Pinky Ring Pizza
Pizza restaurant · Madison ·
Pistachio pesto, fig, lamb, pickle & ricotta pizzas, non-alcoholic drinks
Pistachio pesto, fig, lamb, pickle & ricotta pizzas, non-alcoholic drinks
"Technically, Pinky Ring is located in Madison, but the pies here are so good, they merit a mention. Don Hernandez’s pie shop is in a former Sir Pizza location tucked inside a strip mall. Here, the kitchen churns out 18-inch pies like the Fig & Pig with both white and fig sauce, and the Madison Pickle with daikon pesto, mozzarella, smoked provolone, dill pickles, Calabrian chili, garlic, and ranch. The small patio is great for sipping on the non-alcoholic (and alcoholic) drink selections." - Ellen Fort
"Pinky Ring is a tiny shop in Madison that makes nearly perfect pizza. Each mammoth slice is an expert blend of sauces and toppings, and a good rule of thumb here is if it’s got ricotta on it, get it. Especially if it’s the Madtown, with meatballs sliced like pepperonis and tiny peppadew-like peppers. We’re also big fans of the New Haven Red pie and the Madison Hot Pickle, with white sauce and smoked provolone. No matter what you get, the crust will be heartbreakingly tender, and the toppings are always treated with precision. They’ve got a cute little takeout window, but this pizza deserves to be eaten as fresh as can be, so we prefer sitting at their counter, especially for the two-slice special during lunch." - ann walczak
"Pinky Ring is a tiny shop in Madison that makes nearly perfect pizza. Each mammoth slice is an expert blend of sauces and toppings, and a good rule of thumb here is if it’s got ricotta on it, get it. Especially if it’s the Madtown, with meatballs sliced like pepperonis and tiny peppadew-like peppers. We’re also big fans of the New Haven Red pie and the Madison Hot Pickle, with white sauce and smoked provolone. No matter what you get, the crust will be heartbreakingly tender, and the toppings are always treated with precision. They’ve got a cute little takeout window, but this pizza deserves to be eaten as fresh as can be, so we prefer sitting at their counter, especially for the two-slice special during lunch." - Ann Walczak
"Wedged into a strip mall parking lot behind a Subway, this unassuming pizza parlor turns out 18-inch New York–style pies that could make Manhattan’s top pizzaiolos weak in the knees. Offerings lean unconventional, with standouts including the Esmerelda, featuring pistachio pesto, fig preserves, and charred lamb flank, and the Bianca, which tops a ricotta base with locally grown oyster mushrooms. The real feat of nature, however, is the pickle pizza, which pairs slivers of kosher dill pickles with toasted garlic, ricotta cream, smoked provolone, and ranch. Recently, the kitchen crew has been experimenting with a plussed-up variation called the “Hot Matty.” Chef David Bonner, Jr., inspired by a cluster of daikon radish sprouts growing on the counter, whipped up a daikon-feta pesto and amped up the heat using a healthy hit of Calabrian chiles. It sounds bizarre; it tastes sensational. The sweet-hot-savory flavor is loosely reminiscent of Nashville’s famous hot chicken sandwich. “If you think about it, a pizza is really just an exhibitionist panino,” says chef David Paternostro. Attention to detail is what makes this unlikely flavor combination sing. Wes Scoggins, Pinky Ring’s founding executive chef (who sometimes goes by the Jewish Cowboy), uses two wild starters in his 48-hour-aged dough: One hails from Bootleg Biology, a local Nashville fermentation lab, and one is collected by Jester King, the pioneering Texas brewery known for their spontaneously fermented ales. The pickles (as well as the restaurant’s banana peppers and giardiniera) bathe in a house mother vinegar. And that ranch dressing? It begins by soaking Parmigiano-Reggiano rinds in heavy cream until they liquify, which Wes’s brother and kitchen-overseer, Kameron Scoggins, does in-house, along with the help of the team. The umami-packed elixir then gets a shower of fresh herbs, plus a blend of marigolds, borage, and other edible flower blossoms. According to the chefs, the brightly speckled mixture initially resembles a bowl of Fruity Pebbles. It’s a “ranch” so good, regulars know to ask for a side for dunking, regardless of what pizza they’ve ordered. Know Before You Go To avoid waiting for your pizza at peak dining hours, call ahead to order, then simply tear open your box on the picnic benches. Owner Don Hernandez, a restaurant and bar industry veteran who is sober, made sure that there’s also an excellent selection of non-alcoholic drinks available." - rachelrummel
Abe and S.
Binh N.
frank A.
Aaron Y.
Kerrie B.
Jackie B.
Catherine P.
Joshua L. G.
Nina H.
Dylan P.
Jay G.
Becky Y.
Simone G.
Codie W.
Lillian K.
Alyssa M.
Mark B.
Arthur B.
Mae D.
Laura R.
Connor S.
Erin C.
Hank D.
David S.
Michelle T.
Christina B.
Be G.
Kristina M.
Amber B.
Erick M.
Pamela D.
Mike Z.
Lina R.
Steve B.
Dagan B.
Brian D.
Matt A.
Marlo G.
Phil M.
Kelle F.
Tracy D.
Tommy B.
Annika S.
Ayana N.
Rick M.
Lisa A.
Faith S.
Laura K.
Matthew S.
Britne D.
Shawna O.
Carolyn A.
Maric S.
Kimberley M.
LD615 _.
Christal J.
Renee C.
Tyeisha G.
