OddFellows Ice Cream Co. Domino Park

Location! Location! Location! Perfect spot for an ice cream shoppe. Nestled between a brewery and Roberta’s Pizza and across from the heart of Domino Park. The shoppe is spacious with high ceilings to help dispel any suffocating pandemic feelings. The outdoor seating is adorable with perfect views of Domino Park. Located on a section of River St with very little car traffic. The flavors are unique and well made and the prices are about average for the area. Some swag available and a freezer of popular flavors available for grab and go.

I’ve been here a couple times. New flavors from the last time i was in. The passion fruit, apricot and pistachio was iconic. The strawberry roses forever was my kids favorite

Solid ice cream joint right across the street from Domino Park with plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. Quirky, but fun vibe with decent variety of unique flavors. We got Brooklyn Blackout (chocolate on chocolate on chocolate), Strawberry (honestly a really good strawberry scoop), and Passionfruit.

I walked by on my way to Domino Park and it immediately caught my attention. They have scoops, an ice cream flight (6 scoops for $11), pints, etc. I got the flight (yes to myself) and I had grasshopper (9/10), chocotorta (7/10), bubblegum pop (10/10), something passion fruit (7/10), journey to outer spice (7/10), and I can't remember the others. The people working there were helpful and patient, plus photogenic lol Most of the flavors I got were vegan and you would never be able to tell the difference! Much less bloated than usual bc of that even after 6 scoops lol

First of all great customer service especially by lovely and sweet tall blonde girl, I loved ice creams here, they have big choice of unusual flavors, great atmosphere and music inside!

Love the location! You can enjoy your ice cream with a nice view by the river. There are a lot of interesting flavors and combinations like Olive Oil and Mandarin Jasmine. It also includes some bold topping options like the Fly by Jing chili oil.The price is pretty standard ($5.5 for single) and the scoop is generous. Excited to come back and try the other flavors!

The coffee crunch ice cream was incredible- I wish they had a vegan version of that one!! I sampled a few others and nothing else stuck out to me but I’ll definitely be back to try other seasonal flavors

They don’t have as many locations as they used to. This one on the Williamsburg waterfront is perfect for after dinner stroll or an afternoon treat. Still outstanding flavor combinations featuring saffron or miso, as well as classic peanut butter and jelly. Recent visit, OddFellows featured collab with skin care Glow Recipe and the guava eye gel.

This place was great. We were able to sample all the flavors we wanted and were able to decide on 3 pints to take home. The pints were $10 plus tax. We got the vanilla blackberry blondies, coconut mango sticky rice and exotic fruits sorbet. These flavors are really great. I am very fond of the vanilla blackberry blondie. It is nice and smooth and easy to eat. The exotic fruits sorbet sorbet os great. It has a tart and then has a sweet flavor. It is worth tasting. The coconut mango sticky rice was a big surprise but its so creamy and has small pieces of coconut and streams of mango. All delicious The staff was nice to let us taste everything and the place has lots of nice seating area.

This Oddfellows location in Domino Park surprised me with how spacious it was compared to other locations I've visited. The store was clean, and the staff was super friendly, which added to the pleasant experience. As always, Oddfellows delivers when it comes to unique flavors. This location offers a variety of options, including dairy, nondairy, vegan, and sorbet choices. The best part is that all the flavors are displayed, and you're welcome to sample before making your decision. I decided to try the mango coconut flavor, which was incredibly creamy. While I didn't taste much mango, the coconut flavor really stood out, and to my surprise, the scoop was with mochi bits! I love mochi, so that was a delightful surprise. Overall, this Oddfellows location is worth visiting if you're in Domino Park. The space, friendly service, and fun flavor combinations make it a solid choice for ice cream lovers. I'll definitely be back to try more flavors!

We were craving ice cream after dinner and came here to get a few scoops. Pretty neat that they have an ice cream flight if you want all the flavors. I got a single scoop ($6.77) of the coconut mango flavor in a waffle cone ($1.56). Good ice cream that's perfect to have while walking the waterfront at Domino Park across the street.

Another great dessert place. Well worth the trek to Brooklyn. Right on the water with great views of Manhattan. Lots of outlets if you need to charge a device and paying customers can use their bathroom. It's right by the Old Dominion Sugar Factory Park. Definitely a little quirky but I'm a fan! Try the Marshmallow Peeps soft serve!

