This cozy Hamilton Park scoop shop whips up silky, inventive ice creams like lemon olive oil and matcha Oreo, plus playful ice cream sandwiches.
"Milk Sugar Love doesn’t have much seating of its own, but it’s across the street from Hamilton Park, so you’ll have plenty of places to sit while eating their ice cream sandwiches held together by housemade cookies. Know that only one guest or family/friend group is allowed inside at a time, masks are required, and cash is not accepted." - hannah albertine, nikko duren, matt tervooren
"Rather than deciding between cookies and ice cream at MilkSugarLove, just order an ice cream sandwich, like the one with coffee cream packed between two fresh chocolate chip cookies. Whether you go with one of those, or you just order everything, you can have it delivered from their location in Hamilton Park or The Heights." - matt tervooren
"Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakery has the best ice cream in Jersey City, hands down. While you can absolutely order a cone of vanilla bean or a cup of strawberry and leave perfectly happy, try one of their funkier flavors, like matcha with chunks of Oreos or the honey lavender. They also do playful ice cream sandwiches like the Birthday Sprinkle (two confetti sugar cookies with vanilla ice cream and sprinkles) and the Red Velvet Dream (red velvet white chocolate cookies with cream cheese ice cream), plus blondies, brownies, ice cream cakes, and more. " - matt tervooren, nisha vedi pawar, kendal nicole lambert
"Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakery has the best ice cream in Jersey City, hands down. While you can absolutely order a cone of vanilla bean or a cup of strawberry and leave perfectly happy, try one of their funkier flavors, like matcha with chunks of Oreos or the honey lavender. They also do playful ice cream sandwiches like the Birthday Sprinkle (two confetti sugar cookies with vanilla ice cream and sprinkles) and the Red Velvet Dream (red velvet white chocolate cookies with cream cheese ice cream), plus blondies, brownies, ice cream cakes, and more." - Kendal Nicole Lambert
"Milk Sugar Love is churning out unique ice cream flavors like a Thai Tea soft serve."
