Old City Pizzeria & Sports Bar

Nice spot, cozy ambience and friendly service. If this jawn was outside of Chicago I'd likely give 5 stars for the pie, but "for Chicago Pie" I have to give it 4. It was good, but we've had better. Also the jalapeño poppers definitely seemed like the frozen out of the box type which was disappointing.

Ms. Gina, Ms.Palese and the owner Peter was So Amazing!!!!!! I came in with family and friends and I left out feeling like I was apart of there family. The food was delicious and the hospitality was top notch. I highly recommend stopping in. We had mozzarella sticks, pizza, taco salad and drinks and it was so good. I learned a lot about the history which I can appreciate and I will definitely be back!!!

Had a pizza and some fries doordashed to my location..Ate a piece of the item they call “pizza” and my disappointment was immeasurable.No life in the pizza no tang, was drunk and still couldn’t consume much.Ended up tossing the rest and went to a real place that serves real good food

My all time favorite pizza place since I was a kid. The owners were great people and had excellent food but the place changed hands recently. They remodeled and updated the place. The original owner is still there transitioning and she is still involved. My personal opinion is that the stuffed pizza recipe changed a little bit it's still excellent. I could be wrong on that but the crust seemed a little different to me. The service was very attentive and took good care of us. I highly recommend it.

Been going to Nancy's for over a decade. Fred and his family are absolutely wonderful! 💯 I love their vegetarian/vegan pizzas, salads, and baked artichoke hearts. My ONLY complaint is that there is a little too much oil in their baked artichoke heart dish. It's still REALLY GOOD. I don't like a lot of oil. Nonetheless, I give this place a 10/10.

Great food, good service, and a classic Italian restaurant atmosphere. We've eaten at Nancy's twice and have ordered thin crust pizza and lasagna so far. Both are delicious and you really can't go wrong either way. We specifically ordered the four cheese pizza. The pizza is thin crust, but not a cracker crust. The combination of the cheeses is amazing and it was different (in a good way) having ricotta on a pizza. The lasagna was so comforting and good. Perfect meat to sauce to cheese to pasta ratio. We also got bread sticks and salad with our lasagna and even those were really good. The salad ingredients were very fresh.

This is my first time visiting Nancy’s and the staff are extremely nice and friendly. Gina was really nice and talked about the history about the place and was really helpful with everything. Highly recommend coming here before the change the name.

I’ve been going to Nancy’s for over 20 years and the food, service, and staff have been consistent and awesome. I love stopping in on Saturdays after running errands for a 1/2 price stuffed pizza, Fred has the best stuffed pizza with sausage, mushroom and green pepper. He has the best 4 cheese and Canadian thin crust and I love being able to get a 1/2 price thin crust if I don’t want to cook on Mondays. My order is always correct and he cooks the pizza crust exactly how I ask.