Sweet & savory pies, pastries, cookies, cupcakes & scones


























"It’s in the name, so you know pies headline the menu here, but it’s not just the sweet ones that steal the show. In addition to selections like salted caramel apple, pecan, pumpkin, and apple pear cranberry pies, Petsi Pies also makes savory pies stuffed full of vegetables, chicken, cheese, and sometimes bacon. There are also vegan pies available." - Celina Colby

"A bakery known for both sweets and savory hand pies; the standout savory is a chicken hand pie (essentially a portable chicken pot pie) priced around $14, making it a satisfying, easy-to-eat option on the move." - Nadia Chaudhury

"Founder Renee McLeod has retired, but Petsi Pies is still going strong with classic fruit pies and seasonal offerings like ham and cheddar with tarragon potatoes and dijon; apple, pear, and cranberry; and chocolate bourbon pecan. Stop by for a slice of savory pie for a nice mid-day lunch, or grab a whole pie to take home and share (or not)." - Julian Cohen, Eater Staff


"Petsi Pies is offering a variety of 10-inch holiday pies ($30–$32 each) intended to feed six to eight — flavors include peppermint chocolate cream and pumpkin praline — with smaller five-inch pies starting at $8 for one to two people and several vegan pies available; order online by December 20 for pickup December 16 through 31." - Rachel Leah Blumenthal
"We’re not sure why, but we’ve never really been pie people. Then again, we didn’t grow up with the salted caramel apple, sweet potato pecan, or roasted broccoli and caramelized garlic ones from Petsi Pies either. Having any number of slices here is a revelatory experience, not unlike the first time we tried aerial yoga after a Blood Mary-heavy brunch. Yeah, we’ll just leave it at that." - Joel Ang