Courtney L.
Yelp
In 2010, the "Rajun Cajun" at Other Coast Cafe was named one of the top five sandwiches in Seattle (per SeattleMag). While the award is a little dated, this item is still their number one seller, so it clearly continues to make quite the impression and I couldn't pass it up!
Four of us each ordered a sandwich to-go...three Rajun Cajuns ($12.25 each) and one Italiano ($11.75). For the time-being, they are offering take-out only and the inside of the restaurant is mostly blocked off except for the cashier's counter. There was a pretty steady stream of customers ordering inside the shop, but they also support online orders as well. It took about 25 minutes for our four sandwiches to be prepared which was definitely longer than expected, especially when we saw people who ordered after us receive their food first. Perhaps they had a ton of online orders, so I'll give them the benefit of the doubt here... at least the service was very friendly! Since this spot is located fairly close to the water, we took our sandwiches to Fisherman's Terminal and ate along the docks.
I will confess that I've never tasted a bolder sandwich with this one consisting of cajun turkey, pepper jack cheese, red onion, tomato and their special salsa mayo. The turkey was lean, cheese nicely melted and the punch of heat from the salsa mayo melded everything together. However, for $12.25, I did not consider this sandwich to be a good value. The ratio of bread to ingredients was pretty disproportionate, with the baguette making up the majority of each bite. While the thick bread acted like a sponge and absorbed the flavors, it could definitely have used another layer of turkey and a couple extra slices of tomato to balance it out.
Other Coast Cafe offers a generous variety of hot and cold sandwiches along with salads, so I'd likely opt for a different item if I were to return. I do believe the sandwiches here are made with quality ingredients and worthy of trying, but their Rajun Cajun just unfortunately did not live up to the hype for me. 3.75 stars.