Mama's Fish House
Seafood restaurant · Paia ·
Seafood-centric Hawaiian menu, Polynesian decor & epic ocean views
Seafood-centric Hawaiian menu, Polynesian decor & epic ocean views
"After a swim at nearby beaches like Baldwin, I recommend stopping into the beloved Mama's Fish House for a post-swim seafood feast." - Kat Chen
"At first glance, Mama’s comes across as a tourist snare: the South Pacific motif borders on kitschy and entrees cost an eye-popping $80. But this Polynesian fantasy has legitimate appeal. Waitstaff dressed in vintage Aloha wear deliver warm bread and an amuse bouche as salt air wafts in from the private cove. The kitchen’s consistency, honed by Maui-born executive chef Perry Bateman, justifies its international reputation. Each fish is listed along with who caught it and where — which, in an era of overfishing and mystery fillets, is worth the price. Start with seared local octopus or grilled Haleakalā beef served in half a papaya, then dive into the fragrant bouillabaisse with its saffron-scented chunks of Tristan lobster and Kauai shrimp. Reservations fill up 3-6 months in advance; book as early as possible. Must-try dish: Mama’s offers free house-made poi (mashed fermented taro root). Sample this native Hawaiian staple with something salty on your plate." - Shannon Wianecki
"A popular Polynesian-themed restaurant known for its fresh seafood and beautiful ocean views. It requires reservations well in advance due to its popularity." - Jen Murphy Jen Murphy Jen Murphy is an avid adventurer who splits her time between Colorado and Maui. She travels the globe pursuing passions that include surfing, snowboarding, cycling, and trail running and tries to
"A highly sought-after oceanfront dinner destination known for its fresh, locally sourced seafood and island-accented preparations that often require advance reservations due to its popularity and reputation for memorable meals." - Evie Carrick Evie Carrick Evie Carrick is a writer and editor who’s lived in five countries and visited well over 50. She now splits her time between Colorado and Paris, ensuring she doesn't have to live without skiing or L'As du Fallafel. Travel + Leisure Editorial Guidelines
"A true Maui landmark, Mama’s Fish House has been serving seafood in this same location since 1973. Their menu is so local that it’s updated daily with the name of the fisherman, the location where the fish was caught, and what it likes to do on the weekends (OK, maybe not that last one). This place is located steps from the sand at Kuau Cove, so it’s about as beachfront as it gets. And despite the bamboo walls and thatched roof, Mama’s Fish House is a pretty upscale and intimate place—expect to spend upwards of $60 on entrées. Book early—like, three to six months early—or try your luck snagging one of the limited bar seats, which are reserved for walk-ins." - martha cheng
