Jeremiah B.
Yelp
Since the 80's we've been to 4 of the 10 Medieval times castles. We lived in San Diego for over 20 years, and we've visited the Buena Park castle many times. We moved to Maryland (work related the only thing that would get me to go there), and we've been to the Baltimore castle many times. We've been to the Florida castle once, and now the NJ castle.
The used to have something like a loyalty program. It stopped some time ago. I honestly don't remember the details, but I remember when they did away with it. It was years before went back.
When we started visiting in the 80's, it was the king's royalty. There was no queen, but there was a princess. They changed to the queen's royalty a couple of years prior to COVID.
In my opinion, Buena Park has the best castle. It has a medieval torture chamber with all the trappings, and you get to see the horses and Falcons preshow. What I remember of the Florida castle, it was decent. Baltimore's castle is nice. NJ's castle is okay. Entering I felt a bit underwhelmed. It seems they passed on any semblance of authenticity. They need to redo the main hall/room. They do have better swords for sale (I think Buena Park has/had the worse sword selection). The service is on par with the other castles, but the NJ show outshines the other castles we've been to, even though the horses, while they were beautiful and majestic as the horses of the other castles, they fell short as far as performance goes. The Knights made up for it. The fighting scenes are noticeably more energetic and entertaining.
NJ has the smallest arena, to my eyes it made the horses look bigger:-). The knights don't have room enough to fake fall off the horses while in motion, but that didn't detract from the rest of the show.
We paid $170 (with a discount) for Queens royalty seats for 2, and we got stuck between people with no elbow room. Not worth it, and that goes for all castles, but NJ has stadium seating, so there's no lateral movement, that is ridiculous.
Don't get me wrong. My wife and I do date nights at Medieval Times occasionally because of the service and people. It's safe and fun mostly (as long as you don't get stuck next to someone obnoxious, yikes!)
No Medieval Times review would be complete without mentioning the food. It hasn't changed much since the mid 80's, but the last few years the taste has improved. In the last few years, I've noticed they are not over seasoning the chicken. The tomato (dragon) soup is a bit odd for my taste, but my Wife likes it. The potato does have a bit too much seasoning. If you've ever had Chesapeake Bay Blue Crabs smothered in Old Bay, that's what it's like, but it is quite edible. It's pretty much the same at all the castles we've been to.
We will most likely continue to go, but we'll probably stop paying for the queen's royalty package.