Nom nom portions are ridiculous. Vegan flavors are amazing! So fresh, so good! And right across from domino park and next door to other half brewery. It's a win win. They also serve alcohol. Really?!

pretty solid option for ice cream. only downside is that they were out of hot fudge and Nutella. overall, the ice cream was pretty solid. i opted for the chocolate chunk which was a dark chocolate ice cream with plenty of chocolate chunks and it was really creamy and tasted fresh. and they did have many many different flavors of ice cream; probably like around 20 different flavors that you're able to sample. i did opt for the Oreo crumbles topping on mine, and I thought that the serving of toppings was less than usual. there's a lot of seating inside. overall pretty good experience. i would recommend i would definitely go back.

Staff was nice service was good but the establishment was filthy. Bathrooms disgusting no toilet paper! Floors disgusting tables dirty atleast make sure your customers are able to sit down in a clean place what happened guys! No porters no one mops floors or cleans bathrooms or table tops! Please do better if you are charging premium price for ice cream we expect better clean establishment to sit at.

We decided to try a few flavors that they had and were delightfully surprised at how tasty they were. My favorite was the peanut butter smores and my friends were the mint cookies and vegan coconut caramel chip. All were pretty good. Would order from here again.

Love this location! It's huge and all the staff are really nice. They have a wide selection of flavors and toppings so there is something for everyone. My favorite is the soft serve! They have "happy hour" discounts during the week, which is nice because it is definitely on the pricier side. Perfect location across from the park during the summer.

Cute, retro-diner-looking ice cream shop just off Domino Park. There's a large empty space inside to stand around but only a handful of diner booths to sit at. But since it's so close to the park, it's nice to just take it and walk or sit along the water. The staff is super friendly and encouraged us to try as many flavors as we wanted! A scoop was about $7. I got the Fudgy Tiramisu - which was good, but not mindblowing. It tasted like a light version of tiramisu, in that it wasn't overpowering but definitely there.

I've been a fan of Oddfellows from the beginning, and even threw a private party at the DUMBO location with unlimited scoops and even some boozy shakes a couple of years ago. The base cream is rich and the flavors are incredible. Banoffee pie, cheddar apple pie, and kitchen sink are especially noteworthy. Whether you like your ice cream with a lot of fillings and texture like I do or if you like a simpler, straightforward ice cream they'll have something for you. They even have soft serve, and a robust vegan menu that includes excellent flavors like chocolate peanut butter pretzel, coconut caramel chip, and matcha latte. Nothing here is an afterthought and they've managed to scale well across multiple locations. This one is perfect for summer days spent at Domino Park. There are occasional nightlife parties hosted here too. Their CPG product holds up well and I always have a pint or two stocked in my fridge on rotation with Malai, Caffe Panna, and Ample Hills. All of NY's best ice cream shops and Oddfellows is among the prestige ones.

Good ice cream. A bit pricey but has good variety of ice cream. I would say the best in the area. The ice cream is creamy and thick

Went into the store on a scorching Tuesday afternoon and was greeted by three very engaging young workers. The atmosphere was warm and inviting thanks to three people named Hudson, Jameson, and Senica. Amazing spot to stop by with your family or friends and delicious, high-quality ice cream. Music was on point as well. 5/5

Sunny days are ice cream days. Walked by domino park and swung over for a scoop of Passion fruit with pistachios on a cone. It was fruity, tart, creamy with random chunks of pistachios. It did not enhance my flavor experience. Think I would've liked it better as crushed or swirl but overall tasty. The space is pretty large and the staff was nice and allowed me to sample some before committing.

Two scoops in four hours has to be a record! We did a park layout last Saturday and spot happened to be just in front of Oddfellows which was perfect for grabbing ice cream. The first time I went in for vanilla bean but it was still too frozen so I went with vanilla w/ sprinkles and a chocolate drizzle. I really wanted a Nutella drizzle but they were out of it and out of caramel syrup. I also tried a sample of the miso peanut butter ice cream but I wasn't a fan. I only gave Oddfellows four stars because they were out of so many items and it sucked having to go back an hour later just for vanilla bean ice cream.

