Ron R.
Yelp
Hmm, where do I start? Nico's is a seafood house on the pier that's apparently a local favorite. But from my short dine-in experience here, it felt as if it "was" a favorite back in the day, but not so much anymore. My debate was deciding between 2 and 3 stars. So here's my take:
: Parking, Location & Atmoshphere :
The area seemed fairly active with other eateries and the fish market nearby. Plenty of parking spots all around, but I can imagine how packed it could be during weekends. As for Nico's itself, they had a full bar with indoor dining around it, as well as patio dining.
:: Reservations, Staff, & Service ::
We made a reservation for nine, with four chairs being for kids. It also was a nice evening, so we did the patio. The hostess didn't say much, other than seating us, and them immediately telling us of a time limit with our group. I think one hour or something, I don't recall. It just sounded awkward and annoying to be told, but understandable I guess. Could've been more discreet. As for our server, he was nice, but I forgot his name because I couldn't stop thinking that my first visit here was limited.
::: Appetizers & Entrées :::
Started with the Fried Calamari ($16) which was decent. Crispy good, but nothing special. The Shrimp Scampi ($26), on the other hand, was prepared very well. I feel the capers gave the dish a nice kick. A couple of us ordered the Catch of the Day (Market Price $32) which was the pan seared tombo ahi tuna. The inside of my ahi was not even soft. Seared OK, but not long enough for my fork to easily break off a piece. It was a disappointing waste of a tuna cut.
:::: Overall ::::
Nico's is your typical, "by the pier" or landing or wharf type of seafood restaurant. Their dishes are average in taste and high in price. Dining in is chill, but can get loud. And if it gets really busy, they will give you a time limit with your party and kick you out if you're just lounging around. I liked it here, but did not love it here. And I'm sure the locals feel the same way.