Lauren C.
Yelp
Been pretty disappointed after every meal we've gotten here. Ordered takeout because of COVID twice in the last week and both times we were disappointed. The burger was quite good and we enjoyed the fries pommes frites that came with it. However, the clams casino and the lobster mac and cheese were extremely disappointing. The clams were very oily, and the breading completely overwhelmed the clams themselves both in amount of filling and flavor. In fact, I didn't think the flavor of the stuffing was complementary to the clams at all. The lobster mac and cheese was incredibly rich, but not in a good way. Rich to the point of unappetizing, and not salty or cheesy enough. I heated up my leftovers the next day and was absolutely horrified. My pasta was swimming in a lake of clarified butter. I tried to stir it back in to reincorporate it but it didn't matter. In order to even attempt to eat it, I had to start soaking up the butter. Even after completely saturating three full-sheet paper towels, there as still quite a bit of butter left over. We ended up throwing the meal away and wasting $38. A total bummer.
Our friends raved about the $10 Tuesday pasta special, so we decided to give Maison Carlos another try this evening. We ordered the pasta special and the bolognese. The special, a pesto linguini with chicken, had many of the same problems as the lobster mac and cheese. Although the amount of oil was nowhere near as egregious as the amount of butter in the lobster mac, it was still enough to be unappetizing. Also, there wasn't enough salt to flavor the dish at all and the chicken breast was burnt. I ended up throwing my portion out after eating half of my plate - not because I was full, but because it was that bad. However, the bolognese was wonderful. I really enjoyed how robust and fresh tasting the sauce was, and I thought the pasta was cooked well. I liked seeing full basil leaves in the sauce as well.
Unfortunately, the inconsistency in the quality of the meals we've ordered from Maison Carlos will keep us from returning.