Great to see this location by Domino Park. It was so hot that we wanted to cool off with some amazing ice cream while we were strolling to the park. Oddfellows always has fun flavors to choose from - apologies to the employees for being indecisive and taking forever. We chose the Coffee Crunch and the Coffee Whiskey Smoked Almond on a waffle cone to share after much deliberation. It was really good - thankfully not overly sweet. The only annoying part is that the ice cream melts rather quickly compared to other brands and it gets messy. Make sure you grab a few napkins...one will not suffice.

Was in the area on a date. Had just had an amazing dinner and was ready for desert. Stopped into this location to check out the variety of options. Flavors range from classic: vanilla, chocolate, mint chocolate chip etc to gourmet: olive oil. They were definitely missing some signature flavors like rum raisin, chocolate chip and cookie dough so I went for what felt safe: sweet cream with sprinkles. Not a fan of sprinkles but the server assured me that I wouldn't taste them and she was right. It was super rich and creamy. A notch above Coldstone I'd say. Bae had the Mint chocolate and had to steal some it was so good. I will definitely revisit this spot. Prices were on par to the quality and service was personable.

This is definitely an odd one, oddly delish. A good lock on a sunny spring almost bummer afternoon. The Domino Park location is the best in terms of perfect view by the river. During this visit, I tried the passion fruit, apricot and pistachio flavor and vegan coconut caramel chip. I really enjoyed the passion fruit one. The tartness is perfect to balance the sweetness and the added crunch of pistachios gives the perfect punch of cold treat. Drop by and get a scoop of a sweet and odd delight

The location of this ice cream shop is superb, right across from the Domino Park strip. I stopped in with my boyfriend to grab some icecream and use the bathroom. Note that the line gets pretty long around 9 to 9:30pm when we went on a Sunday, and cookies and cream was all sold out. It was pretty unfortunate since cookies and cream is my all time fave. Oh well. There's always next time! I got the dark chocolate chunk and while it was rich and the chunks were yummy, it just didn't hit the same...but it was good! Pro tip: The bathroom door says you must be a customer to access the bathroom, but I've seen people ask the cashier and workers for the pin number to open the bathroom and they are all nice and give you the pin number, in case you were looking for a bathroom nearby!

OddFellows was born from odd pregnancy cravings. The wife of one of the creators wanted savory ice cream she couldn't find anywhere in stores. So her husband contacted a chef friend, and OddFellows emerged. The original shop is in Williamsburg, but they are now so successful that they are in other parts of NYC and several other states, and ship through GoldBelly. I've had tons of flavors and I'm always excited to see what they do next. The buttery, velvety olive oil (it's good, I swear!). The crunchy, candy-filled or chocolate-filled bodega collection. Pistachio cardamom is another favorite of ours. They have a cake & pie collection (key lime, ricotta lemon sponge cake, and more). They have some that are more like fruity sherbet (exotic fruits). They also have a classics collection for those less adventurous (vanilla, chocolate, cookies & milk). They do a lot of fun celeb collaborations. ODB is their newest one and I'm excited to try it! The ice cream/ingredients are high quality. Creamy. Rich. Luxurious. You can't find them anywhere else. And if you can't get to a brick and mortar store, they arrive to your door fast, fresh, and frozen from GoldBelly.

Nice little ice cream shop next to Domino Park! The workers let us sample whatever flavors we wanted, which was very nice. I ended up getting the Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio ice cream. I highly recommend getting ice cream here then walking the park.

I love me some some cream. Oddfellows offers some delicious creamy flavors. Vegan and soft serve options too. After a good long run into Brooklyn I was headed to the Williamsburg Bridge and happened on this location. Great spot across Domino Park to have a cone and walk around with it by the waterfront. Fun interior with some seating. Super friendly staff. Decent prices for quality ice cream. I had a cone of the Cinnamon dulce de leche and it was just what I needed after a sweaty workout. Yum.

This ice cream shop has a perfect after-meal dessert monopoly in the area. As it's name would imply, expect to come across very "odd" flavors of ice cream, sorbets, and "vegan" ice cream. The server was very kind and did recommend the $11 flight which was to include 6 generous scoops of ice cream. From the flight, the Cookies N' Cream was a sweet one for nostalgia sake, the mint an interesting addition but overall not too distracting. Both the Dark Chocolate Chunk and Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio each quite powerful in taste -- one very rich and the other quite tart. Quite the treat for anyone who fancies the depth of flavor. The Matcha Passion Coconut just tasted like Coconut to me, nothing else. A delightful treat nonetheless and perfect for any after dinner meal whether it is cold or warm outside.

