Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches

We were really happy we stopped in! A little out of the way, but worth the time. We got an order of the Greek fries, the orzo harvest salad, and a make your own pizza. Everything was very fresh and good! I have e a hard time finding pizza I like and this was pretty decent! This is the fiest pizza in along time I would consider coming back to order again. Overall, we really enjoyed our meal!

Clean and convenient place for pizza or sandwiches. Our 1st time here. Everything was hot and good. Cheese curds delicious. Salad could've had the spring greens cut a little smaller for easier eating. Hand tossed extra pepperoni, extra cheese was delicious.

The food was great and the service was quick! Had the chicken Tilly with some curly fries and the sandwich was fantastic, me and my friend will def be stopping by again.

Wonderful MUST STOP local eatery! Owner is fantastic and the remodel turned out beautifully. Open, clean, inviting space. Food is superb and drinks are great. Prices are competitive and not outrageous for the quality of food you get. Made after you order so everything is fresh. So lucky to have this in our neighborhood! Make sure to get a giant cookie for dessert!

Stopped by for lunch as I have been curious about Olive’s. Totally worth trying out and the food was great. A bonus is that they have a “what to expect” at the door for us introverted-types that don’t like to feel awkward. Totally made the experience better! The turkey sub was amazing and I for certain will return.

Bit chilly and music a tad loud but other than that great experience overall. Best pizza we've had in years. Will definitely visit again when in the area.

Great local pizza joint. Friendly owner with super tasty pizza on a thin crust. Tried one deluxe and one sausage mushroom. Both were excellent. They bake their own sub buns, so we will try one next time.

My family and I had a great time at Olives. The food was amazing, and service was excellent. We definitely will be back again!

This place is nice. Sandwiches are great and i love the bread. The have a nice setup inside which is great for families. Easy parking also.

We were running errands down in Green Bay recently and searched yelp for a high rated sandwich, shop and landed at Olives. What a hidden gem, a half mile off the highway, but you may need your GPS to navigate to it. Being from New England originally, I was delighted to find what they carried main lobster rolls for a limited time, so I had to order one of those and then we ordered a spicy Italian sub and split both for variety. Both sandwiches were superb, and the lobster rolls were significantly less expensive than the small handful of places that you can find them here in Northeast Wisconsin. The place was fairly empty because we got there well after lunch hour, but we were surprised to not see anyone else in there because this place is far better than most other options, including, but not limited to the corporate franchise options like subway, Jimmy John's, firehouse, subs, etc. Nothing beats Local small business owned restaurants like this! The staff was very friendly, and although the place was empty, they were processing a bunch of phone orders and we've watched a bunch of people come through for pick ups. Our sandwiches were prepared within five minutes, and they were absolutely delicious! We highly recommend this place and plan to go back next time we're off the Door Peninsula and down in that Green Bay area around lunch.

I'd rate you 5 stars for the food. But marked you down for reserving the 10 closest parking spots for curbside pickup. You prioritize pickup, then you wonder why your server jobs are eliminated. Lol

Very nice staff this Saturday for lunch. We order two hand tossed pizzas and a flatbread gourmet pizza...all really good.

This might be the best pizza in Green Bay! Crispy hand tossed crust supporting an exceptionally well spiced sauce and generous toppings. Plus, the staff is fast and friendly.

Great place run by a family I suppose. The kids working here are great, the spot is pristine and kept super clean and the sandwiches are pretty dope. Service is five stars. Give it a shot if you're in the area.

Friendly service! The pizza was very tasty with just the right amount of sauce. Place was clean and bright.

The food is delicious!! Pizza selection is awesome and the staff are all very friendly and courteous!

Very good pizza. The meat pizza was great. The margarita pizza could have used more cheese and the fresh mozzarella should have been broken up a bit more. We will be back, though, as it was great sauce and crust.

Stop in to try a new pizza place. I have high expectations for pizza because there are so many places. At Olive's you order at the counter and pick a seat they bring the food and drinks to your table then. The service is very good but also you can tell that many are new. I'm sure it will improve but it wasn't bad at all. The flatbread pizza was good and thin. It had a lot of cheese on it but honestly I didn't get a lot of flavor. The pizza is a thin bottom but a chewiness in the middle. My wife didn't like it at all but she likes thin crust. I didn't hate it but it isn't my go to for a pizza. I will say though it's very filling. The interior is nice but very basic. Metal and hard surfaces. It feels like a fast food restaurant but the food seems like it should be a more comfortable setting.

Amazing hand tossed pizza and wonderful service on a Sunday. The white sauce was delicious and just the right amount of cheese! Definitely worth the stop.

Super easy and fast, and delicious. Especially if you like a thicker crust the hand tossed was great. Wish there would have been more bbq on the bbq pizza but still good flavor.

Wow, how great was that? Excellent service, amazing sandwich and clean little cafe like interior. I'm from LA just passing through and am really glad I stopped in for lunch. Thank you Carrie!!

Loved our subs from Olives. 4 of us came for lunch and had a variety of sandwiches. Next time we want to try the pizza. It looked delicious as well.

Great menu, Great people. Next to an excellent art studio. Must stop if traveling through GB, DePEre, Bellevue or any suburb in the area. You won't be disappointed. I travel a LOT. Live in Kansas. This is a great place, great atmosphere and excellent food!

We were in town visiting from San Francisco and this place has amazing pizza and great enviornment. The workers are extremely friendly and patient. There's a bit of a wait on the food but it's more than worth it because the pizza is priced very well and extremely fresh, hot, delicious and cheesy!

Excellent with each item made at the time of ordering. I had chicken/pesto flatbread and my husband had a chicken sun type sandwich! Service was excellent, friendly and prompt. Wine and beer list extensive! Will definitely be back!

