DurShawn Robinson
Google
A Mixed Experience at Papi’s New Location
As a long-time supporter of Papi, I was excited to visit their new location at Proper Cuisine’s sister property. While the atmosphere and service were absolutely top-notch (10/10 for both!), the food didn’t quite meet the high expectations I’ve had over the years.
The Highlights:
Atmosphere & Service: Both were fantastic. The space is vibrant and inviting, and the service was friendly and attentive, making for a pleasant dining experience overall.
The Disappointments:
Jerk Lamb Chops: Unfortunately, the lamb chops were a letdown. The portion size was much smaller than I remember, and the flavor just didn’t hit the mark like it used to.
Kale: The kale was overly salty, which overshadowed its potential to be a flavorful side dish
Crab Fries: My husband’s crab fries were missing the “fixings” that were promised on the menu, which was a bit disappointing. While they were still edible, they didn’t have the full flavor profile I was expecting.
The Wins:
Honey Brussels Sprouts: On the bright side, the honey Brussels sprouts were on point and exactly what I was hoping for—crispy, sweet, and delicious.
Other Notes:
Parking: Parking can be a bit tricky, as it’s limited in the area. There is street parking available, as well as a nearby garage, but be prepared for potentially having to circle a bit for a spot.
While I’ve enjoyed these dishes for many years, today’s experience left me uncertain about returning anytime soon. I’ll likely give it another try, but I hope the kitchen finds its rhythm with these classic favorites.