Catherine S.
Google
Check-in was handled extremely poorly and fell well below the standard expected for a luxury hotel.
I arrived at 3:00pm knowing check-in was at 4:00pm and politely asked if my room happened to be ready early. It wasn’t, which was fine. I was told to return at 4:00pm or that I would receive a call if it became available sooner. At 4:00pm, my room was still not ready. I was asked to wait on the rooftop and told I would be called when it was ready.
After nearly 40 minutes on a cold, windy rooftop, well past my confirmed 4:00pm check-in time, I returned to the front desk. I had received no call. Meanwhile, I watched other guests be sent to their rooms. When I politely expressed that my check-in time had passed and this was becoming unacceptable, the front desk agent (Andreina) did not apologize or offer any courtesy whatsoever.
Instead, she (Andreina) insisted that check-in starts at 4pm siting your reservation states, “From 4pm” and that my room could be ready at any point after 4pm, implying that the posted check-in time did not guarantee room availability. That logic makes no sense. My reservation clearly states 4:00pm to noon, not an undefined window. Shifting blame to the guest rather than owning the delay was inappropriate and dismissive.
To make matters worse, I was offered a “ready” room only if I accepted a downgrade. When I declined because I wanted the room I paid for, the explanation kept changing from “not as nice” to “same room, just no view.” It was confusing, frustrating, and poorly handled.
I finally got into my room just before 5:00pm, nearly an hour after check-in, with no apology, no compensation, and no accountability.
That said, not everyone here deserves criticism. Omar, the valet and bellman, was an absolute gem. He was kind, helpful, and professional, and he deserves recognition. The restaurant was outstanding. The steak was one of the best I’ve ever had, and the service was excellent. The room was gorgeous and clean.
Unfortunately, front desk service sets the tone of a hotel stay, and this experience overshadowed everything else. For a hotel at this price point, this level of check-in mismanagement and customer dismissal is unacceptable.
I am local and booked this for a staycation. I won’t be back nor would I recommend it to anyone I know solely based off of what they would be dealing with at check in.