Nolita Pizza

AMAZING PIZZA. If you are in the area, try this pizza, if you’re not, make a trip out! I regret not eating more slices. There are many slice options to choose from and they all had the perfect flavor and texture. The prices are great. The establishment has a large dining area with seating. I have only great things to say about Nolita Pizza, check them out!

Nolita Pizza is a fantastic alternative to Prince St Pizza. It's more affordable, less crowded, and has ample seating. The sauce is delicious and comparable in quality. One of the highlights is their spicy pepperoni, which is generously topped on the pizzas, offering a perfect balance of spice and flavor. The pepperoni is crispy around the edges and pairs exceptionally well with the rich tomato sauce and gooey cheese. Additionally, they offer hot honey as a free complementary condiment, which adds a delightful sweetness to the spice of the pepperoni. Highly recommend!

One of the Best Pizza Spots in Town! If you’re craving top-tier pizza, this place is a must-visit. The sauce is fresh and flavorful, the cheese is rich and perfectly melty, and the crust is just right—crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. Toppings are high-quality and generously portioned, whether you go for a classic Margherita or a fully loaded pie. Every bite is packed with flavor, and you can tell they use only the best ingredients. Add in the friendly service and cozy atmosphere, and you’ve got a pizza experience that’s hard to beat. Easily one of the best in the city—highly recommend!

Great crunch on the grandma and the sauce was sweet but punchy. Round pie had that same great crunch but hit even better because of the thinness. Overall, great stop after some lunch on Mulberry

Finding the best slice of pizza is a religion in this city. And if you are in SoHo I recommend dropping by this no frills eatery. They sell by the pizza slice in both thick and thin crust in very generous portions! I had the vodka pizza which is thin slice with a sublime vodka tomato sauce . It came straight out of the oven and I have to say it is one of the best slices of pizza I have ever had. The prices are absolute value and the service is very friendly! Will be back when I’m in the neighbourhood

This is NYC. Sure, you can go to Joe's or Lombardi's, and they're good, but this place is quentissential NYC. By far the best pizza I've had in the city. Tony is the best. I came with the family 2 years ago, and he remembered me, and asked about my children. He's an owner who genuinely cares about his customers. I recommend the spicy pepperoni (with some hot honey), or the Margherita. Sweet sauce, thin crispy crust. The best authentic pizza place in NYC hands down.

Got a spicy pepperoni slice: it was pretty good. The pizza wasn't overcooked so the slice was crispy enough and the sauce cheese ratio was decent. They had hot honey for the pizza too. Note: There's a 4% discount if you pay in cash.

I don’t review often but this place deserves all the stars!! Good pizza is everywhere in this city but Nolita offers some of the best!!! If Portnoy came here (maybe he has already??) I’d be surprised if Nolita didn’t earn top marks. Crispyness, undercarriage…. It’s all 12/10!!!!

A must visit if you're a fan of thin crust pizza! The crust is soo thin and crispy but still had a good chew to it. We ordered a slice of Burrata and Vodka Sauce. Both were flavorful but I enjoyed the Vodka Sauce a bit more since it was a bit more cheesy.

Went here for a quick dinner after work, it's a simple pizza place with a dining area attached to it if you want to sit down. Instead of a pizza, the Eggplant Parmegian Hero caught my eye, so I went for that & ordered it for take-out. They told me I would have to wait for about 15 minutes, which I was fine with. After 10 minutes they were already ready & handed me my sandwich. Unfortunately, I forgot to take pictures but the sandwich was huge and for approx. $13 it's a great deal! It was piping hot with a tasty marinara sauce & lots of cheese. The eggplant was still slightly crunchy as well. Overall, for its price a great deal, lots of food and really well made!

Weekend get away to NYC and stopped by Nolita's Pizza. Get slices, cheese quickly warmed up. Garlic bread loaf takes 7 mins, but nice crispy and garlicky on the inside. Spicy pepperoni has a kick, but not that bad and very yummy. On the opposite side there 2 larger tables for 6, and smaller 2 seaters. So during busy times, to go might be the best options.

Amazing gluten and dairy free pizza. I called in advance and ordered a gluten free pizza with chicken, spinach, and vegan cheese. It takes a while to get the gluten free pizza because they make it fresh as a personal pie upon order. So definitely recommend calling in advance. It felt very safe allergy wise and they cooked my pizza separately. And it was delicious! Vegan cheese can be super hit or miss but theirs actually melted and had a mozzarella consistency. I was impressed!

Great pizza spot in Nolita that is open very late. The hot honey on the counter pairs PERFECTLY with any slice!

