Paul M.
Yelp
I had very high expectations for this dining experience, and while it was quite good, I'd rate both The Pheasant in Dennis and the Water Street Kitchen in Woods Hole higher in terms of overall quality for the eye-opening price tag.
It was a Friday night during the off-season, so there wasn't much of a crowd. Our cocktails were served promptly - I had "The Lovers," a refreshing tequila drink with strawberry and passionfruit, while my wife had a spicy mezcal cocktail that I believe was called "The Smoke Show." As an appetizer, I had the escargot, which for me was the highlight of the meal. My wife had a potato and leek soup that was delicately seasoned and, in her words, "layered." As an entree, she had the Duck Cassoulet, a very interesting deconstruction of the classic dish with the beans served in a ceramic crock and the duck, pork belly and merguez sausage served on the side. I had a taste of the sausage, and it was quite good! I had the Icelandic Cod, which was nicely cooked and served on a bed of spinach and wild mushrooms. Given the price and the venue, I would have expected it to be more imaginatively seasoned.
We noticed that our waiter was engaged in conversation with what appeared to be his manager while we were waiting to order a glass of wine. He did come by eventually, but I wouldn't have expected that lapse of service in such a highly rated restaurant.
All in all I was glad to finally visit this restaurant considering that it's so close to us. While it didn't meet my elevated expectations, it was still first-rate.