First time here at Olive's and all the food we ordered was amazing. The cowboy bites were superb as was the garlic cheese bread. We ordered three different types of flatbread and all of them were delicious. Loved the thin cracker crust of the flatbread.

Newest pizza joint in Green Bay Area. It is phenomenal!! The menu is very creative with fresh ingredients. And the price is very reasonable as well. If you haven't tried this place yet you might have to ask yourselves why not. The crust has a nice char on the bottom that brings me back to New York. The sandwiches were also amazing. The inside is very clean and the staff is incredibly friendly. You have to get here soon.

Hidden gem of Green Bay, easily one of the best subs if not the best. Comparable to Scott's subs with better quality meat, 3x more meat, Better bread and half the wait time!! The owner and staff are very friendly. This is a must try with a nice modern design!!!

The subs are amazing, home made rolls, special seasonings and fresh ingredients. The homemade onion rings were great too, not greasy. Loved the atmosphere and staff is super friendly. Our new favorite sub place!

What an AMAZING experience with Olive's, even though it started out a little rough--but not from their doing! We are in town for our child's DI tournament and a local pizza shop was the goal for dinner! We ordered the cheesesteak pizza for mom and dad, and the Hawaiian for the kids. Delivery--through DoorDash--was expected about 30-40 minutes later. But, about 40 minutes later, I received a text that said our order was modified or cancelled. So I called Olive's. DoorDash declined to deliver our order!!! This could have been a terrible headache! But, the lady I was talking to said she was making sure the pizzas were hot, and then she'd be bringing the pizzas herself!!! And there was no charge for the pizzas. When the pizzas arrived, she refused to take any payment. I wanted to pay, but she didn't! What an amazing woman and business! Now, for the pizzas....oh my goodness! Yum! Especially the cheesesteak pizza! The steak was thin sliced and tender, the sauce was rich and flavorful with a hit of heat, and the peppers, onions, and cheese were the perfect pairing. The hand-tossed crust was amazing on both pizzas. My kids both loved these pizzas--and they both ate a full slice of the cheesesteak--it was that incredible! Thank you, Olive's, for an incredible dinner! To the employee who delivered --I hope your Saturday got better and you get a drink! (And I'm definitely getting your pizza the next time we're in GB!)

So excited to have a new pizza place in the neighborhood!! The open kitchen meets you on the way in - stop here to order, then find a seat in the bright and comfortable dining area. There is a bar with wine, beer and cocktails to accompany your meal. The vegetarian options are great not your typical green pepper, onion, olive, blah blah... think caramelized onions, olive tapenade, blue cheese, artichoke hearts... 3 different sauce options... so exciting! The pizzas are cooked in a stone oven giving a crusty yet chewy bite. I'm easily a fan.

Dumpy little strip mall with a new secret. The sub was delicious and the service top notch. New and clean. Give it a try!

Didn't know they were here. I got the Cal Sub! Delicious flavor! Great service. I'll be back with my wife for a pizza and wine.

Clean, friendly, and delicious! The subs bring me back to some other "greatest hits" such as Hansen's and Zeppelin's. The flatbreads and pizza is equally delicious. All nestled in quaint Allouez. What a gem! So lucky to have this in Green Bay.

First time at Olives and won't be my last. What a awesome place this is ! When you walk in the door and see the fresh bread , you know it's going to be good . From the super friendly service to getting our food fast , couldn't ask for anything better . My wife loves spinach and I think I'm a fan of it now. Everything melted in your mouth and the flavors were spectacular ! We live an hour away, but will be back soon to try there pizza next !!

Love their sandwiches! Owner Carrie typically there and is very warm and welcoming. Artichoke sandwich is my fav. Great place for sandwiches

I tried this place since it's next to Zestys ice cream! The menu is pretty expansive and has a big wine selection too! I had a chicken parm sub and it was really big, really well toasted, and fresh tasting. Not too hard and not too soggy! I had a cookie as well, which was good! I think the pricing is fair and the decor is simple and cute. Highly recommend! Can't wait to try more! I'd give it a 9/10.

Awesome find! I had planned on taking my tasty Italian sub back to the hotel. Didn't realize they served alcohol until I arrived. So I ordered a cocktail while waiting, sat at the bar thinking I would be back on the road in 10. I struck up a conversation with the owner and her chief dishwasher-a local neighbor with an MBA who works for drinks. Super nice folks and great conversation. I snacked on my yummy Mac n cheese, bacon jalapeño bites and hung out for an hour enjoying the conversation.

Thankful for this place. Friendly staff and service with a smile. Can't beat that nowadays. Pizza was amazing and much better than franchise pizza. Ordered a veggie thin crust and it didn't disappoint. Even though I was just in the area for work, I like to try local small business food. This is the pizza you are looking for so you can stop the search! If I'm ever in the area again I will definitely order again for sure.

Pizza not that great, but sandwiches are good! Very bright inside, which takes away being ambiance for me, so we had take away

Great service and wonderful sandwiches! A hidden gem for sure! The bread they use is amazing

My mouth is watering thinking about this pizza place. We stopped in on Saturday and got a pizza and fried ravioli. You order at the counter and sit down. They will bring you all your yummy food. I really want to focus in on the pizza crust at this place because it is special. A light char to the crust and I like the chew of the bread. I mean if you put any toppings on it at all is up to you. I also like the crispness of the ravioli app we got. It had a yummy red sauce to dip the pieces in. I will be back soon!

Great place! Nice atmosphere, clean and great sandwiches. Nice to have nearby. Service was very good . Nice place to go!

Great service and a friendly atmosphere. I accidentally called 5 min before close, and they still made me a pizza!! 10/10 recommend!

One of my new underrated pizza locations in green bay! Will definitely go back. Originally got the thick crust and would like to try the thin