Otto’s Ice Cream. Seasonal with Pop Up Openings! SEE OUR fb page for updated Info.

We stopped here on our way through the town. This little shop is incredibly adorable! The atmosphere is fun and playful. Everyone is happy and enjoying their time. They have games on the tables and a fun play area for the little ones! We brought our 40’ rv through the lot and the owners were incredibly welcoming and kind. The staff was happy and seemed to genuinely enjoy their job and they were so kind with their interactions with their customers and the children. The ice cream was very smooth and creamy and the waffle cones were fresh and crunchy with a hint of sweet just like they should be! I am so thankful that we got the chance to stop and visit and get this wonderful sweet treat! I will stop every time we pass this way!

I was pleasantly surprised when driving through this little town and I came upon this ice cream shop. It was definitely good enough to go out of your way to eat there. The staff on the inside was amazingly nice and the food was even better than that. I highly recommend sampling the ice cream before buying so that way you can get exactly what you're looking for. I can't say this enough "One of the best ice cream places I've ever had".

The decor from “Xmas in July” was still up so that was an awesome treat. Christmas trees decorated with lights, flocked with white cotton (snow), and ornaments that were simulated ice cream treats ! A disco ball to Enhance the ambiance. The store, inadvertently I’m sure, was all Barbie colors, pink and light blue, with tons of nostalgic items from the 60s,70s and 80s. Connectfour and Trouble games were on every other table as well as a Jenga game. Definitely worth the trip. The ice cream is sourced from a Wisconsin creamery, with over 50 flavors. With fun names like “Superman”, “This $h!t is about to get Real!” And “Munchie Madness” The owners and workers were sweet as pie and opened to and answered any questions you may have whether it’s about the store’s decor or the actual ice cream flavors. If you are driving through Lake Country in Indiana please stop in and treat yourself! 💪🍧💪 BUT YOU HAVE TO HURRY AS THEIR SEASON ENDS ON SATURDAY AUGUST 26th!!!

Awesome ice cream parlor. So many flavors to choose from. They are all delicious. They have low sugar options. I had the blue raspberry cheesecake with red raspberry and lemon italian ice. Oh my! It was excellent. The place looks like a 50s kitchen with the mint and pink colours. Will take debit and credit. Handicap entrance to the one side. They also have other treats like candies and chocolate.

Quite possibly the best ice cream I’ve ever had. They serve Chocolate Shoppe from WI. Found this gem passing through on a road trip. Service was friendly and fast. Highly recommend!

Soooooo many unique flavors to choose from! The icecream was excellent and the atmosphere is a fun throwback to the 50's! Really enjoyed our visit and will go there again soon!

Such a cute place! Went today for the Kate's kart event, and I got some bubblegum to take home, and strawberry cheesecake. Both were delish!

Loved this little small town ice cream place, they had probably about a dozen or more flavors, the two young ladies working there were great, friendly and professional. They have board games you could play while you eat your ice cream, as well as tetherball outside and other games. I highly recommend this place, stop by for sure if you are passing through or live close by.

Creamy delicious flavorful ice cream. MANY flavors and toppings to choose from and sample. Cute vintage decor as well. Very friendly staff

Ice cream was great and creamy, the place had a retro vibe to it with nice staff, also playground for the kids right outside of it

Wow seems like a nice nostalgic, ice cream place. Ordered Door County Cherry. Not only the Smallest dips ever seen and cherries were like ice crystals. No one in my group was impressed and see no reason to return. Service was good, nice people

Excellent Hand Dipped ice cream with MANY exotic flavors! Only bad part is we have to wait for summer to enjoy the love of this place! The ambiance is a 50's dinner with games for the whole family to play!

As a past extensive internationally touring member of Walter Trout Band I know a lot about ice cream! And if you fail to stop at Otto's then you have missed a real wonderful little American oasis. Get some vanilla.....although my wife says have "thisjustgotserious"

Best ice cream store in town with great service and a world class selection of flavors. These guys have it figured out well and I hope their store will become a huge success.

My friends and I first stopped here last Saturday when we were on an ice cream road trip. We discovered Otto's by accident and I just say, it has been the best experience we've ever had! We were delighted by the variety of flavors, including ice creams like "Exhausted Parent" (an espresso ice cream that is spiked with bourbon and contains bittersweet chocolate chunks), "Fat Elvis" (a banana and peanut butter ice cream), and my personal favorite "Snap-o-lantern" (pumpkin pie ice cream with ground cinnamon). We had such a great time, I brought my mom back with me so she could try it! The ice cream is delicious and made with real Wisconsin cream. The staff are friendly, the ice cream is delicious, and the inside of the store is decked out in a cute retro design. They have lots of older family games you can play at your table while you eat. This place is good for friends, family, or a date! 10/10 will definitely come back :D

Great staff. Great service. Unique atmosphere. We love taking our trips to Ottos and playing "vintage" board games!

We spotted Otto's on our way home from Chain o' Lakes state park a few weeks back. It has now become a tradition to stop on the way home from the beach. Cute little diner vibe, BEST ICE CREAM around the Fort Wayne area (my husband always gets seconds). Very family friendly, board games throughout the diner & outside has chalk & bubbles & more.