Regina N.
Yelp
Old Town is hands down my favorite local spot for pizza, craft beers, and just having a good time. I think of Old Town every time I'm craving pizza, and it's always my last meal before I go on a keto diet because it's just . that . satisfying.
Crust/Pizza Dough 5/5*
I usually prefer Sicilian style pizzas with that thicker pan crust, but Old Town's crust is something else! Don't let the plain ol' looking crust fool you. They got the perfect crisp to fluffiness texture ratio, with a cornmeal dusted bottom, and there is actually a flavor to it! This is one crust you don't want to leave on your plate.
No Sleep Til Brooklyn 5/5*
My go-to. Somehow I always end up gravitating back towards this no matter how much I try to switch it up. I love ricotta and basil, and the tender, juicy, subtle flavor of the meatballs pair perfectly.
Chuck Norris 5/5*
How do they stack so many different kinds of protein on this?! It's like a meat market had a baby! And somehow there is still so much red sauce and gooey cheese to balance it all out. Honorable mention goes out to the linguica and meatballs. Phenomenal. Even though there are loads of meats and bacon, it isn't overly salty Iike the Angry Swine.
Mushroom Mayhem 5/5*
This is the best simple veggie pizza I have ever had. There isn't much variety on the toppings, but you can taste each and every one of them.. earthy juicy mushroom, truffle oil that you could actually smell AND taste, spinach, and garlicky sauce.
The Angry Swine 2/5*
They like to pack on the bacon here. Great for bacon lovers, but waaay too salty for me.
Who You Callin' Chicken 3/5*
As expected with chicken, this wasn't as flavorful as some of the other specialty pizzas. I added pesto to amp up the flavors, but it wasn't memorable.
Paco Fries 3/5*
These fries definitly pack a punch. The portion size is insane! They're like Jack's Urban Fries' on steriods.. LOADED with bacon, blue cheese, chili oil and flakes, parsley, green onions, and sauce. The bacon, blue cheese, and fries pairing is really salty, though, and after a while my mouth was begging for veggies or something to cut the salt.
Garlic Parmesan Fries 5/5*
Tons of garlic and real parmesan. Again, huge portions.
Ranch 5/5*
Who rates ranch you're thinking? I do! If you love ranch, you know not all ranches are created equal. This is the buttermilk variety and has a great consistency for dipping your pizzas and fries in. Hell, even that crust that you thought about leaving on your plate. They aren't skimpy here.. if you ask for it, they will give you plenty. Maybe that's not a good thing, since I can drink this stuff up.
This place gets packed, especially on game days and trivia night, so get there early to snag a seat.
Old Town is consistently delicious and they are so accommodating and awesome! I have never been able to order half and half on a small 8" pizza anywhere before. It's a great way to try all their pizzas. I can't even count how many times I have been here...and still counting.