice cream around. Tons of flavors and the service is on point! We always go when we're in town.

One word: WOW!!! Since moving a few blocks away from Magill's, my guy had been reminding me that we needed to stop by. For months, I kept forgetting and now I'm mad that I didn't experience Magills sooner! This place is awesome! Let me preface by saying I pride myself in being somewhat of an ice cream connoisseur. I have some local faves in Denver (shout out to Little Man and Right Cream). So, Im always hopeful when visiting a new ice cream spot, but realistic about the great spots that are out there. Magills has earned a spot in my top 3 favorite ice cream shops! I went on a weeknight and the shop was buzzing with families sitting inside and even hanging outside together enjoying Magills offerings. People popped in and out ordering scoops and also picking up ice cream sandwiches and pints to take home. I got myself a scoop of half birthday cake and half salted caramel Oreo. Both flavors were incredible! If you're an ice cream cake lover, definitely the the birthday cake. However, the salted caramel Oreo is out of this world! My mouth is literally watering just thinking about it! Did I mention that Magills scoops are super generous. One scoop with two flavors was enough to satisfy me! And you can't beat their price for the deliciousness you're getting. Do yourself a favor and swing by Magills for your next ice cream craving. It may be difficult to choose one of their about 40 flavors, but the sweet staff working lets you sample so you can find your favorite!

GO. TO. MAGILL'S!! Do I need to say more? Apparently I do need to say more because YELP won't let me just post that ;) But there is plenty more to be said. Magill's has literally 40 flavors (haven't counted, just eye-balling) could be more! You can get more than one flavor and still count it as one scoop! And let me tell you... one scoop is plenty! They give you a huge serving for just one! One of their most popular flavors is salted Carmel Oreo, try it if you're even slightly interested!

In my opinion, the ice cream is not very flavorful. The strawberry milkshake didn't taste much like strawberry and the ice cream tasted more bland than I expected

I have been coming to Magills with my family since I was a kid and it had always been a favorite! It is so cute and the flavors are all delicious. This time I got salted caramel Oreo and caramel fudge brownie swirl and they are my two new favorites

Love this place!! Excellent ice cream, great prices! Basic, old school ice cream shop!

Great flavor selection, particularly the salted caramel oreo. Lots of sitting space. Friendly servers.

This place has amazing ice cream. One of the best places outside of Bonnie Brae that I have been to for that cold tasty treat! Keep doing what you do guys

My wife and I were simply driving east bound on Jewell when she looked up and saw this store. She was wanting ice cream and this is a place we had never been before. So, we flipped a u-turn and pulled in. We are so glad we did. This is clearly a local favorite as it was very busy serving families and teenagers on dates. The store is very bright and cheery and reminded us of an old world ice cream parlor. The ice cream selection was incredible and they even a broad range of ice cream cookies and sandwiches. Not to mention, the had a large variety of ice cakes as well. The staff was extremely pleasant and welcoming and the prices were very reasonable. I bought a quart of homemade strawberry ice cream and I loved it. My wife got pistachio nut ice cream and she enjoyed that as well. The building is clean and well maintained and has plenty of private parking right need the entry doors. This place was fantastic and we will certainly be back.

Blown away by all the good reviews for this place. The main thing Magill's has going for it is the service, as the staff is friendly. The ice cream, however, leaves much to be desired. They clearly use cheap ingredients and artificial flavors. Their strawberry is neon pink and features a few pieces of barely recognizable freeze dried strawberries. It seems like the people who like this either give it the benefit of the doubt due to nostalgia, or have never tried ice cream that uses real, premium ingredients. There are much better options in the Denver area than this!

I'm from out of town and wanted to find a more local ice cream shop. That's how I fell upon Magill's. When I first arrived there was a huge line out the door. Typically this is a good sign and I was happy to wait in line. After about 25 minutes of waiting I finally got to order. The regular size comes with two scoops of flavors, so I chose pistachio nut and butter pecan (my favorite flavor). I should've been warned by the radioactive green pistachio color that it would not be good, but I took a leap of faith. I noticed none of the staff had gloves on and were directly touching the waffle cones and ice cream scoops. The store itself had a weird dirty mop smell too. While I ordered the girl also tipped my cup over and my ice cream touched the counter. She immediately picked it back up and served it to me. She didn't offer to make a new one but brought me to pay. I would've overlooked all of this, but the final taste test was so extremely anticlimactic. The pistachio nut barely tasted like pistachio and dare I say had a hint of mint flavor in it? It was so strange. The butter pecan was also void of the usual rich flavor. The portion sizes are massive, but I think I would have had better luck buying a pint of ice cream from a grocery store.