Very excited to have OddFellows back in Williamsburg at a beautiful new location right next to Domino Park and just a few blocks from the original one that closed a year or so ago. Right next to the Roberta's, this is also a huge space with high ceilings and all the same great ice cream they always make. Always get the Chocotorta.

I like oddfellows, I love their different ice cream flavors. However, I hate that any time I go I never find the banana pudding flavor. It's like they hooked me but now I can't ever get it. They have others that I've enjoyed but I really liked the banana pudding. The service is always good.

Bomb . Great vegan options. Get the sticky rice mango sorbet like wowwwwwwww. And amazing toppings too.

Very unique flavors on their menu - if you wanted something simple like vanilla, you won't be able to find it. I always like doing flights at ice cream shops so you can try a variety! The flights come with a choice of 6 flavors. Line was out the door on a friday night, but moves fairly quickly.

Rude staff, and mediocre ice cream. If this was the only ice cream place in town, you'd probably put up with it, but it isn't. If you're desperate for a cone, it'll do, but life is short--do yourself a favor and go anywhere else.

I walked by on my way to Domino Park and it immediately caught my attention. They have scoops, an ice cream flight (6 scoops for $11), pints, etc. I got the flight (yes to myself) and I had grasshopper (9/10), chocotorta (7/10), bubblegum pop (10/10), something passion fruit (7/10), journey to outer spice (7/10), and I can't remember the others. The people working there were helpful and patient, plus photogenic lol Most of the flavors I got were vegan and you would never be able to tell the difference! Much less bloated than usual bc of that even after 6 scoops lol

HOW DOES THIS PLACE NOT HAVE MORE REVEIWS?! Omg this place was so cute. They had a seating area outside that a disco ball which was adorable. Then I go inside because it was so hot and I needed something to drink. The place inside is even cuter. It is def a vintage vibe back to the 70's and it was so cute. The only downside is they only had one employee which I felt bad for him because they were busy. I didn't try the ice cream but I got the root beer which was so good. They even let me use the bathroom which was clean and spacious which is perfect because I had my baby. Would I return? ABSOLUTELY. They also had seating so this place is perfect for a date!

Great location next to Domino Park if you're feeling a nice treat. They had an assortment of unique flavors, which all sounded good, so I feel that you can't go wrong if you go with a classic like cookies and cream and sprinkles or a specialty like grasshopper (pistachio base chocolate ice cream with cookies) and matcha passion fruit, which are the two that I got. The staff were very friendly. Would recommend coming here for your sweet craving!

They have some funky fun flavors to choose from. I was able to get 2 flavors in a single scoop! I ordered a chocolate flavor and coffee mix. The Oreo mint that my sister got was delicious. There's a level of creamy goodness in the texture. The location is directly from the water so you can enjoy some great views!

I've been wanting to try this ice cream place for so long now. I'm so happy I finally got to go. There are so many fun flavors here including vegan options. It is next to the pier so you can take a nice walk with the ice cream, highly recommend coming at night when it's less hot! Pro tip: don't worry if you're lactose intolerant, they have lactaid available for sale at the counter!

Was curious what the Yelp reviews on this place would be after my experience today and to no surprise I see there are also reviews mentioning rude staff and the location being out of flavors. Rude staff: I asked to sample three flavors and listed them off since I knew which ones I would want to try. Before I could even finish asking the staff member interrupted and said "Nah. One per person." with a heavy amount of attitude / pissed-off tone of voice. Guess if someone wanted to order a triple scoop and try 3 flavors they're out of luck..lol Out of flavors: I ended up ordering a single scoop of the coffee crunch, waited around for about a minute and a half for him to try to locate it in the back and it was out. At this point I was done with this place and left without getting anything, not about to pay for rudeness especially when they were out of the flavor I wanted. I tried a bite of my friend's chocolate scoop and it wasn't great -- too sweet and she thought the same.

Pretty creamy and delicious. They had a photo shoot or commercial going on when I went in.

I've been to another Oddfellows before and was not a fan (mainly because the flavors seemed to try too hard to be unique but didn't necessarily try to taste good), so when I came to this location I decided to order a very normal flavor and was much more pleased. It wasn't my favorite ice cream, but it wasn't a terrible experience like my other one.

