Rebecca K.
Yelp
When researching best restaurants in New Haven (that weren't pizza places), Olea consistently showed up, so we had to check it out. We were very enticed by their tasting menu (nothing makes me happier than the restaurant making my selections for me), but we were disappointed to learn they only offer this menu on Tuesdays and Thursdays and we would be in town over the weekend. Oh well, no big - we made reservations for Saturday night very easily. They have a large enclosed seating area that sits in what looks like their parking lot. This was a great spot - the waiters had most things they needed in the area, and we felt safe in the space while still having a good experience. They did not rush us at all, but the food did come relatively quickly, so that helped expedite the meal itself.
In terms of food, Olea has a lot of Spanish influences on their menu, featuring a good number of tapas but also larger dishes. We wanted to focus on the tapas, so we wound up getting 3 tapas to split between the 2 of us, as well as an entree to also split between the 2 of us. This was definitely plenty of food! For starters, our server brought us complimentary taster - I can't remember the name, but it tasted like a combination of egg, cheese, and potato encased in what seemed like a mini muffin tin. It was pretty basic, but still nice and light. For our selected tapas, we opted for the gazpacho, ceviche, and croquetas. The gazpacho was unique in that we were presented with a mixture of veggies in a dish, and then our server poured the "soup" overtop, followed by the bread crisp and almond foam. A unique take, but very nicely done! The ceviche was very fresh and authentic, and the cheesy "air" on top was a great finishing touch. However, the croquetas were the standouts - featuring oxtail beef, mushrooms, carmelized onions, and brussel sprouts, they were excellent. The flavors were so complex yet the dish was so welcoming. We were big fans! For our main dish, we split the suckling pig, which we would highly recommend. The meat was tender and perfectly crispy, and it sat atop a cheesy potato plank that was quite nice. I would never think to order pig at a restaurant, but we were both incredibly happy we did and would certainly get again. For drinks, we both got glasses of tempraniillo wine, which was nicely spicy and hearty to compliment our meal. Lastly, because we were celebrating our anniversary, we got complimentary small pastries to finish our meal - a nice gesture!
Overall, we agree that Olea is a great finer dining spot in New Haven. I would definitely recommend getting a number of tapas to share, certainly getting the croquetas. If you want an entree as well, highly recommend the pig for a unique dish. We really enjoyed our meal at Olea to celebrate our anniversary, and we would love to make it back on future visits!