Geoff L.
Yelp
We enjoyed eating at Montclair Egg Shop over 15 years ago and because we were going to be in the Montclair area, decided to stop here for brunch on a Saturday around 12 noon. We knew it would be very busy, so used the online Yelp waitlist before we got there. We found metered parking in the neighborhood after circling around once, and waited about 20 minutes to be seated after checking in with the host.
Food Review:
Egg Shop Potato Pancakes (3.5/5): Not potatoes but hash browns cooked with ham, cheddar, onions, cilantro topped with sour cream, one slice of tomato, and cilantro served with scrambled eggs. Sauteed onions and lots of cilantro worked well to elevate this straightforward dish.
Huevos Rancheros (3/5): Fried eggs, tortillas, ranchera sauce and black beans, topped with cheese & sour cream. Added chorizos. Food was okay and basic.
Crepes Pesto (3/5): Chicken, mushroom, pesto, scallions, and jack cheese filled crepe. The filling was just okay and without much flavor. The crepe was bland.
Note: after taking our order, the Huevos Rancheros and Crepes Pesto came out very quickly from the kitchen, so I do not know if these were already pre-prepped but it took a little more time for the Egg shop Potato Pancakes to come out and we liked the potato pancakes the best out of the 3 dishes.
Service (3/5):
The host pointed us to the table at the front windows, brought over an extra place setting but did not bring us any menus. I had to make eye contact with another staff member who was working on to-go orders who saw that we did not have any menus and she was kind enough to bring over menus that we could look over. Our waitress came over to take our order, bring us water, checked in on us once, and then brought over the tab.