I'm a harsh pizza critic. Glad that this didn't disappoint! Regina Napoletana Pizza (Slice $4.50 or pie for $28) was delicious. Crispy and lighter than most crust (which I appreciate--there's nothing worse than eating dense, dry dough that's overwhelming). Good proportion of toppings & sauce to the dough--too many pizzerias skimp out and the ratio of bread to everything else is off. Sweet, light tomato sauce (which takes four hours to prepare in house). Didn't taste the basil much. Didn't feel heavy & greasy & disgusting after one slice, so I'd return for more! Very important not to feel guilty after pizza--speaks to quality ingredients. Indoor and outdoor seating available. Friendly staff. Clean & simple environment. Nice vibe--the seating area is covered with photos of Tony, the owner (who has kept on to his pizza recipes for 20 years!), with all the celebrities who've frequented his pizza places.

Pizza was sooo good, went three days in a row. Staff was nice and fast service. Open late which is great

This spot is pretty good! Their Grandma pizza features a wonderfully sweet, home-style sauce that perfectly complements the fresh, chewy dough. The use of high-quality, fresh cheese adds a delightful richness to each bite. Overall, it's a fantastic place to enjoy delicious, well-crafted pizza.

Tried this place on whim because the original pizza I ordered was 2hrs delayed - so I ordered this in a flash just because I was hungry So glad I did - the Grandma Rosemarie pie saved me that night! Unbelievable crust like a garlic butter crispy. Now my go-to for pizza delivery

Great spot! We came around midnight and it wasn't too packed. Lots of indoor seating and a few tables out front. White - The ricotta and mozzarella tasted so fresh! The crust was crispy and the portion was sizable! Vodka - Tasted great! Wished the sauce was a little more plentiful than it was though. Love how late this place is open for. Definitely coming back!

We stumbled upon this place and was highly pleased. The crust was perfectly crispy & delicious We got the Jalapeño pepperoni pizza & traditional pan pizza. Will be back to try more.

We went after a rave around 10:30 pm and were sooo hungry that we over ordered. The Margherita pizza was fresh and the guy behind asked if we wanted to heat it up even though it was fresh. Because we didn't know any better and like our food hot, we were like YES! Cute a few seating options, long tables, tables for 2-3 as well! However, that's where we made a mistake. Don't heat up freshly ones that just came out. Because when we got our pizza slices, they were so oily and not soggy because they put a good amount of sauce. The sauce is amazing, you taste the tomatoes and there's chunks of tomatoes. So fresh and delicious! Now initially we were like oh the tomato sauce is amazing but minus points because it's too oily and drippy. Like you can't hold up the pizza with one hand and fold it. That's minus, but then as we were eating the first slices the rest cooled down and when we went for the second slice , AMAZING! Crispy, no drip, can hold and fold in one hand, and amazing sauce with chunks of tomato? Can't go wrong! Now we just not fan of deep dish, so it was a miss for use but flavors were good! Thick crust good bread. Oh they gave us ranch too which hit for the thick one because so much bread! Pepperoni was crispyyyu and delicious so this place is solid if you're craving pizza it hits. Also I think price is cheaper than joes! Only minus like very few like -.3 points is that there wasn't enough garlic/ pepper flake shakers out. People kept having to swap them out from one another. Granted we ordered a lot so we weren't done with the shakers right away. Overall, great amazing would def come back again no complaints loved their sauce with the tomato chunks !! My

Outstanding slices. Can't say enough about the crust, the middle was thin-and-crispy, as you would expect.....but the ends were awesome too! Really separates it from other by-the-slice places. One of the best I've had, and I'm a connoisseur. They also have a decent little seating area with a bathroom. Bonus points. 5/5

Coming from the Bay Area I had to go on a pizza tour upon arriving in NYC! Nolita was the first stop and it was a great great start! - Taste: Flavors were really good in my opinion. Tried the Regina Napoletana, Chicken Buffalo, Margherita, and Pepperoni and Sausage. Sauce was balanced, not too salty or too sweet. - Crust: 11/10! Our favorite! So thin and crisp, but not too crispy that it's too hard to bite. - Price: Pretty average, $3.50 - $5.00, cheaper than the Bay Area prices in my opinion - Wait: a few people, but pretty much no wait! - Space/seating: Pretty good amount of seating. There's a few tables outside and maybe 8-9 tables inside? Overall, no complaints and ended up coming back a second time because of how much we liked their crust!

