Janie D.
Yelp
Ancestral Chilean cuisine, beautifully presented in a series of refined tasting menus. As visitors to Chile, my boyfriend and I were thrilled to eat here. Having the opportunity to enjoy unique ingredients and preparations of the indigenous cultures of pre-Hispanic Chile seemed truly special. Reservations are strongly recommended, and can be made online.
The interior is beautiful, with interlaced wooden beams, native art pieces, and an earth tone color palate. The lighting was inconsistent-some tables were brightly lit, while others (like ours) was completely in shadow. It was so dark that it was difficult to see the food (my photos are heavily edited). The acoustics were echoey and the bar seemed to be continuously running a blender, which was also distracting.
You may order from their a la carte menu, or choose from 4 different tasting menus-Land, Sea, Vegetarian, or Mixed (a combination of the 3). Great wine and cocktail list. We enjoyed a few pours by the glass as well as a Pisco Sour, which was fantastic. I got the Vegetarian and my boyfriend got the Mixed, and we both found the food to be hit and miss.
The first amuse-bouche, a grain cracker with mushroom topped with fresh salsa, was flavorful and fresh. Next were fried seaweed sticks, which tasted only of oil. The breads course was fascinating, consisting of rare varieties I had never heard of. Unfortunately, less than half of them were enjoyable to eat. One tasted like raw flour, and two others tasted like bland mashed potatoes. My favorite was the Po'e, a sweet banana bread from Easter Island.
The appetizer, entree, and dessert courses all consist of a variety of small bites, artfully plated on rectangular wooden boards. We were instructed to eat from left to right. The appetizer course began with squash stuffed with a salty cheese and topped with roasted red onion, which was delicious. I also enjoyed the center dish, a tangy causeo with fried yucca. The mushroom pate and bread tasted burnt, and the seaweed salad was inedible. It had no flavor whatsoever, and a terrible gummy texture. The fried eggplant sticks were overcooked and oily.
The star of the entree course was delicate, savory chocolate sauce, served with berries atop pumpkin, potato, and eggplant. Earthy and rich with balanced sweetness, every bite was a treat. Major points for originality here-this dish was unlike anything I have tasted before. The cylinder of pastry dough stuffed with mushroom was tasty, but the lentil and quinoa croquettes and chimichurri were bland and boring.
None of the desserts were good, apart from the wine ice cream, which had a lovely sweet port flavor. The chocolate cake was dry and mealy, and the pineapple panna cotta was pedestrian. The worst was the chochoca with seaweed jam, which was absolutely disgusting. I love seaweed, but the ocean does not belong in dessert.
Two tasting menus, three glasses of wine, and a cocktail came to 75,000 pesos (about $130 USD). Service was friendly and did a good job of explaining the menu, in perfect English. While we enjoyed the novelty of our meal, I cannot recommend Peumayén.