Andy H.
Yelp
A recovering alcoholic living near PJ's is like a recovering overeater living next to a 24 hour bodega, an all you can eat buffet, and like eighteen McDonaldses. It's way more a matter of "when" than "if."
Uptown oenophile? Saints be praised! A whole massive wall in this cavernous flourescent warehouse is devoted to the stuff, from the boxed variety on up. (And those prices! $20 for a Caymus Conundrum? Heck yes!) There are plenty of additional racks devoted to the higher end vino too, and come on people, if a more hoity toity chic feeling than buying off the racks at PJ's is to be found north of Dyckman, I have not yet experienced it. On weekends and some weeknights, be on the lookout for the diplomatic wine staff wandering about if you need a suggestion. This can be tricky because they don't wear nametags, but I've found they're good spotters of indicisive faces.
Booze? Got that too, and got it in spades. Even got a fancy schmancy cache of ridiculously high end hooch behind glass and under lock and key just past the check out lines. It's easy to walk past seeing as you've just paid and are making a bee line out the door, but it's worth a stop if only to ogle and dream.
DOWNSIDES:
* No beer.
* Not a ton in the way of mixers. Well, okay, they have aperitifs and the like, but who seriously needs that much vermouth? And they don't have bitters. Bitters!
* Frequent appearances of bar people buying liquor in bulk and surreptitiously paying in cash in order to avoid wholesale prices at their places of business. Doesn't affect my shopping experience other than holding up the line a bit, but it's annoying.
* Multiple free wine and liquor samples on Friday and Saturday nights. Oh, wait, no, that's absolutely not a downside.