Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Sandwich shop · Midtown West

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Sandwich shop · Midtown West

1

19 W 45th St Suite 104, New York, NY 10036

Photos

Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by Infatuation - Reviews
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null
Potbelly Sandwich Shop by null

Highlights

This retro counter-serve gem in Midtown dishes out made-to-order toasted sandwiches and salads, all in a chill, friendly vibe that welcomes groups.  

Featured in The Infatuation
Placeholder
Placeholder

19 W 45th St Suite 104, New York, NY 10036 Get directions

potbelly.com

$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

19 W 45th St Suite 104, New York, NY 10036 Get directions

+1 917 595 1141
potbelly.com

$ · Menu

Features

delivery
takeout
reservations

Last updated

Jul 19, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Review - New York - The Infatuation

"Is it the name? Is that why it isn’t that busy here? Or is it because people stopped eating 500-calorie sandwiches in favor of 800-calorie salads? If you’re in Midtown, and you don’t want to deal with a huge line at lunchtime, hit up Potbelly. If there’s any sort of wait, an employee will go down the line and start taking orders. And once you tell them what you want, they’ll ask if you want bacon - at which point two timelines will stretch out before you: a life with bacon and a life without. Also, the toaster here is fun to watch. And definitely add bacon. We haven’t been here yet, but want you to know this spot exists." - Team Infatuation

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/potbelly-sandwich-shop
View Postcard for Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Poonam Rai

Google
Excellent sandwiches. My fav is Mediterranean chicken and broccoli cheddar soup. The line gets pretty long during lunch hour so I always order through app. Their cookies are good too.

Mark

Google
Was here with a group of 18. They cheered when we entered, made us feel welcome, and ensured our orders were perfect. Dawn was especially kind and helpful. Friendliest place in NYC.

Nicolas Jacobi

Google
I love Potbelly. Sandwiches and Dreambars are awesome and the staff is always extremely well skilled. This location is definitely less busy than others.

ej shortell

Google
This is a basic sandwich shop. Choose the type of bread you want for your made to order sandwich. Then choose the filling, toppings, dressings or other condiments. All for around $6. Choose a drink and side if you want. The service is very friendly. The sandwiches are tasty. Good place to go, if you are in the area. Take lunch back to the office. Reasonably priced.

Gerald Acevedo

Google
The sandwiches are good, but their delivery guy James Smith is fantastic! Totally cool guy, very kind and respectful and very easy to talk to, hoping to see him again when I get my next delivery! A++

Patrick Flanagan

Google
Hot delicious sandwiches that don't break your budget. You'll be glad you came. The only thing I almost forgot to mention was that they have many nick nacks on the walls that give the place a fun friendly atmosphere. There was an old school metal lunch box sitting on the counter that was just like the kind I took to school only mine was a Tarzan one. I guess they were using it to hold gift cards or coupons or promotional items. But when I was there it was empty and quite filthy. I wasn't going to say anything. But now that I know they actually read these reviews...

Abigail Smith

Google
Ordered here with a big group and the food came on time. Though we were a bit disappointed that the skinny menu was not available. The food was yummy and hot. There were no utensils in the order though so I had to eat salad with a spoon which was challenging.

Kevin Neighbor

Google
Wife and daughter liked the sandwiches. They let me and other daughters bring in food and eat w them and were so nice. Both employees that were working couldnt have been nicer. Great place.