Italian Restaurants in Green Bay (2025)
Angelina Restaurant
Italian restaurant · Green Bay
A downtown stalwart since 1998 with handmade pastas, veal saltimbocca, and tiramisu served in a brick townhouse with a heated, retractable-roof patio. A perennial Best of the Bay winner and praised by the Green Bay Press-Gazette; a favorite of Packers players.
Mangiare
Italian restaurant · Green Bay
From the team behind Republic Chophouse, this refined-but-relaxed spot leans Northern Italian—think mezzaluna, brown-butter gnocchi, and thoughtful wine service. Covered by the Green Bay Press-Gazette and consistently praised by OpenTable diners for polished hospitality.
Luigi's Italian Bistro
Italian restaurant · Bellevue
Family-run on the east side, Luigi’s turns out stone-oven pies, hearty red‑sauce pastas, and old‑school breadsticks. Recent menus and hours verified through ordering platforms; locals applaud the friendly service and value.
Rustique Pizzeria
Pizza restaurant · Suamico
Set in a restored chapel, Rustique’s wood‑stone ovens power New York‑style pizzas and seasonal cocktails. Featured by Travel Wisconsin and Discover Green Bay, it’s a local favorite for date nights, pesto fries, and a singular sense of place.
Olive's Pizza and Sandwiches
Pizza restaurant · Allouez
A mom‑and‑pop with stone‑deck pies, hefty subs, and a second presence testing new ideas at The Cannery. Highlighted by WFRV Local 5 and Discover Green Bay, it’s a reliable pick for takeout with a personal touch.
Orsetta Craft Kitchen & Bar
Italian restaurant · De Pere
Chef‑owned and dinner‑only, Orsetta brings fresh pasta, sourdough‑crust pizza, and seasonal plates to downtown De Pere. Covered by NBC26 and Discover Green Bay, it reflects the city’s next generation of Italian cooking.
Jake's Pizza Green Bay
Pizza restaurant · Green Bay
A 50‑year Green Bay recipe, revived by two local sisters and celebrated by regional business press. Expect tavern‑style thin crust, house‑made sausage, and a convivial Broadway District vibe.
Pope's Pizza
Restaurant · Ashwaubenon
A 2025 addition near Lambeau Field inside Great North Commons, serving Sicilian and Neapolitan pizzas plus vodka rigatoni and a full bar. Covered by WBAY and NBC26, it’s already drawing pre‑game crowds.
Pasquale's International Cafe
Italian restaurant · De Pere
A retro De Pere institution blending Chicago‑Italian comfort—pasta, Italian beef, baked lasagna—with neighborhood personality and memorabilia. Recognized by Definitely De Pere and long trusted by locals for hearty portions and friendly service.
