Tony G.
Yelp
On February 2nd, I went to Marugame Udon for a noodle breakfast consisting of a large Nikutama Bowl with a Diet Coke. Since I was already here, my order was made quickly and delivered to me in no time. The meal cost about $20, including my 15% tip, and I had no problem finding a seat. The place was clean, the employees were helpful, and the music was pleasant to listen to. Overall, I can leave it at that.
The thing is, though this is my second time at Marugame Udon, my first visit was on Christmas Eve last year at the Waikiki location during my layover for my homecoming trip to Cambodia--a trip long overdue because of the pandemic.
When I visited Marugame Udon in Waikiki, it was an experience from the moment I waited in line with other tourists to the moment I exited the building. Looking through the window, I saw a man preparing the next batch of noodles by hand as I stood next to friends talking about their days in Hawaii. Even though it was a humid and sunny day, the occasional breeze helped soften the temperature. I was excited to try something different from McDonald's or a microwave meal.
When I entered, we were in a conga line, but it was moving fast. I ordered the same noodle soup then as I do now--a meal that would be enough to sustain me for the entire day. I got my food and sat by myself after being directed by one of the staff to an open seat. It took me 20 minutes to finish my soup, but I took my time because I was immersed in the atmosphere, observing a diverse community of people laughing and smiling together in Hawaii. I said to myself, "This is amazing. It's like Thanksgiving." The soup was tasty and satisfying, leaving me full without needing seconds. Once I finished, I exited the restaurant and made my way to a nearby café, planning out my homecoming stay in Cambodia.
The problem is that while I did visit Marugame Udon in Hawaii, it was tied to one of the most meaningful experiences I had in a long time. This means that a review of my recent visit to Marugame Udon will inevitably be influenced by that memory, whether I wish for it to be or not. While I did enjoy the meal and believe it was flavorful, it is bound to "taste" different from the one I had in Waikiki because that memory is so significant.
Therefore, though I am giving this location the same four-star rating as the Waikiki location, I am basing my review on the product, service, and cost value rather than my personal memories, to ensure fairness and remove factors that the restaurant cannot control. That's why I can confidently say: If you like Japanese noodles, Marugame Udon is the place to go.