OddFellows Ice Cream Co. Domino Park

I’ve been here a couple times. New flavors from the last time i was in. The passion fruit, apricot and pistachio was iconic. The strawberry roses forever was my kids favorite

Excellent service and interesting flavors. Enjoyed the vegan mango sticky rice with mochi and mint cookies. Dawn the server was extremely helpful and warm.

Location! Location! Location! Perfect spot for an ice cream shoppe. Nestled between a brewery and Roberta’s Pizza and across from the heart of Domino Park. The shoppe is spacious with high ceilings to help dispel any suffocating pandemic feelings. The outdoor seating is adorable with perfect views of Domino Park. Located on a section of River St with very little car traffic. The flavors are unique and well made and the prices are about average for the area. Some swag available and a freezer of popular flavors available for grab and go.

First of all great customer service especially by lovely and sweet tall blonde girl, I loved ice creams here, they have big choice of unusual flavors, great atmosphere and music inside!

We visited this ( I believe the original?) location tonight, not for the first time. Always delicious, unique, modern flavors. The reason I decided to leave a review tonight though is that the staff was exceptionally lovely this evening, so genuine and friendly, yet professional. A fun way to end our evening. So refreshing, thank you!

Solid ice cream joint right across the street from Domino Park with plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. Quirky, but fun vibe with decent variety of unique flavors. We got Brooklyn Blackout (chocolate on chocolate on chocolate), Strawberry (honestly a really good strawberry scoop), and Passionfruit.

ATTENTION MANAGEMENT: A bunch of us came to this location on Sat. 7/6 after dinner and this place was a mess. Used napkins on the ground in random locations on the floor, all but one napkin dispenser had 6 napkins left in the entire place, the rest were empty. All the sample spoon handles were sticky, YUK!, all the counter surfaces were sticky and unkempt. It felt like a McDonalds in there. It’s sad to see one of our favorite spots looking like this. Especially since there are other options like Gentile Gelato that is just up the block. Also, the service could’ve been a lot better especially since no other people were on line. What the 2 ladies served up was just a pulse and the bare minimum. Pleasant people should be hired when they’re the face of your business. At $10 a head for ice cream, you can do better for your patrons.

This place has a fantastic location and the flavors are creative and very well-made. The matcha and strawberry flavor was a favorite. The toppings are also delicious especially the olive oil and marshmallow fluff.