Vivian C.
Yelp
More of a 3.5... but the large plates brought it up to a 4. We're always trying to find new places to try. So, a seasonal menu with small plates (we love ordering a slew of small bites!), a laidback and casual vibe AND super close to where we live? We were sold :)
When we called a couple days before to try and make a reservation, they sadly told us that they were booked; however, they always saved some tables for walk-ins. We decided to risk it and rushed from work. We were lucky as we were able to get a prime spot overlooking the hustle and bustle of Angel. Soon after, the other tables downstairs filled up and people began to get turned away! There were a few tables even set up outside for those brave enough to weather the cold. It's best to book as the space is really small. Probably enough for 10 downstairs with seating for maybe an additional 20 upstairs. I was able to check out the upstairs as that is where the bathroom was and it felt really cramped. I actually much preferred the downstairs which due to the large glass entryway brought in a good amount of light, making the room feel a bit more airy.
We decided to start with some cocktails. I had the spotless martini which was described as a gin martini served dry with a twist, olive or pickled onion (£9) and Adam was in the mood for the Oldroyd mary - Oldroyd spiced vodka, chipotle & fresh tomato, pickled pepper (£8). We both love a good Bloody Mary but it's definitely been difficult in London. The one at Oldroyd was good, not the best but definitely one of the better ones we've had. As per usual, even though Adam asked for it spicy, there was no spice to be found. A couple shakes of Tabasco and it was pretty good. My martini was really nice and well-made though very tiny. It was almost laughable the size of the glass when it came to the table. BUT, it was a really strong drink, so I don't think I needed a hi-ball glass of it :D
As we looked over the small menu (4 small plates/appetizers, 6 large plates/mains and 2 sides) everything sounded really fantastic. We opted to start with two of the small plates: the smoked pork belly & pea croquettas, truffle mayonnaise (£4) and the Mazzancolle prawn alla griglia, gremolata (£3.50 each). We love a good croquetta and this one was freshly fried. While the truffle mayonnaise was superb, the croquetta was underwhelming as it was pretty bland. We couldn't taste any smokiness and if we didn't know what was supposed to be in the croquetta, there was no way we could have guessed. The prawn was fresh but, unfortunately, slightly overcooked and the shell was burned in places. This lead to a bitterness that made this dish unappetizing.
We were feeling a bit underwhelmed at this point and were nervous as we had ordered 4 of the large plates. However, Oldroyd completely redeemed themselves with the large plates. The Cornish crab tagliarini provencal, brown crab rouille (£9) was incredible. The pasta was so thin and delicate and the sauce with the fresh and sweet crab were perfect. We thought about ordering another. Definitely get this if you go. The lamb & almond meatballs, salsa romesco & pickled garlic (£7.50) was another highlight. The meatballs were flavorful, tender and moist (hate a dry meatball!) and the pickled garlic was such a nice surprise adding some acidity to cut through the fattiness of the dish. The addition of almond in the meatballs was also fantastic and we loved the crunch it added. We also ordered the mackerel, beetroot & horseradish (£9). The fish was cooked really well but, it was a bit of an unmemorable dish. Lastly, we opted for the grilled pork ribeye, lentils & salsa verde (£14). This was so delicious. The pork was cooked perfectly - tender and juicy and went really well with the homemade salsa verde. The lentils were still firm but retained great flavor. This was a definite standout as well. We also thought we should get something to balance all of this meat and opted for the heritage tomato & green bean salad, béarnaise reduction (£4.50). The mix of tomatoes were sweet and fresh and went well with the crunchy and sweet green beans. We loved the béarnaise reduction with the tart flavors in balancing the sweetness of the other components.
After all of that, there was no way we would be able to order dessert, though they had a selection of four desserts with one being a cheese plate. While there were a couple of issues with our starters, the large plates were fantastic overall. It's definitely a nice addition to the area, so stop by and order a bunch of plates (especially the tagliarini and pork!).