Jeff B.
Yelp
Rewriting and downgrading to 3 stars from 5 (ambiance 1, food 4). Wow, what happened to Mi Casa?? We've been coming here for 30 years, back when Barrie was seating people, and after having lunch here today, we were so stunned that we paused on the way out and almost said something to the manager (he seemed super nice btw). **GUYS** people go to dinner at a restaurant for 2 things- the food and the vibe/ambience (how the place makes you feel), and you screwed with both of the things that made you popular for over 50 years? Your remodel stripped out the super inviting and cozy, dark wood, kitschy old-school Mexican vibe and throw-back bar that made us want to order a second round of margaritas, and turned it into a bright white, open, sterile, noisy, generic restaurant with largely blank walls that's a stylistically and visually confusing mess. Then there's this big white wall separating the right side, which is now..man, this makes me sad.. it turned into a big open space with cheap tables that looks like a cafeteria. On to the food. Not sure what changed with the cheese enchiladas; the sauce picked up a slightly odd taste. The chili relleno was great; maybe a touch better than before. Seems like they also tried to upgrade the quality of the food too, and we appreciate what you are doing- Really. The problem is, Mi Casa is known for its unique taste. On the upside, the chips and tortillas seem fresher, and a big 5 stars to the new staff; the service was exceptional. In the end, we left feeling super sad that we lost something special (and without having any margaritas; Mi Casa no longer feels like a place we want to hang out at, and we didn't seem to be the only people that looked confused). I'm a change agent and love it when something gets better, but this seems like an epic fail. We'll come back once more in a couple of months just to be sure, but for the first time in 30 years, we left without wanting to come back again :( :(