Overall a solid NY pizzeria experience with fresh and tasty pizza and fast service! 1. Margherita pizza slice - this slice was very solid, with a perfect light and airy NY style crust, fresh mozzarella and flavorful tomato sauce, the only downside was the tomato usage was a bit heavy which watered down some parts of the pizza. Still recommend! Crust: 9.5/10 (amazing texture, floppy and crispy!) Cheese: 8/10 Tomato Sauce: 6/10 (a bit watery) 2. Pizza Bianca slice Crust: 9/10 Cheese: 7.5/10 Sauce: 8/10 3. Spicy Sausage al taglio Crust: 7/10 Cheese: 7/10 Tomato Sauce: 5/10

Ordered two slices when I passed by Nolita Pizza on Kenmare Street in Little Italy. You order at the front when coming in and then you wait for your order once the staff rings the bell telling you that it's ready to pick up. There's a fridge containing different kinds of beverages like soda, juice and water. For a self-serve indoor pizzeria, there're actually lots of tables and seating like roughly about 30 seats. Additionally, they've all the seasonings and condiment bottles on the counter for customers to put on their slices like cheese powder and chili flakes. Best of all, there's actually a whole bottle of Mike's Hot Honey to drizzle onto your slices....for that I'm super impressed! Because hot honey can get pretty expensive at Whole Foods, Eataly and Target. As for the taste of the pizza, my favorite is probably the buffalo chicken slice only because there're huge chunks of chicken (although not tender) on it. The other slice with olive oil and mozzarella is only alright, not bad I guess. The slices are definitely not hot and fresh from the oven, just warm when they reheat them up. I think it can be hotter as in temperature wise. Love how crispy the crust is though. There's one restroom stall for customers to use...thank goodness for free public restrooms. It's so difficult to be able to find a decent bathroom these days. As for the ambiance wise, there's a wall of fame displaying all the celebrities and famous people who have visited Nolita Pizza in the past. They've extra chairs if the place ever gets packed like sardines. There's even a high chair for kids. Look around carefully and you'll be able to see some outlets either on the wall or hidden somewhere underneath the tables. If you wanna charge your phones, be sure to look for those spots I've mentioned! I always try looking high and low everywhere in order to find a wall outlet close to where I'm sitting. Customers can use either credit/debit cards and/or cash as accepted forms of payment. I can see this place getting crowded by tourists in the summertime. Conveniently located by the 6, N, Q, & R trains. I can see myself coming back to this pizzeria whenever I'm in this neighborhood again next time.

Great spot to grab a late night slice with quality taste. We came by after a concert at the Bowery Ballroom at about 12:30am on a Sunday morning. There were a lot of customers happily eating and hanging out. It is a very relaxed feel, perfect for a closer to an eventful night. The kitchen was still making fresh pizzas at this time of the day and they were friendly even for the hour that it was. The pizzas looked and tasted great. Different styles and flavors to accommodate anyone in your party.

Best pizza we had in NY! I was skeptical to order by the slice but it tasted great. Got a new respect for vodka sauce as it was a delicious twist on the regular cheese pizza . They have a small dinning area but most people grabbed their slices to go . Several yours stopped by and grabbed a slice while we were there. Don't discard it until you try it !

I ordered a pizza and baked ziti for delivery. The food is delicious! The Ziti is enough for 4 people! To have for dinner and be satisfied! The pizza was delicious. They use fresh veggies so there may be a variation in the veggies on your pizza but they will be fresh and delicious!! I called the restaurant with a question and they were courteous and professional. This is a great place to eat!

One bite 8.7. This is a solid cheese slice. Good sauce to crust ratio. Definitely if you're hungry and craving a slice, this is the go to. Always a bit of a wait, but that's how you know the locals know it's good. Eat this instead of that tourist place Prince Street pizza

I decided to try this place based on reviews and prince street pizza was closed. I like that they sell pizzas by the slice in addition the pies. I didn't need an entire pie for myself so I ordered 2 slices. There were a couple people in line which was nice because the other places I looked into were packed and had a long wait. They have a seating area and a few of the tables were filled. The lady at the counter was really helpful and made some suggestions and was polite. I ordered a pepperoni slice (really good, highly recommend!) and the Regina Napoletana slice (mediocre). The crust is perfectly crispy with a good chew. The Regina slice would be better with buffalo mozzarella I think. It just didn't nail it for me if I'm being honest. The texture of the cheese felt a bit rubbery and flavor was kind of off. Maybe not as fresh? Not sure but I didn't care for it. I typically go for wood fired pizzas but I did enjoy it nonetheless...the pepperoni pizza that is. I would definitely come back for a slice of that next time I'm in town!