Unfortunately, my experience left much to be desired. While the size and price were commendable, the flavors fell far short of expectations. One of the key aspects I noticed was the artificial taste that pervaded all the flavors I tried. It seemed as though the ingredients used were not of the highest quality, resulting in a lackluster and inauthentic taste. This was particularly disappointing considering the vibrant and enticing descriptions provided on the menu. Another issue I encountered was the excessive sweetness in the ice cream. It's not uncommon for ice cream to be on the sweeter side, but in this case, it was overpowering and overwhelming. This made it challenging to truly enjoy the flavors and appreciate the nuances that could have been present. Despite giving Migills Ice Cream a couple of chances, the outcome was consistently underwhelming. The flavors just didn't deliver on the promises made and left me feeling indifferent towards them. It was a missed opportunity for me to discover new and exciting tastes. On a positive note, Migills Ice Cream does excel in the portion size department. Their ice cream servings are undoubtedly generous, providing you with plenty to enjoy. If you're someone who values quantity over flavor, then this may be a redeeming factor worth considering. A great hang out for teens. In summary, while Migills Ice Cream offers sizable portions at fair prices, the artificial taste and excessive sweetness detract from the overall experience. If you're seeking truly unforgettable flavors, you may want to explore other options instead.

Meh. A lot of people rave about this place and I don't get it. We have tried it several times just to see if maybe some of the other flavors would be better, but haven't loved any of it. Seems like a great place for kids- everything is overly sweet tasting and there are games and stuff to play when you're there. As an adult, if you want some solid home made ice cream, I'd make the drive to Denver to get something way better. There's always a giant line at this place too... Not worth the wait in my opinion.

awesome place. If I lived closer it would be a weekly must. GREAT ice cream and fun atmosphere with good service. Yes please!

Lots of cool flavors to choose from! Extremely generous scoops. We loved it and glad we found this place!

We go here fairly regularly and have never once had a bad experience. I have a few favorites but the piece of cake is not only good, but this is the only place I've ever seen anything like it. It's ice cream cake by the scoop. The staff is always friendly. The portions are huge. There is a well stocked pint/quart to go freezer. They also sell a handful of novelties to go. There are a ton of options. And for us, it's right around the corner.

Five stars and worth every one of them. Huge portions, cheap prices, and ice cream is super delicious! Tried cookies and cream and Reese's PB cup. Talk about the chunks! Will be coming here every time I want ice cream in the near future.

The service here can only be explained with one word. Exceptional. By far, the best staff and ice cream I've ever had in my entire life. As somebody who, quite frankly, enjoys a lot of ice cream, knows a good spot when I find one. The girl who helped us, I think her name was Ally, is made to put a smile on peoples faces. Definitely give this place a try

This tucked away little gem in Lakewood is SO GOOD! The service was great and so many ice cream flavors to choose from!

HOLY MOLY! I'd melt for another scoop of ice scream from Magill's. The scoops are HUGE! We were warned by the person helping us, but it still exceeded our expectations. I got one scoop of birthday cake and one scoop of coconut cream pie. The coconut was definitely my favorite, though they were both delicious. The ice cream is creamy and smooth and soft just as it should be! I was also excited to see the wide variety of unique flavors -- the espresso, coconut seven layer and Jack Daniels flavors are calling my name for the next visit.

Exceptional service, and fabulous assortment of ice cream flavors. If you encounter a long line .. do not fret the staff makes the little wait well worth it, and put that yummy smile on your face. Wow! At the wall of your to go ice creams, cakes and pies are amazing. Oh and they too have treats for your dog. Games at the tables if you desire to eat inside The staff is quite friendly and helpfully. We will always make Magill's a must stop when in town.

After reading the most recent comment, I had to get on and post the real truth. Magill's is truly an amazing family owned and operated establishment. They provide an amazing variety of flavor's throughout the year with amazing customer service. I have been to Magill's probably 10/15 times since 2019 and this is still my favorite ice cream place in Denver. I don't care if it's a 10/20 minute drive, I'm going to Magill's for my ice cream .

Kind of your present day B&R (for those old enough to decode that) Lots of flavors. When the lines are quite long (I was also there Sunday, International Ice Cream day!) simply grab a couple quarts and go.The Jack Daniels /choc chip is quite bomb. two thumbs up

We LOVE Magills! The flavors they have are amazing and delicious! It is so hard to decide which flavors to get! I always say I will try something new and in the end I get a scoop of 7 layer coconut, and a scoop of salted Carmel Oreo. The scoops are huge, and I have enough in the bowl to have a few bites each night for about 5-6 days. My husband and kids can eat their two scoops in one or two days lol. Our son often gets the malts instead and they are made perfectly. They have various sizes of your favorite flavors to go, as well as cakes and treats for the pups! The staff are a great group of teens/younger adults, and do a great job of moving the line along quickly. The wait is never long even when out the door, and you won't be disappointed!

Some of the best ice cream this side of town. The flavors are great & the service is speedy. It's worth the long lines! They also have puppy treats.

Wow! Super fresh ice cream with amazing flavor choices. One scoop is $4 but actually has 2 scoops and you can mix flavors! Coconut options are decadent. Ice cream cakes are gorgeous and with a chocolate cookie crunch layer and frosting that reminds me of Carvel cakes. We splurged and got one for $27. The layer of cookie crunch was too thin, which was a bummer but the ice cream is worth it. Lots of seating including booths with connect 4 and other games to play. Staff are consistently friendly, patient while you sample from so many choices- be sure to take their recommendations.

Clean and great ice cream. Staff is hard-working and friendly. I recommend the mint chocolate chip or the cookie dough.