Other Coast Cafe

Sandwich shop · First Hill

Other Coast Cafe

Sandwich shop · First Hill

1

721 E Pike St, Seattle, WA 98122

Photos

Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by Infatuation - Reviews
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null
Other Coast Cafe by null

Highlights

The Other Coast Cafe is a beloved Capitol Hill sandwich spot dishing out East Coast-style hoagies and rockin’ vibes that keep the crowds coming back.  

Featured in The Infatuation
Placeholder
Placeholder

721 E Pike St, Seattle, WA 98122 Get directions

othercoastcafe.com

$$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

721 E Pike St, Seattle, WA 98122 Get directions

+1 206 257 5927
othercoastcafe.com

$$ · Menu

Features

Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Mar 6, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

"The Other Coast Cafe is a casual sandwich counter serving the kind of meat, cheese, and sauce combinations college students doing all-nighters dream about. Like the Electric Wizard sandwich with ham, smoked fresh mozzarella, and balsamic mayo. If you actually are a college student pulling an all-nighter, know that they close at 9, so prepare accordingly." - Aimee Rizzo

The Other Coast Cafe Review - Capitol Hill - Seattle - The Infatuation
View Postcard for Other Coast Cafe

Michael Natkin

Google
Seattle used to be a crappy sandwich town, nothing like what you find on the east coast, but it has gotten much better and this place was one of the first to flip the script. Try the vegetarian chickpea salad sandwich, it is super satisfying. The vibe is Capitol Hill rock and roll, but clean and fast. Good place to order carryout from one of the delivery services too.

Mike Nemeth

Google
Just inside the Other Coast Cafe, the west wall is covered with event posters, the mood informal, people doing what they do on a drizzly day. Having memorized the menu and made our decisions on what we all wanted, my crew of six walked in and headed to the back. We piled into one of the booths, which had just been vacated and politely bused by the former occupants. My wife, Peggy, made the orders, including something special and bland for my picky first-grader grandson. We had parked just opposite Seattle University and went for a walking tour of Seattle's Capitol Hill to see how it had changed over the years. My son was the instigator. He had attended Seattle U. and loved the area. He kept pointing out the cranes and new construction. From my perspective, the entire district had undergone a pretty intensive transformation. The IHOP was there. My dad, sister and I went there for breakfast after church a number of times. I had attended St. James Cathedral's elementary school back in the 1960s. The church spires remain but not the school. Then I attended Seattle Central Community College. My wife attended, and graduated from the University of Washington, just a bus ride away. She had us take a picture of her in front of Neighbors. I remembered it. She had gone there to dance with friends during her college years. As we recounted these ancient memories, the boredom proved evident on the faces of our daughter and son. The grandkids thought we may have been speaking another language. Then the food arrived. It was marvelous. I got a soda, lemonade flavor, to accompany the Turkey Reuben. I'd never had one. I now forget what everybody had. But I do recall my string bean granddaughter, a third-grader, finishing all of her sandwich even though she said she was full. And the grandson voiced not a single complaint. My wife was happy. My son and daughter, too. I bit into the Reuben and felt like Guy Fieri on "Diner, Drive-Ins and Dives," which I occasionally watch on the Food Network and daydream of eating whatever massive meal he's got on the agenda. This was like that. So good. And I made a pig of myself eating the whole thing. A half would have been sufficient. My wife saved half of hers for the flight home to Fresno, Calif. We live in adjoining Clovis. We had spent five days hanging with family, hiking and wondering if the girl my son Calvin is pursuing will wind up a daughter in law. I snapped some photos with my Canon and asked the guy behind the counter about the name, Other Coast. He said something about it being opened in the tradition of an East Coast deli. I had very little experience with such things but did go to a Jewish deli in New York and treasure the memory. For more detail, I emailed the company and got connected to Emily Mabus, who owns the three Other Coast restaurants with husband, Dean Frazier. Their operation is truly worthy of its own story, full of comments from them and their customers and better pictures than the one I took. It has character. And original art on the walls. The works I saw looked to be inspired by the late Arturo Vega, Ramones artist and tour set builder and designer. Mabus said the original owner opened the original Ballard location in about 1999. She said Ballard "was not nearly as well healed as it appears now, and his approach to blue-collar type sandwiches fit in nicely." That original owner sold his business to another person who sold it to Mabus and Frazier in 2007. "Yes, right when the recession hit, but that's another story," Mabus wrote in an email. "We opened our Capitol Hill location on Nov. 4, 2010 -- just one days after National Sandwich Day. We took a former art gallery space and turned it into the restaurant you visited in just three months. Several of the employees that you may have seen this past weekend have been with us since we opened, and I do consider myself extremely fortunate to have such loyal employees."

Ali Tayyebi

Google
I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve eaten here. The staff are super friendly and are always playing cool music. There’s a rotating set of paintings and photos on the wall from different local artists, and the food is fantastic. Definitely try the Rajun Cajun!

Morgan Cesa

Google
Good sandwiches, but be warned-their “happy hour” seems to be a lie. We asked the employee behind the counter if happy hour was going on (they said yes) and what the happy hour specials were, and ordered one of each sandwich. After I sat down and looked at my receipt I realized they had charged me full price. I see others have had the same issue, so it seems to be a systematic issue and not just one person having an off day. (Especially since we had just confirmed what the deal was before ordering.) I probably won’t be going back.

NJI

Google
The Good: The Rajin Cajun sandwich was about as good a hot sandwich as I can remember eating. Soft, warm, spicy, flavorful and filling. I'm already looking forward to having another one. The Not So Good: First, the music was brutal. I don't expect to like the music at every business I walk into but this noisy hip hoppish stuff made me want to leave immediately. Secondly, we ordered, payed and sat down to wait for our food. At that time, we noticed the Happy Hour sign and realized that despite the fact that the sandwich and beer I ordered were both on the Happy Hour menu, neither was rung up at the discounted price. After mentioning this, the bill was corrected but it would not have been if I hadn't noticed the mistake myself. Overall: excellent sandwich but the music and service both need to be addressed.

Mark Guzman

Google
Truly great sandwiches, just overpriced. I don't normally order anything with "OUR MOST POPULAR!" next to it on the menu, but I made an exception for the rajun cajun and it was pretty great. I went on a Sunday afternoon during the farmer's market, and honestly don't know if I'll be back. They didn't have avocado on the menu (they have some sort of avocado relish that they charge for).

Crystal Jones

Google
This place is delicious. A little pricey but completely worth it🤤🤤🤤. Best BLT I've ever had, ever!

Joe Dailey

Google
I really enjoyed the sandwiches here. However, I have to give a low rating as the portion of undercooked chick in the middle of my sandwich gave me food poisoning with a side of acute internal bleeding. I ate there around noon last saturday and I'm still not myself by monday. I've got chills, nausea, and lower gut and kidney pain. I won't be going back.