Maura G.
Yelp
I have to admit, I was disappointed when I ordered here. Maybe it's a better experience eating in but, after a couple of years ordering 2-3 times a week from one of their sister restaurants (42 North), I expected more, based on the high bar set by 42 North. Before leaving the Manomet area, the friendly staff at 42 assured me that the menu at P-10 was nearly the same so I'd have my go-to's every time I ordered at P-10.
I moved recently and had P-10 in my sights from day one since I was unpacking so slowly, and I had nothing to cook with! The menu items all sounded good, just a bit different from what I had become accustomed to. I eat a lot of salmon and in five visits here, I kept ordering the salmon done medium- but it was always well done to the point of dry and flavorless. I did like the steak tips, they have a nice marinade on them, but again, always cooked to medium well/well. And the Wedge salad was pretty good- again, not up to the bar set by 42 North, but tasty with a delicious dresssing added. One thing that bugged me was there's supposed to be "bacon" on this salad, and it really seemed like fake bacon bits- and salty.
The chain has a blue cheese salad dressing that you could add to cardboard and it would still be delicious, so on the Wedge salad it's deelish! But, I always order the tips rare and without fail they were done medium well to well. Every single time. That's a chef thing, cooking the protein too long and thanks, but I know what I like, you don't!
Anyway, there are other restaurants in my new neighborhood that I'm discovering, so P-10 will unfortunately go on the back burner for now, since as much as I wanted it to be my go-to, it's not going to be on the regular.