Drove by and decided to stop. First time here. The people were friendly and talkative. The pie was good and price friendly. Order three slices, winner goes to the Margherita slice. The interior is relaxing and

My sister RAVES about this place. Because of that, I think that my expectations were too high. With that being said, the pizza was good, but I've had much better. The place is small, good thing is even though the lines can get long, it seemed to move fast enough. Very efficient. I ordered the margarita pizza.. the crust was thin, but maybe too thin... not enough flavor in it.. cheese to sauce ratio--I believe that it could've had more cheese and sauce lol. It did seem to have very fresh ingredients, though. Let me also say this.... it was good! But, I have to be honest about my experience... that's the Yelp way! Would I come back? Absolutely.. I'm very interested in how a regular slice and one with other toppings would fare.

Yummy! Good quality Quick order ! So friendly !! Ambiance - small pizza shop Has a cute sitting area .

The best slice I've had in NYC. This is my go to spot whenever I am in the Soho/Nolita area. I stopped randomly on my way to a hotel when I saw the line out the door. A line that size on a Saturday night meant the food had to be good and it was. Also, the line goes by really quick. I ordered the plain slice and a grandma slice *chefs kiss*. The grandma slice was so good from the sauce, to the nice thin crust. Everything was so good ! I have been back almost four times and I don't even live in NY . This is definitely a must try. The restaurant is fairly small with a nice seating area thats filled to capacity every-time I go. I enjoy people watching and eating my slice anyway so this didn't matter to me.

Good slices. The best are the spicy pepperoni and Regina Napoletana. Service is so so, the lady behind the counter is really nice, but the restaurant could use better organization and management overall. I encourage you to try it if you're in the area.

nice slice shop with both ny style and sicilian slices. stopped in for a vodka slice recently, crust was good, flavor was ok, solid slice of pizza but not the best around there was a line, they have a decent sized dining room inside and tables out.

Absolutely amazing! A small informal place that serves best pizza in NY. And they are open until 2am. The staff is very polite and helpful.

Whoever is reviewing this pizza with four or five stars needs to have their head examined. This is eminently mediocre pizza and it is beyond unfathomable that there is a line to wait for it (and I did because someone I know recommended it as "the best slice in New York." It's not even close). I've been here twice and both times were completely underwhelming. The crust is too thick, sauce/cheese ratio has too much cheese and overall completely unremarkable. On the second visit I even had their gluten-free pizza because I was dating someone who had a gluten intolerance and it was served on a premade crust and took almost a half an hour. Absolute garbage. Do yourself a favor, go get yourself a slice of Joe's.

Nolita Pizza, while offering a pizza menu, also offers various appetizers, salads, calzones, heros, and even Italian entrees, such as baked ziti, eggplant alla parmigiana, and pasta bolognese. We stopped by for a mini snack break, and we tried a few pizza by-the-slice. They were okay; they were a little overcooked, and the toppings and the cheeses could have been more melty. Make sure you sprinkle your pie with the crushed red pepper and the Parm located on the counter inside. Note that this is strictly a carry-out place, but there are a few tables outside on the sidewalk. Staff were friendly! +overdone pizza +friendly staff

My husband and daughter love pizza. I am so-so on it, but I enjoy a good slice now and then. My definition of now and then would change if I lived in NYC and could easily access Nolita Pizza to shove into my pie hole. How it doesn't constantly have lines out the door and around the corner is anyone's guess, but I have to attribute it to efficiency of the staff. The original shop is tiiiiny, but they acquired some side space for seating, and for that I am grateful. The staff didn't like it when I asked them to double cut my pizza and that was a little annoying (what's the big deal - it's easier for me to share that way and try more pizza), but they did it anyway. On the upside, I can confirm that every one of the pizzas we tried were exceptional.

The cheese pizza was good, the spicy pepperoni and the Sicilian slice were just ok, nothing special. Friendly and quick service!

I love me a good nolita slice with the hot honey on it. There isn't really any pizza spots in soho that carry hot honey so shout out them. The service is pretty straight forward. Order your slice wait then get a table. I love the aesthetic inside it really embodies a modern New York pizza shop. Try the pepperoni and bacon slice with hot honey thank me later.

Hands down the best Pizza in NYC!! We water there for 1 week straight for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. When 5 NYC officers come to eat there on their break you know it's that good!! Love their thin crust pizza, even the meatless options were amazing vodka sauce was A1! Don't sleep on their meatballs or wings either.

