Sheena T.
Yelp
Best croissant in all of NYC - this is in comparison to Jean George's Tin Building, Radio Bakery, Bakeri, L'Appartement 4F, La Bicyclette, Dominique Ansel, and even some bakeries I've had in Paris/Normandie France: Chez Meunier (along with some others in Galleries Lafayette), Moderne Boulangerie (the famous bakery featured in Emily in Paris which actually received a top 3-5 croissant nomination with a Grand Prix designation), Ritz Comptoir, Conticini, local neighborhood pâtisseries in France, etc).
My partner is also a French National and gave his stamp of approval of Nick and Sons having the best croissant in NYC. So he has a lifetime/25+ years of prior croissant tasting experience from the Motherland. He's spent the last ten years as a NYC resident trying out bakeries that are close to authentic, French Patisserie levels.
The croissants here were perfectly buttery, not dense, and the texture inside had a nice pull to it. We ordered the plain croissant, cheddar and ham croissant, sesame and cheese pull, and a baguette to go.
Now the baguette was a little more dense to our preferences, but still good nonetheless.
To the other reviewers who claim that any croissant is good out of the oven clearly does not know anything about cooking or baking. Some of the other reviews on here give me a good laugh as I question if some of these reviewers truly tour the world for baked goods. Dare I say, if I asked one of them to make a croissant from scratch, they wouldn't even have the slightest clue on how to make a croissant to begin with...baking and cooking is truly science and art combined, and these bakers deserve true respect and acknowledgement for it.
I can say that I've had a solid 100 croissants in my life (obesity and high cholesterol hasn't hit me yet...knocking on wood!), and can safely attest that Nick & Sons Bakery deserves this 5 star review for all around best croissant in NYC.
I will be bringing my French in-laws for a croissant should they be craving one when they visit us in NYC.