Juan P.
Yelp
My girlfriend and I decided to visit Maxine's On Shine for the first time as part of Magical Dining and as part of our date night.We wanted to try something new, and I'm glad we did because the customer service here was outstanding by far some of the best I've experienced in any restaurant. The atmosphere was also very unique and made the experience even more enjoyable.
We started with the Wine Lover's Board, which we both agreed was our favorite. It came with fruits, nuts, salami, and three different types of cheese. I was surprised to find that the blue cheese was one of the best I've ever tasted, even though I usually don't like it.
My girlfriend ordered the Caviar Blini, Maxine's Lobster Ravioli, Berries Romanoff, and added the Hamptons Sangria. If you're a seafood lover, you'll likely enjoy the Caviar Blini and Lobster Ravioli, as they both have a strong, fishy taste. They were good, but not exactly what we expected. The Berries Romanoff was very sweet, though a bit sour, and the Sangria was just okay, it got watered down pretty quickly, which made it less enjoyable.
I had the Lobster Roll, NY Strip Steak, and Biscotti with Vin Santo del Chianti. The Lobster Roll was my favorite of the three course meal, it was tasty and came with some homemade fries. Unfortunately, the NY Strip Steak was a letdown. It arrived cold, even though the plate was warm, and it was under seasoned. I was very hungry by the time it came out, so I didn't mention it until after I finished. When I told the server, she immediately spoke to the manager, who apologized and explained that the kitchen was backed up. To my surprise, they offered to make a new steak for me to take home, which I appreciated. The Biscotti was pretty standard, but the Vin Santo del Chianti paired with it was an acquired taste that grew on me the more I had it.
Getting to the restaurant was easy, but parking can be tricky since it's in the middle of a neighborhood.
Overall, I'm not sure if we'd return for dinner, but we've heard great things about their brunch, so we might give that a try in the future. I would have rated this place a 3, but the exceptional customer service bumped it up to a 4.