Brett K.
Yelp
Nina June is good in spots, rough around the edges and a bit disjointed in others. It did not live up to the praise that has been heaped on it in every article and most reviews I've read. If you're restricting your comparisons to mid-coast only, then I suppose it rates a little better as the choices for exceptional dining in the region aren't great, however if it's being compared to Maine dining as a whole, it does not execute at the level so many Portland restaurants are these days.
The space is beautiful and exactly what you would hope for in this quaint seaside community, but the food just didn't live up to expectations. The service and plating was just very clunky, with some decent food mixed in with disappointments.
We started with Oysters because of the deliciously described Tomato Mignonette. They arrived and we had to ask the server if the tablespoon sized pool of liquid in the middle of the dish was the mignonette. She paused, seemingly unsure herself, and confirmed it was. Alas, because of the plating style and the fact there was no spoon, there was no way to transport the liquid onto the oyster. After requesting a spoon we were able to get literally a few drops of mignonette onto each oyster. Not the experience we'd hoped for to start the meal and it essentially set the tone for what followed. I also noticed other diners later that evening who had received oysters from another server must have had the same issue as awhile after they had received them the server came back with a small ramekin full of mignonette for them.
The next app was the tomato tart with blue cheese which was the highlight of the meal. The flaky tart was incredibly light and flavorful. The filling for the tart was also full of savory flavor, but somewhat overpowered what I'd been expecting and hoped to be the dominant flavor of the dish, the tomatoes themselves.
My entree was the duck, which was cooked perfectly. Paired with a cold baby lentil salad with shaved carrots and marinated olives. It was strong with middle eastern flavors and good on it's own, but seemed a slightly odd pairing with the warm duck.
My wife's entree was the risotto, on the advice of the server. My wife had planned on the spaghetti dish, but when asking the server for recommendations she had a difficult time explaining the spaghetti dish and clearly had a favorite in the risotto. When it arrived, and I hate to describe it like this, but it just looked like a gloppy bowl of green mush with no garnish, overflowing up onto the lip of the bowl. The bowl was too small for this entree sized portion of risotto. It had some good flavor but again, the combination of plating plus the consistency of the risotto being a creamy gooey mush, it was a miss.
Overall, the entire experience, service, food, plating, just seemed incredibly disjointed with a few flavorful bites in between. We'd made the drive up from Portland based on all the positive things we'd heard, but ultimately were disappointed, compared with the offerings down here. It reminded me of our two experiences at Primo in Rockland, another mid-coast establishment constantly described as a regional gem. The overall experience at Primo was much more professional and special, but the food came across as solidly good, but nothing of the complexity and excellence of what's being done in southern Maine.
If I was in the area I'd likely give Nina June another shot and just treat it casually with a seat at the bar and go with my own gut when ordering.