Peter H.
Yelp
I've been going to Noble Pie for years, since it was Pie Face and was on 2nd St., and am disappointed this is my first review on Yelp. I will start off by saying this is a great spot to go for outdoor seating and a wide variety of food options. The location is also perfect with a mix of restaurants and bars on Cheney st.
That being said, the price to eat here with a family is prohibitive. I ended spending close to $100 for a meal with 3 people, which seemed very high for a casual meal. Even a large 16" pepperoni will cost you close to $30 which is outrageous. I also found that the pizza is not that great, not what it used to be. Maybe the specialty pizzas are better, but I thought the crust was too soft and a bit soggy, and the 16" large looks more like a medium compared to other pizza places.
The Caesar was a Jerk salad was good, the employee that took my order warned me it isn't like a regular Caesar salad which I was fine with, and I actually liked it much better.
The Fried Cheese Please is a basket of cheese curds, also not a large portion but it was a nice appetizer and they were good.
I ordered a pound of BBQ wings and was also not very impressed with the overall quality, quantity and price. They were more on the soggy wet side than a good cooked wing, and the BBQ sauce didn't really make an impression. I normally order the Burq-style and always enjoy that, but I'm starting to wonder whether those would have been any better given how the wings were prepared.
Noble Pie always has good beers on tap, and Pinion being next door is also a good option for even more variety.
I'm still giving Noble Pie 4 starts because it's a nice place to go with friends, hang out at the bar, maybe catch a special, but I won't be coming back with my family or a large group, as I would find much better value elsewhere for the price.