Pizzeria Sirenetta

Italian restaurant · Upper West Side

Pizzeria Sirenetta

Italian restaurant · Upper West Side

3

568 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024

Photos

Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by Infatuation - Reviews
Pizzeria Sirenetta by @TheInfatuation
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null
Pizzeria Sirenetta by null

Highlights

Italian eatery serving wood-fired pizzas & rustic pastas in a casual, contemporary space.  

Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in Grub Street
Placeholder

568 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024 Get directions

pizzeriasirenetta.com
@sirenettanyc

$$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

568 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024 Get directions

+1 212 799 7401
pizzeriasirenetta.com
@sirenettanyc
𝕏
@Sirenetta_NYC

$$ · Menu

Features

delivery
takeout
dine in
reservations

Last updated

Mar 5, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

"The pizzas at this UWS spot have thin, crispy crusts with toppings like clam and crumbled sausage, and they’re the perfect size for when you want to eat a full 360 degrees of pie by yourself. Each costs around $20 - but during Happy Hour (from 5-7pm), a few are $12, and there are discounted drinks and small plates as well. If you want to take advantage of this, get here on the early side, since seats fill up quickly. Your parents think you finish work at 5pm anyway." - Hannah Albertine

20 Great Restaurants For A Casual Dinner With Your Parents - New York - The Infatuation
View Postcard for Pizzeria Sirenetta
@infatuation

"Pizzeria Sirenetta is from the same people behind The Mermaid Inn (which is right next door), and the pizzas here are some of the best in the neighborhood. They have thin, crispy crusts with toppings like clam and crumbled sausage, and they’re the perfect size for when you want to eat a full 360 degrees of pie by yourself. They’re all around $20 - but during happy hour (from 5-7pm), a few are $12, and there are discounted drinks and small plates as well. If you want to take advantage of this, get here close to 5pm, since seats fill up quickly." - Bryan Kim

The Best Places To Have Dinner For Around $30 On The Upper West Side - New York - The Infatuation
View Postcard for Pizzeria Sirenetta
@infatuation

"Pizzeria Sirenetta is a pizza place on the Upper West Side from the same people behind The Mermaid Inn. Each pie here is large enough to feed one person for dinner, and there are also a few pastas and mains (like veal milanese), plus a perfectly good kale salad and a bunch of other small plates. Get a table in the little dining room, or sit on the front patio when they open up their big garage-door windows in the summertime. While this place doesn’t quite crack our top-20 pizza list, you should still be eating here if you live in the neighborhood - and do your best to stop by at Happy Hour, when all the pizzas are $12.50 and a few drinks are discounted as well." - Bryan Kim

Pizzeria Sirenetta Review - Upper West Side - New York - The Infatuation
View Postcard for Pizzeria Sirenetta

Aria Ni

Google
We had a 3pm reservation (Sunday) . Modern, classy but casual decor set for a great ambiance. There weren't many people when we arrived but the crowd picked up a bit later when we were leaving. Mixed crowd, from couples, friends to families with young children. Medium sized space, no tables were set to hold more than four people but it seems as though larger parties could definitely be accommodated.. Concise menu but a variety of great options. Take a look at the menu before hand because I do not think you are allowed substitutions. Our server was great! The persons at the table next to ours asked a myriad of questions (some even twice), and he answered every one showing great deal of patience and genuine helpful attitude. Food was superb! Very flavorful. The pizza was definitely the best part; you could taste every single fresh ingredient and spice with out any over powering the other. Finished off with some complimentary panna cotta (one of the best I've had). Over all great experience.

Jana Chams

Google
It can be for a romantic dinner date, catching up with a friend dinner or an amazing brunch place. It’s delicious and light. Although it is always packed, I always seem to find a table for 2 when I walk in. Make sure you check their opening hours before you go there ! I always get: Salami Pizza 🍕

Serhei Baranouski

Google
We’ve been ordering from them every Friday (our family’s Pizza Friday tradition!) for over a year. We’ve always enjoyed the food and service at the restaurant (manager Sydney is super nice and customer focused) but the food delivered has been pretty bad often.Tonight we received burned pizzas and my toddler Could not eat but a slice of it. The “roasted” potatoes that came with our chicken were clearly reheated and inedible. All around a disappointing meal.

Q Lim

Google
This is my fav date spot with my husband. We come here often whenever we crave their fennel sausage pizza. Great service and they have an awesome happy hour deal! easy to make reservations. We love their broccoli rabe but one time it was extremely salty but they remade it for us right away.

Peter Falco

Google
Good place to go with a small group and share plates. The waitstaff was attentive. The drink menu has some inspired choices. The food wasn't too inventive, but was tasty.

Lisa Kim

Google
Great pizza. Love the atmosphere. Food was great, service was nice.

Michael Sin

Google
Service was great but food was so so. Presentation was on point. The pasta was inedible salty and we had to send it back - both of our dishes. Our server was apologetic and we got our replacements right away. The replacements were not salty but they didn’t taste particularly good either. I don’t think the chef tasted either pasta dishes before sending them out. For apps we got the prosciutto and meatballs. Meatballs were so so. Prosciutto was really good but since they didn’t make it but just sliced it, it doesn’t count in the restaurant’s benefit. The bread was really good though. Ambiance was really nice but probably wouldn’t come back

Quang Nguyen

Google
Kind of expensive for what this place offers. The type of pizza serve is not as good as some other places that does the same. The ambiance and atmosphere was pleasant though.