Scott B.
Yelp
Even though this establishment is in the heart of the touristy Historic District, there is no question but that this is a locals' hangout. So much so that when my wife and I walked in the front door at a few minutes after 2pm on a weekday afternoon last week, every single stool at the bar was already taken by obviously local barflys. (No disrespect intended.) And why were they there at 2pm on a weekday afternoon? Because that is when happy hour begins. (Extra points to McDonough's for beginning happy hour that early rather than the more routine starting time of 4pm or 5pm.)
And why, you mighy ask, were my wife and I there as well at 2pm? A very reasonable question! We are visiting Savannah at present and had gone to the Savannah Visitor Center on MLK earlier in the day and had picked up a flyer/advertisement for McDonough's and it looked interesting. I especially noted that happy hour ran from 2pm - 6pm and included craft beer specials for $4.00. So after a few hours walking around the Historic District, we decided to give McDonough's a try.
As I noted earlier, when we walked in just after 2pm, we found that the bar stools were already all taken, so we grabbed a table. After a few minutes, the harried bartender, who was also the waitress/server, came over and asked what she could get us. When I asked what beers were included under the HH special, she replied that it was only cans, not draft, and that the choices were Bud, Coors, PBR, and perhaps some other mass market beer that I don't remember. When I referenced the flyer I picked up that specifically stated that "craft" beers were on special, she just shrugged. I didn't want to press the issue, especially since the misleading (if not outright false) flyer wasn't her doing, I just chuckled and said that I'd forego the HH prices and just order a draft Guinness. My wife ordered a "glass" of pinot grigio. (I use the term "glass" loosely, because her wine arrived in a small plastic cup.)
After bringing my wife her wine, the bartender/server informed me that the Guinness tap had just "blown out." When I asked if the bar had any other stouts or porters on tap, she told me there was a Terrapin Chocolate Milk Stout, so I ordered that. I was very pleased with that selection as it tasted quite good, and I was even more pleased at the reasonable price ($6). My wife's pinot was even more reasonably priced at $4. Unfortunately however, she said that it tasted like vinegar.
We decided to leave after our one drink rather than order food because we thought it could be quite awhile before our order would be taken. (Again, not a reflection on the bartender/server who definitely needed help.) And if the kitchen was as understaffed as the front of the house, it could be even longer before the kitchen prepared it.
I think 3 stars is a fair review. Our experience would probably only warrant 2 stars based on the misleading flyer, but if you like mass market American beer served in a low-key friendly establishment, then this could be a 4 or 5 star experience for you. Especially if you factor in the low-cost HH prices. I don't think my wife and I will be returning though.