A pretty cool place to check out. Located just opposite Dominos park and right next to Roberta's pizza this is an awesome place to check out for dessert. So many flavors to choose from. In the ended I thought the ice cream flight option will give me the best choice of flavors. For $10 I was able to choose up to 6 flavors. Awesome! If you go for this option then I would suggest eating it quick as when it melts all the flavors are combined together.

I walked by this after hanging out at domino park. I was glad to see that this place was open until pretty late on a wednesday evening! For some reason, that night I had such a strong craving for lemonade. I ended up stopping by here with a friend and I tried the strawberry lemonade sorbet. It hit the spot and the texture reminds me almost of a gelato. Maybe it actually was and I missed that detail. Regardless, I enjoyed my icecream a lot and I also found the staff very friendly and welcoming. Inside is also a very spacious and nice environment to hang out. I definitely would stop by again!

Popped in for soft serve chocolate ice cream on a cone. I think the ice cream is vegan. I'm not certain. It was missing the richness and creaminess I'd expect in chocolate ice cream. It reminded me sugar free chocolate sorbet. Cone was lackluster too.

Came here on a packed memorial day, waited about 15 minutes to order 20 minutes all together.Only 3 guys at the counter. Had never been here before but my girls wanted ice cream and honestly did I. lol There was an ice cream truck at the corner but me personally i don't like soft serve . Anyway hubby and eldest daughter ordered dark chocolate chunk on a cone as soon as i gave it to him outside the cone fell ( i think they packed so much ice cream lol ) he was holding it with his hand they were very nice to give us cups and spoons. Boy what a mess!!! But a very enjoyable moment. Me and youngest got the cookie and cream and oh my delicious.. Will definitely come again . Just didn't like waiting so long .

My little brother & I bought the cookies & cream ice cream with chocolate sprinkles. Within 2 minutes my little brother felt nauseous & threw up badly. I felt a little nauseous and we both threw the ice cream in the trash. When we first tasted the ice cream something tasted off about it. It tasted old & stale. I was expecting it to taste amazing with the high price but it caused us to get sick from it. Disappointed. Please throw out that entire bucket of cookies & cream please. Even now my stomach feels messed up.

One-sentence summary: When it comes to ice cream in Brooklyn, Odd Fellows is as good as it gets.

Got a flight (best deal IMO!) to share. Our favorite flavors were chocotorta (cream cheese chocolate), olive oil, and Brooklyn blackout (basically chocolate on chocolate). Decadent, unique, and just the right sweetness! I also enjoyed the grapefruit bergamot flavor (just be aware that it's slightly alcoholic). Matcha passion fruit and strawberry basil lemonade sorbet were ok, not bad but nothing special, but maybe I was in the mood for good old creamy ice cream that day.

Nice people, great location. Walked a minute to domino park and enjoyed a scoop of the pistachio cardamom caramel. The flavor was really unique and the texture was spot on! With such a strange flavor combination, I wasn't expecting it work together so well. It wasn't overly sweet and the flavor was delicious. Would come again if I'm in the area!

Great Icecream spot. Great I'm not a big chocolate lover but I highly recommend the Brooklyn blackout Icecream

Rude staff. , a lack of clear organisation when attempting to order followed by an unnecessarily rude and confrontational server when just confirming that i wanted my order in a waffle cone. The overall experience left a bad taste to the point I didn't even want my order.

Overall, okay. As others have mentioned, they were out of a few flavors, especially the vegan ones. Not ideal, when this is one of the reasons I tried out this place. Other than that, the ice cream was fine. Nothing special, just your run-of-the-mill, overpriced, artisanal or whatever ice cream. Service is fine. Just all around, alright. Nothing special.

I had the greatest ice cream experience of my life at Odd Fellows. I love the vibe of this place: watching the vintage tv while I waited in line, fun music, and the greatest customer service I've ever received. Megan deserves a special shout-out for her great attitude and excellent flavor recommendations! I can't wait to come back soon and try a double scoop of passionfruit and olive oil!

Coming from some very unsatisfying service at Roberta's next door, it was great to be given very friendly service here. (Perhaps surprising considering it was just 10-15 minutes before closing.) The ice cream was very good, as you expect from any Odd Fellows location, but the service made the ice cream even sweeter.