Alex E.
Yelp
I am struggling in figuring out how to review Oak Steakhouse; I've been bouncing back and forth between 3 and 4 stars. Landing on a 4. Here's why....
Arriving at Oak Steakhouse, we waited a weirdly long time to have someone see us at the check-in desk. A sign that they are understaffed currently. No biggie, just a little odd.
I ordered a filet, as well as the chopped side salad. My husband ordered the burger (he just wasn't super hungry and didn't feel like a steak), which came with fries.
My salad was HUGE. Easily could have been a meal in itself, especially if you had an appetizer.
My steak was the problem. I ordered it medium-rare. It came out well-done.
(Background: I am originally from Nebraska. I was brought up on having good steak, and often. I know my steak.)
Cutting into the very middle, it did seem to arrive closer to a Medium temperature. But I paid for a 8oz steak cooked Medium-Rare, not a 6 oz Well-Done (which was dryyyyyy and flavorless). There was maybe only 2oz cooked properly.
The waitress was apologetic, and took my steak back to the kitchen. Maybe 10-15 minutes later she brought out a new plate.
Fortunately my new steak was cooked correctly (maybe even a touch on the rare side of things). Much, much better. The char was a nice addition to the steak, and I very much appreciated it.
My husbands burger was *fine*. I wouldn't have called it a smashburger, and it wasn't the best burger in the world. It was fine. The fries were YUM though, for sure.
The reason why this isn't getting a lower review: they did not charge us for my steak! kudos to Oak Steakhouse for doing everything they possibly good to make things RIGHT. Thank you!
BUT: I wouldn't go back. Why? Because $60 for a steak that was good, not great (even after being fixed)...just isn't worth it. The steak, plus the price of my side salad (sides are not included in the price of the steaks), and no bread service or anything along those lines....like, that better be a heck of a meal. And ours just didn't blow me out of the water.
Service was slow. Not our waitresses fault, she was seriously running between tables. They are understaffed. The restaurant was loud, and only half full. (No soft carpeting, etc, to help with noise).
Bottom line: Oak Steakhouse made up for their overcooked steak, and then some. But it just isn't worth the money, honey.