What a weird pizza experience this was. I noticed when I walked in that it was absolutely packed with tourists, leaving virtually no place to sit with my pizza (had to squeeze in between two families). All the tables outside were also packed. A few minutes after I sat down, I realized I was in the middle of a large food tour and got to hear the tour guide ask the group if this was the best pizza they'd ever had. Total crickets...I should've known that was a bad sign. The tour group left 5 minutes later, and the restaurant was completely empty until 5 minutes later when the next giant tour group descended and swarmed the place. As for the pizza? The spicy pepperoni Sicilian slice was pretty okay. The pepperoni had a nice crunch on the edges, but there was so much of that it left the pizza really greasy. The sauce, cheese, and crust were pretty bland. I added some hot honey, but even that didn't make this taste like anything other than pepperoni grease. Felt like overall, this was forgettable pizza.

Great service - walked in first things before going to walk to Chinatown. Getting here was easy and love the grandma spicy slice, cheese and tried the eggplant parm hero. Also the Vodka slice hot out of the oven was great.

Best pizza in New York! Hands down. Friendly staff and food is just amazing . They want me have more characters before I post so here it is

Had to stop by here during my visit to NYC. It was a weekday and the line was short. There isn't much room to sit and it is a small restaurant. The lady who was taking the orders was efficient fast and yet kind; you didn't feel rushed to order. Looking at the pictures on the wall, you feel like you are taking a short journey in history of NYC. Pizza tasted unique in a pleasing way. Will defiantly go back during next visit.

AMAZING pizza!!! Small sit down area inside and outside. Pizza was delicious. Loved the crust!!!

Nice oven baked pizza, clean and seemed very fresh. It is more of a traditional Italian style seemed much lighter than large chain pizza

Had a plain slice from here today, and it's fire. Cheese and sauce mesh together in harmony. The cheese has the perfect amount of sodium on top, creating the salty splash I need from my slice. Sauce with just the right amount of sweetness. Only thing I don't feel are the bubbles on the bottom of the crust, several spots incorporate this into their pizza making, I dunno what causes it but it reminds me of brand new basketball ridges. I'm definitely coming back here when I'm in the area.

Walk up counter, order, go sit and enjoy-easy peasy! Crust is AWESOME! I could eat that alone. Had a slice of Grandma Rosemarie and pepperoni. They have bacon ON the PEPPERONI because you can't get enough pork products! Adds to the crunchy! Good stuff. Dave Portnoy hasn't tried this place yet. Y'all tell him to come to it.

Pizza Delivery: 7.8/10 I got the Formaggio Bianco Pie [(White Pie) Creamy fresh ricotta cheese, aged mozzarella, Parmesan Reggiano, fresh basil, homemade spices, and imported cold-pressed virgin olive oil]. I added italian sausage on half of the pie. The pie was large. Good amount of cheese. It tasted bland though. The italian sausage half was better because it was more tasty. For the price, I think the quality is better than other pizza places in NYC. I would try Nolita Pizza again.

Delicious pizza!!! Great customer service! A must! Good Everything beer everything!! Can't' say enough!!

A hidden hole-in-the-wall with many walk-in clients. No frills with a dining area adjacent. Legit and fantastic pizza. The owner is on-the-scene and kind in a New York way. Choices are abundant and there is no wrong answer. As blistered and chewy as the sit-down restaurants and the late hours are perfect for any student who is studying. We, the parents, were the delivery service to said study group.

See that bite in my photo of the pizza? Yeah, after that bite, I reached for the phone and quickly went here to yelp. The most CRISP and flavorful bite of a pizza slice I've ever had. I can taste the fresh basil and olive oil. And as other reviewers said, the slices are large. For this price in soho, I'd come back here over any other of the pizza spots. Super friendly staff and outdoor seating. Generous toppings. Next time I'd try the pepperoni (real ones, the small circular pop up ones vs the cheap flat fake ones). There's so many toppings you can't even see the pizza :) ciao!

The pizza was nice and crunchy the way I like it. Service was fast and great!! Looking forward to going back.

This pizza was everything it was the only pizza I had on my trip to New York and it was worth the wait. Everything about it was perfect not too saucy pepperoni was spicy it was fresh. Gosh I should've bought another one and froze it lol. The woman at the register was so sweet so helpful she charged my phone too lol. I was about to order another one and random line just came out of nowhere and they ordered all the spicy pepperoni I was pissed lol. The pizza slice was $5 just worth every penny and then some. Please open a location in Miami please!! 10/10

Was in the area and stopped by because of the high reviews. It was okay - nothing to write home about. I got the spicy pepperoni and though there was a ton of pepperoni on it - that's the only standout flavor - it wasn't warmed well and got cold in the center. Its a typical pizza spot vibe - fast service, with tables inside to sit, and slices ranging from $3.50-$6.