Osteria 57

Italian restaurant · Greenwich Village

Osteria 57

Italian restaurant · Greenwich Village

57 W 10th St, New York, NY 10011

Highlights

Nestled in the heart of Greenwich Village, this cozy Italian gem boasts a rustic vibe, exceptional cocktails, and a delightful menu that’s perfect for intimate dinners or lively gatherings.

57 W 10th St, New York, NY 10011 Get directions

osteria57.com

@osteria57

Reserve

@eater

"A vegetarian Thanksgiving dinner is delivered to your home for $180 a ticket, with reheating instructions included. Appetizers include Brussels sprouts and kale salad; main courses are butternut squash lasagna, mushroom Wellington, stuffing, and two sides. Dessert is an apple tart. Pre-order until November 21 for Wednesday pickup." - Beth Landman, Eater Staff

Where to Eat on Thanksgiving in NYC

View Postcard for Osteria 57

@eater

"The Accademia Italiana della Cucina rates Italian restaurants in NYC for their “authenticity” of Italian cuisine on a scale of five to nine. No restaurants have reached nine, but some with an eight rating include Osteria 57 in Greenwich Village." - Stefanie Tuder

A $340 Private Helicopter Ride to Brunch at JFK’s TWA Hotel Exists - Eater NY

View Postcard for Osteria 57

@eater

"Pasta pomodoro can be easily underestimated. It’s something you can make at home in 15 minutes on a budget, or order off a kiddie menu, but grouping limp noodles in bland tomato sauce with an expertly crafted spaghetti or penne is like confusing a White Castle patty with Corner Bistro’s thick, juicy meat. The version at Osteria 57, a charming jewel box in the West Village with new chef Riccardo Orfino, uses wide ribbons of paccheri which makes the al dente pasta particularly satisfying." - Eater Staff

The Best Dishes Eater Editors Ate This Week, Spring 2019 - Eater NY

View Postcard for Osteria 57

Ivanna Kaleniuk

Google

This Italian restaurant offers a charming and secluded ambiance, perfect for a cozy meal. We booked a reservation for a group of 10-15 people after work on a Monday, and they accommodated us well, even rearranging furniture to seat us all in one room. The service was attentive, and the cocktails were truly exceptional—some of the best I’ve had in a while. They were so smooth that you only realize how strong they are when you stand up! However, the food left something to be desired. Despite the pasta being homemade, it tasted quite plain and didn’t stand out. The one dish that did impress me was the truffle ricotta, which was a delicious appetizer worth trying. In terms of pricing, it’s in line with the area—cocktails around $20 and main dishes about $30. Overall, it’s a great spot for drinks and a cozy atmosphere, but the food may not leave a lasting impression.

Juliette Groarke

Google

My friends took me for a graduation dinner and it was one of the best restaurants I’ve been to in NYC. The highest quality food I’ve seen and tasted thus far. Beautiful drinks and the best truffle ricotta bread. Everything was blowing my mind with the flavor and freshness. And I’ve tasted a lot. I would only advise with going for a lot of food because it was all so rich.

Julia Korabelska

Google

Absolutely wonderful place! The staff were very friendly, the food was incredible. Specifically the pasta was one of the best I’ve had in nyc! Never had crab meat pasta before and it was 🔥🔥🔥

Kavya Rajesh

Google

Went here for an early birthday dinner with my girls and had an excellent time. Definitely worth the money- ricotta toast and cacio e pepe were excellent. Loved the tiramisu, perfect texture and they put a candle on top!

Beau Chard

Google

This meal was a delight from start to finish. The ambiance inside is just spectacular and our server was fantastic and the food matched. We had 3 of the specials; truffle toast, ravioli in a lobster bisque, and a lobster pasta which was followed by a slice of cake. Could not recommend this more

Emily S

Google

I happened to stumble upon this place one night in the city and I’m so happy I did. My friend has a gluten intolerance and this is the perfect spot for her. The service was amazing. Everyone was very attentive and sweet. From the moment I walked in to the moment I left, I was very impressed. They were busy and still on top of everything. The salmon and truffle entrees were delicious. We did the truffle on gluten free pasta. Also, the cocktails were tasty and not too sweet. I will definitely be back!

Jasmine Williams

Google

A quaint and cozy Italian restaurant! The ambiance is nice. It's good for a date or to be with friends. It's more on the quiet side. They have warm houses if you want to dine outside. The service is great. The team is observant. The drinks and food come to the table fairly quickly. Everything was tasty. We tried the lobster dish and the black sea bass. The cauliflower app and the app with the calamari are also really good! I recommend this place!!

Noémie

Google

What a great find! This is such a cozy place with an intimate vibe. The food was delicious! I had the fusili with mushrooms and scallops and my friend had the cacio e pepe pasta. For dessert we ordered the tiramisu and millefoglie. Everything was very good and portions were just right! The staff were so friendly and were so apologetic when we were asked to move since another group had arrived for their reservation. I can appreciate a restaurant that respects reservation times! We gladly moved to the bar and had a great time there. I'll definitely be back!