Stephanie W.
Yelp
Mediocrity and Missteps.
After much anticipation, I finally went in to Oceano this past weekend. I love patronizing local restaurants, and I was truly excited to stop by here. It felt long overdue. Unfortunately, both the overall experience and service were less than stellar. I might be willing to revisit at some point in the future to allow them an opportunity to right my impression, but at present I'm not eager to return.
Where to start?
Oceano has a relatively positive reputation in the local community with foodies, so it seemed a natural place to add to my standard rotation. Located on East Ocean Ave in Lantana, slightly east of Federal, the vibe is decidedly "beachy" - and the parking situation is what you would expect for anything near the water in South Florida. Be prepared and arrive early so you've got time to scout out a spot in advance of your dining experience. We arrived slightly before 7pm, had no issues parking (delightedly), and we were seated within 15 minutes or so.
It's worth noting that the menu and website present an air of pretentiousness that set the tone for the evening - and unfortunately led to some dissatisfaction from my party. First, this is a cash only establishment, which feels very "off" in a major metro area in 2022. We did our due diligence and came prepared, and while Oceano does have an ATM inside for those who did not know in advance, we still felt this detracted from the experience. Secondly, the menu expressly notes that patrons are limited to a 2 hour timespan. I understand the desire to keep tables rotating, and I think this would be a fine request *IF* service was well executed. But that's a big IF, and unfortunately, service was well below par for an establishment that demands so much from its patrons.
The menu is short and sweet - exactly what you would expect from a restaurant that lives by the farm-to-table freshness mantra. A quick review and I had my order decided. The waiter arrived shortly after we were seated to deliver water and ask us for our drink orders. Typically, I'd have ordered a cocktail with dinner, but there was only a wine list provided. I chose a glass, and we proceeded to order our appetizer and entrées.
We started with a Mushroom pizza, and ordered the smoked pork ribs and orechiettte with lamb bolognese as our mains. The biggest misstep of the night was the service, which began slowly and progressively got worse. After a bit of a wait, our appetizer was delivered. The pizza was very lackluster. The dough was flat and not as springy or airy as you would expect from something made fresh in house. I order a very similar pizza at another local spot in Delray, and sadly this one did not hold a candle to theirs. The ingredients were fresh, just not as well executed or as well seasoned as the pizzas at Rose's Daughter.
On to the mains. My companion received his pork ribs relatively swiftly after the appetizer, however my main was nowhere in sight. I urged him to eat while his meal was hot, instead of waiting for mine to arrive. He dug in and was pleased with the flavor combinations. Their salsa verde was tasty, and capers were a nice unexpected flair. We flagged our server to ask about my entree, as it had still not yet arrived, 30+ minutes into service. Our inquiry was met with a response that the food is served "sharing style". This is not listed anywhere on the menu, web site or elsewhere and felt like a poorly crafted retort to a disorganized kitchen or poor service. Continuing to wait, my companion actually *finished* his entree well before mine was ever even served. 45+ minutes into service my pasta was delivered (at the same time as the table adjacent to us, who were seated 25 minutes after we arrived). Admittedly, the pasta was delicious and well seasoned - but it was not mind blowing - and certainly did not make up for the service missteps, which were acknowledged and sidestepped by staff.
In a final hope for redemption, we ordered dessert. My companion ordered the roasted apple and I ordered the chocolate cake with poached pear and hazelnut ice cream. The roasted apple was the clear winner of the two. What I thought would be a dessert plated elegantly, was presented in a trifle cup. The chocolate cake was juvenile and uncomplex, and the hazelnut flavor was lost in the sea of chocolate. The poached pear seemed misplaced.
All in all, there were many missteps and a lot of mediocrity in a restaurant that is generally held to fairly high repute in the local community.
Not sure if this was an off night, but I'm not rushing back - and I wouldn't suggest that you do, either.