Jane P.
Yelp
This is one of the hidden gems of NYC, and holds a special place in my heart. I try to take visiting friends here as often as I can, and my boyfriend and I make a point of coming here once every month or so.
Don't come here expecting five course meals or extravagant fine dining. That's not what this place is for. This place is for authentic, simple, elegant Italian food in an intimate, simply decorated restaurant. It's the perfect date night spot: polished but not stuck-up, high quality but not ridiculously priced, good food but no fuss.
I think everything great about this restaurant can be summed up just by its olive oil, which comes with bread. This is the most fragrant, rich olive oil I have ever tasted in my life, with fruity notes and a magical ability to melt away on the palate without leaving behind the usual pungent olive flavor. We have been raring to buy a bottle ourselves, but sadly, the waiter informed us that Mozzarella and Vino imports their olive oil directly from Italy, from a vendor that sells to no other restaurant in America. (My boyfriend was ready to bribe a waiter to give him a bottle, but I stopped him.)
The most outstanding dish here is the cheese plate. You absolutely must get the cheese plate if you come here, and when you get the cheese plate, you MUST order the buffalo ricotta cheese. Smooth, delicately flavored, and with a dollop of honey on top -- spread it on a slice of bread and slap a piece of cured meat on top. I've never had any cheese quite like it, and have not been able to find it in the grocery store, either. The plate comes with a richly flavored fruit compote, berries, nuts, and one piece of pumpernickel bread per guest (an admittedly small amount, so we usually ask for more plain bread to go with the cheese plate).
I've had the ravioli here multiple times. It always seems to be the same filling -- plain ricotta cheese, with tomato sauce -- but good god, despite the simple ingredients, I've never had ravioli quite so good. The texture of the pasta sheet is perfect; the ricotta filling is delicate, and absolute perfection with the sauce. And man, that sauce! It really is something special. Most sauces with a strong flavor linger somewhat stickily on the palate, but the tomato sauce here retains a unique lively freshness without sacrificing flavor.
This place is also the site of the ONLY panna cotta I have ever enjoyed in my life. I have always hated panna cotta because chefs seem to love adding some unique ~twist~ on it. But, as with the rest, this dessert was simple -- a vanilla panna cotta with berries, and a berry reduction sauce (if I remember correctly, I only had it once, the first time I ate here). The flavor of the panna cotta was perfect, with true vanilla bean flavor, a smooth texture, no aftertaste, and most importantly, the right level of sweetness. Combined with ripe strawberries and raspberries, and a touch of berry reduction, it was absolute perfection. Ever since it was taken off the menu, I have been mourning its disappearance.
Chefs of Mozzarella and Vino, if you are reading this, for God's sake, please put the panna cotta back on your menu.
The meal concludes with complimentary pieces of biscotti, cooked to crispy, crumbly perfection -- one almond (hazelnut, perhaps?) flavored, one chocolate.
I can't recommend this restaurant enough. Take your artsy friends here for wine and cheese. Take your family here for pasta and paninis. Take your significant other here for small bites. And when they put panna cotta back on the menu -- DON'T MISS OUT ON THE PANNA COTTA.