Adam S.
Yelp
I imagine that there are some polarized opinions when it comes to the newly renovated Pop's. In San Francisco, and especially in The Mission, the debate over gentrification is practically as heated as debates about religion in the 1500's. Granted, we don't see much burning at the stake, but you rarely find opinions that are not pretty set on one side or the other. Most will either welcome the changes to Pop's or despise them.
"Pop's, Before": I came exactly one time. It was 12:30pm on a Saturday. I was a bit hung-over (Maybe a bit more than a bit) and had to use the bathroom. Those were the only reasons I stopped in: Hangover Remediation and a Bathroom. This was a Super-Divey place. Dark, dank, rough around the edges. I probably wouldn't have stayed for more that my Pit-Stop and one Cheap Beer, but (see the original review) I found out that people actually put Bacon in Bloody Mary's. I won't lie - for all the dark-ness and dank-ness, for all "go-the-f-back-to-suburbia" this place had to offer... They crushed the Bloody. This thing was killer.
"Pop's, After": If the sign on the door hadn't said Pop's when I walked in, there is no way I would have believed this was the same place. The place has been turned classy. It's like Rocker Tommy Lee turned into Realtor Phil Dunphy. It's now a nice, although not super-pretentious, neighborhood bar. You can take a look at the new photos - if you remember what it once looked like, you'll be stunned. They still had the Bacon Bloody, but it wasn't quite the same. Again, check out my photo vs. some of the originals from "Pop's, Before". The service was nice, the crowd was not much different than a place like R Bar in the Tendernob (yeah yeah, I know some of you think that place is much more fratty than it really is, a la Wreck Room).
So, what is the real analysis? Was it better to have the edgy, divey, f-the-squares joint? Is it better to have another perfectly affable spot with daylight and nice finishes? We've endured another Neil Young to Neil Diamond transformation. But, such is life in SF. I don't know what the answer is, but I know in SF that this is something that is a fact of life, writ large. For what it's worth, I think they did a nice job. Had I not known "Pop's, Before", I would have found this to be a nicely-finished neighborhood spot that was friendly and had good service. But, there is a little something in my "go-the-f-back-to-suburbia" soul that reminds me that eventually, suburbia can swallow you up and turn you into everyone else. And trust me, I grew up in Golden Valley, Minnesota.
If there's a moral of the story, it's that times change. Often times progress is good - but it is worth thinking about what won't be anymore. Some of the change is colored by nostalgia. But, I wonder what exactly we lose...