Oldestone Steakhouse

We visited on Saturday for my birthday. Terrific atmosphere and delicious food. The sweet potato souflee was spectacular! Loved all the stained glass windows and the huge painting (we ate in the dining room upstairs) Service was spectacular. Can’t wait to visit again! Thanks for the great experience.

Wow! What a great choice for a nice Christmas dining experience!! My wife always wanted to dine here. First is the decor. Well decorated for Christmas. Such a beautiful converted old church into a restaurant. We have had drinks in the bar area on the 1st. floor here, some years back and loved it. So we made our dinner reservations for Christmas night 2024. We were directed to the upstairs dining room. It was gorgeous! The atmosphere, the decorations. As we were being seated, we noticed our jingle bell on a lanyard at our beautiful place settings. Great touch! As was the Christmas music playing in the background. The entire staff was friendly from our hostess (who also can check in your coats) to our servers Michael & Max. Michael & Max were excellent. They were very attentive to any of our needs. They were very friendly & professional. Michael gave us the best suggestions for our meals & dessert. The steaks he suggested were excellent. He was so knowledgeable of the differences of how they were prepared. They came prepared perfectly. The sides we ordered were great. I loved the sautéed spinach & mashed potatoes. Delicious. A garlic hint in both. I figured I may finish my 20 oz. steak, but I was surprised to see my wife finish hers. It was that good. The dessert was a 24 Ct. (Carrot) Cake. Wow! It tasted delicious. The icing drizzled across it just made it perfect. Our compliments to the Chef & The Baker!!! Thanks so much to Michael, Max & the entire staff. I worked a job for years that took me away from family & friends at Christmas time. We appreciate you being there so my wife and I (and we could see many of other people seated around us) have a wonderful (Christmas) dining experience. Looking forward to a future return visit.

Food was delicious definitely had a diverse menu. The artistry in the architecture of the Old church is such a great touch to the atmosphere. The steak was great I definitely recommend to my beef lovers. Surf and turf for those who don’t mind spending a little more.

We went here on a date night and were super impressed. Very cool building from the outside, but the upstairs main dining room was stunning. We had a medium rare filet which was beautifully seared in the outside and cooked perfectly inside. My salmon was cooked house temperature, which was a little more done than I'd prefer, but shame on me for forgetting to specify my temp. Cocktails were great. It was a the perfect beginning to our night French onion soup was bomb, as was the spinach dip .

My wife and I sat in the cozy, interesting bar area. Comfortable high top and stools…funky art…beautiful stained glass windows. 5 stars! Our waitress was friendly and, for the most part, efficient, although I think water glasses need to be kept filled, esp. when the place isn’t busy. 4-5 stars My wife had the chopped salad appetizer. An interesting presentation and delicious! My onion soup was…very good…the broth was excellent but the onions were sparse. 4 stars Her filet was cooked to order (medium rare) on a simple, hot plate…and the filet was the same. Simple…nothing out-of-the-ordinary. At the price, it should have been more tender, we felt. 3-4 stars My Kansas City Strip was very good, but I’ve had better. Overall, a nice experience but, at Manhattan prices ($60 and $70-80…total bill $230 plus)we expect to be wowed…

Best steak (filet mignon) I’ve ever had. We’ve ever had. Went with my mother on her last week here in the US before going back home, she wanted a good steak more than anything as she’s a huge steak lover. Happened to stumble upon this place while staying for a night in New Hope and taking a stroll at night. Everything was divine and perfect, from the drinks and service to the appetizers, dessert and of course the steaks. Already planning the next visit to New Hope just for this steak

UPDATE: dinner in 4/26/25 was absolutely exceptional. Freddie was our server and the service was fantastic. Steaks were cooked perfectly. I've seen some of the negative reviews. As to slow service, this is definitely not a fast casual restaurant. The service is exceptional if you enjoy relaxing over an incredible meal. Corey and Mason were an exceptional team who waited on us. They got the perfect balance right of not being intrusive but never having to look for them. We had calamari and the meatballs with Alfredo sauce. Calamari was cooked perfectly and was very light. The meatballs were incredibly tender and the light Alfredo sauce with a little melted Parmesan cheese was excellent. Our steaks were cooked to perfection. The potato casserole and brussel sprouts were excellent sides. Creme brulee was excellent and the real whipped cream in the Irish coffee was a nice touch. Everything we ordered came out piping hot. Bartender made a perfect Vesper martini as well. We were at our table for a little more than two hours, and we thoroughly enjoyed it. We will be back, for sure!

Simply fantastic Anniversary dinner. Food was delicious: French onion soup may have been the best we’ve ever had. Petit filets were seasoned and cooked to perfection. Yummy bread pudding for desert. Wine & drinks were great. The atmosphere at Oldestone is fantastic but it is the service that sets this restaurant apart. Mason, our server, was knowledgeable, engaging, efficient, charming, and uber professional. He helped make our Anniversary that much more special. The busser was also pleasant and professional and the restaurant manager stopped by to ensure everything was as we expected. Love this place and can’t wait to return!